frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

Are we building AI coding assistants wrong?

2•anaempromptu•19h ago
The Jason Lemkin/Replit incident this week got me thinking about the fundamental problems with how we're approaching AI coding assistants. We've all seen the demos - natural language to working code, conversational debugging, "just describe what you want." But then you hit prod and everything breaks down.

The core technical challenges I keep seeing:

- Context management at scale - These systems work great for isolated tasks but struggle to maintain coherent state across complex, multi-file projects. How do you handle context that spans thousands of lines across dozens of files?

- The safety/capability tradeoff - More powerful tools can do more damage. Replit promised not to touch production, then deleted a database anyway. How do you build guardrails that actually work without neutering the tool?

- Conversational interfaces for complex systems - Natural language is ambiguous. Code is precise. Are we trying to solve the wrong interface problem?

- The production gap - Every AI coding tool I've tested works beautifully in demos and falls apart with real codebases, real data, real edge cases. Why is this gap so persistent?

I'm genuinely curious - has anyone built AI apps with tools that actually work reliably in prod?

Comments

moomoo11•19h ago
As with anything, complexity becomes the limiting factor.

Anyone can drive. Some even have cars that drive themselves. Very few people can drive Formula 1.

They're also totally different - getting from A to B vs competing on a track.

I think its easier than ever for total n00bs to build software. Its on them to use the same AI that did everything for them to figure out how to scale their software add features, maintainability, testing, and organizational efficiency.

You put the same AI workflows into the hands of someone that was a exceeds expectations tier engineer or someone highly motivated like that, and they'll push it even farther on the most complex systems.

Just need to know the limits, the opportunities, and go wild.

lgl•19h ago
Isn't the main reason the split between dev, stage and prod exactly to weed out these sorts of issues?

An incompetent/distrated/etc dev can do just as much damage as an AI on these cases.

Just dont blindly give prod access to any entity.

anaempromptu•12h ago
most AI coding tools don't have this option or does it mention it as a "must have"

Ask HN: How will the OSA affect small Mastadon instances?

9•Digit-Al•1h ago•1 comments

Claude Code weekly rate limits

569•thebestmoshe•19h ago•647 comments

Ask HN: Does Claude AI run locally?

2•kvthweatt•2h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: What are you working on? (July 2025)

251•david927•1d ago•814 comments

Have We Stopped Inventing Futures Worth Predicting?

4•squarekernels•5h ago•1 comments

How do I get a paid internship as a 16yo developer?

8•uint23•12h ago•18 comments

Drafting Software Recommendation

15•morpheos137•4d ago•16 comments

Warp.dev Terminal – Overpriced, Buggy, and AI-Sabotaged My Code

53•MistermanX•1d ago•37 comments

Ask HN: How many of you are working in tech without a STEM degree?

51•zebproj•6d ago•77 comments

My Theory: Advertising is a lot like capitalism itself

8•cm2012•18h ago•10 comments

Ask HN: Has your opinion on AI changed over the past year?

4•atleastoptimal•15h ago•11 comments

Ask HN: Is there any LLM provider that is GDPR compliant?

6•pera•16h ago•1 comments

Are we building AI coding assistants wrong?

2•anaempromptu•19h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: How do you handle audit logs in your systems?

16•efeoge•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Have you ever waited for a project to be launched but it never did?

3•alganet•20h ago•3 comments

How to prioritize marketing when attribution is broken and AI is changing rules?

3•ivanmarketingua•1d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: What is Lex Fridman's association with MIT?

11•chirau•10h ago•7 comments

Ask HN: Do You Block DigitalOcean?

11•sugarpimpdorsey•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Will I get left behind if I don't jump on AI train?

21•LLcolD•2d ago•32 comments

Ask HN: How do you build B2B software that pays living expenses?

10•architectofsw•1d ago•7 comments

Ask HN: Why do Cursor, Windsurf and Claude Code dominate the conversation?

28•bluelightning2k•1w ago•38 comments

Ask HN: What is so good about MCP servers?

43•metadat•4d ago•38 comments

FreeToolSuite – 200 growing collection of genuinely useful free online tools

25•mviradia•2d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: Are we pretending RAG is ready, when it's barely out of demo phase?

11•TXTOS•2d ago•10 comments

Ask HN: Discrete Mathematics Preriquisites for Data Structures?

3•shivajikobardan•2d ago•1 comments

I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA

164•proberts•1w ago•266 comments

Ask HN: What's your uv exit strategy?

12•ctoth•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Engineers deserve better recognition. Can a protocol change that?

7•mzk_pi•1d ago•16 comments

Ask HN: Why is virtualization still not solved?

16•prmph•3d ago•30 comments

Ask HN: Who is looking for a cofounder in London?

10•warthog•2d ago•4 comments