frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

How to Fix the Gaming Industry

2•azyLum•8h ago
Hey everyone! For some time now, I have been observing how some practices in the gaming industry are increasingly moving away from the interests of players.

So I decided to collect the most common pain points and put them in the form of a simple, clear “Gaming Industry Consumer Bill of Rights.” These are 12 principles that, in my opinion, should become the standard if we want a fairer and more transparent market. I have tried to approach the subject sensibly, from a player’s perspective, but also without hostility towards creators.

Share your thoughts – what would you change, add, or remove?

§1. Prohibition on remastering young games A remaster/remake may be released no sooner than 8 years after the original's release.

§2. Prohibition on deleting original versions of games after the release of a remaster/remake. The original must still be available in digital distribution.

§3. The remaster must contain the original. By purchasing the remaster, the player must have access to the original version of the game in the library.

§4. Discount for owners of the original. The player receives a discount on the remaster/remake if they bought the original at least 6 months before the official announcement, the first official information or a leak informing about the production of the new version. Publishers cannot announce remasters/remakes earlier than 12 months before they reach their minimum age (i.e. 7 years after the premiere of the original)

§5. Prohibition of announcing DLC before the game's release. Additions may only be announced after the base game's release.

§6. DLC Price Limit. DLC cannot cost more than 50% of the base game price. If it costs more, it must be considered a separate game and meet the full requirements.

§7. Micropayments are prohibited in single-player games. Unless they are full-fledged story add-ons. Skins, boosters, currencies should be prohibited.

§8. Prohibition of manipulation of fictitious currency. Each item in the game must show the price in real currency. The conversion rate must be constant in all packages. The player must be able to buy the exact amount of fictitious currency needed to buy a given item

§9. Prohibition of depriving access to paid games. A game that was paid for must remain available for download and launch.

§10. Obligation to provide a date for shutting down servers in paid online games. The date must be known on the day of release. It can be updated, but no more than once every 6 months.

§11. Marking of games dependent on DLSS/FSR/FG. Games that do not work well without these technologies must receive a special mark warning players about poor optimization until the problem is fixed. The mark will be awarded on the basis of a mandatory pre-release game test by a specially designated group.

§12. Mandatory free demo of games. Every game costing more than $50 must have a free demo with at least 10% of content. The demo cannot be removed after the game's release

Let me know what you think.

Comments

scantis•8h ago
Laws and regulation should never be to specific. You give very specific guidelines and times, such as 8 years, 50% of etc.

Principles would be formulated differently. I'd prefer something along the lines like:

Before remastering, let a game mature.

Cherish the initial release, archive it and keep it available.

Take care when remastering a game, to be true to the original, include a switch in the options if possible.

Etc.... maybe improved wording.

Lionga•32s ago
Laws and regulation would be much better if they were specific. It is just that people making laws and regulation are usually too lazy to do so or just want to be able to interpret them how ever they want afterwards.
eimrine•7h ago
This is not bill of rights, but a bill of musts. I do not play games, I use to read books but nothing from your 1-12 can make the market better. Imagine skyrocketing the prices for games because of game companies has to hire more layers each layer having expertise in different counries. Imagine having even more regulations than we have today in many many industries, how many industries left which do not require a layer eventually?
szszrk•5h ago
I would gamify workarounds for each of your points like it's a speedrun of Mario. These are typical low quality laws. You prohibit things randomly with good intentions and low focus on how this would be abused.

This just makes it way harder for small studios to operate, you tell them how to make business, you seem to know in advance what players want and what they don't.

1 - I would release a half baked game very early, then push basic content as DLCs for years and remake 2 years after "initial release". Or simply call it an Specific Hardware Targeted Port and release it 6 months after, by adding some crap like better accelerated shadows.

2 - as above. Original will be mostly useless.

5 - since the "initial release" is now just a random alpha demo, I have all the time I need to announce DLCs

6 - easy, my base prices will be 500 USD, I will aggressively discount. Like a Telco operator.

7 - I would make sure to break single-player game definition. Is Death Stranding single or multiplayer? I'd do something similar.

...

Ask HN: What's behind the strong anti-AI sentiment on Hacker News?

5•cloudking•2h ago•19 comments

Tell HN: The Hetzner Experience - Invisible Outages

20•AmazingTurtle•7h ago•10 comments

Ask HN: Does the languages we speak affect the way we think?

2•Genius_um•3h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Do people actually pay for small web tools?

48•scratchyone•2d ago•54 comments

How to Fix the Gaming Industry

2•azyLum•8h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: When do you just give up and ship it?

11•90s_dev•12h ago•6 comments

I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney, who does work for YC and startups. AMA

253•proberts•3d ago•451 comments

Ask HN: Don't You Mind That LLMs Are Mostly Proprietary?

9•dakiol•16h ago•12 comments

Big Beautiful Bill R&D Tax: Will tech go on a hiring spree again?

13•jbverschoor•1d ago•14 comments

Ask HN: How do you use AI for development in high security environments?

6•thesurlydev•18h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Is there a Wikipedia or LLM wrapper for kids (with parental controls)?

4•soferio•13h ago•6 comments

Ask HN: What's your go-to message queue in 2025?

58•enether•5d ago•96 comments

Ask HN: We built a travel app – a classic tarpit idea. What now?

4•kenforthewin•21h ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Conversational AI to Learn a Language

14•edweis•3d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: How do you handle licensing and revenue leaks for self-hosted software?

3•lexokoh•21h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Tech Behind the "Magic" Company?

4•ChicagoBoy11•22h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: When will managers be replaced by AI?

53•GianFabien•11h ago•71 comments

What interesting things low spending people do, that others know nothing about?

14•evolve2k•1d ago•33 comments

Ask HN: Anyone working in traditional ML/stats research instead of LLMs?

20•itsmekali321•3d ago•10 comments

Ask HN: Best on device LLM tooling for PDFs?

4•martinald•1d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Moving to London from California

12•siamese_puff•1d ago•13 comments

Ask HN: Do you have a side project making more than $100 monthly?

12•leonagano•1d ago•4 comments

Is current state of querying on observability data broken?

12•pranay01•2d ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What newsletters do you follow?

5•cyndunlop•20h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: Email Provider for Main Account?

24•agent008t•5d ago•27 comments

Best AI editor for local models?

7•rocketbro•3d ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How do you store the knowledge gained in a day?

67•dennisy•6d ago•95 comments

Xray: A full-behavior-chain anti-malware system built in Go by a student

6•tangtian•3d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How do you store private keys?

7•max_•3d ago•16 comments