frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Anyone built an email or calendar assistant that syncs and indexes data?

5•Bahushruth•22h ago
I’ve been exploring what it takes to build a simple email and calendar assistant that connects to Gmail and Google Calendar. The goal is to make it easy to search and reason over your own data in a useful way.

The part I’m still trying to figure out is how much data actually needs to be synced and indexed. Some tools seem to just call APIs on demand, while others keep everything in a local or vector store for faster retrieval.

If you’ve built something like this:

- Did you bother syncing and indexing the data, or just query live APIs?

- How painful is it to keep that data fresh without hitting rate limits?

- Did you use something like Merge.dev or Composio, or just wire it all up yourself?

I’m mostly trying to understand what the practical tradeoffs are before going too deep.

Comments

PaulHoule•22h ago
I access gmail with the web client that comes with the iPhone and I've done the same with Android, performance is good enough in both cases. For that matter I've used the IMAP support in EM Client to access gmail.
rguldener•22h ago
Founder of https://www.nango.dev here.

A lot of teams use us for their Gmail & Google calendar integrations.

If you want to run complex queries across large parts of the data, syncing + indexing on your side will be necessary. Limits on filters, pagination & rate limits make it infeasible to search across most of a user's inbox without tens of seconds to minutes of latency.

But before you sync all the data, I would test if your users actually need to run such queries.

Both Gmail & Google Calendar have a query endpoint that searches across many fields. I would start with a simple tool for your agent to run queries on that, and expand from there if necessary.

Both Nango and Composio could do this for you.

With Nango, you would also get syncs on the same platform, if it turns out you need them.

Hope this helps!

Bahushruth•21h ago
Thank you that is really helpful. Will check Nango out.

When teams integrate Gmail or other tools with Nango, what usually triggers them to start syncing data instead of just using the query endpoints? Is there a specific type of query or user behavior that makes them realize they need to index and sync data? Just curious

rguldener•21h ago
It varies a lot. Which is why we always recommend to start with the feature requirements/user problem and work backwards from there.

Examples: - Low latency to show X last emails a person had with a specific email address

- Enriching data from the emails/calendar with other data from your product (E.g. mapping email recipients to contacts)

- Knowing when a calendar event has changed (sometimes also possible with webhooks)

- Detecting deletes (maybe also possible with webhooks, not sure for gmail/calendar)

isaachinman•21h ago
Not quite sure what you're asking for. Are you asking for a GUI/cli, or something else?

I've built exactly what you're describing, but for the sake of a b2c product.

rogerkirkness•20h ago
Convictional founder here. Our experience is different than others:

- We had to sync, pre process and index the data to make the resultant knowledge search outputs actually good. MCP totally fails at this by comparison.

- It is not hugely painful thanks to bulk APIs, in Gmail in particular, as well as webhooks. We implemented both of them and it works well (so far).

- We wired it all up ourselves. Given the conclusion we had about pre-processing and indexing being required to make it work well, this seems preferred.

I think that MCP and using an integration platform will ultimately not work for any kind of agentic or deep research task heavily depending on Gmail context.

yashgupta417•19h ago
what is your company doing exactly?
Bahushruth•18h ago
That’s really interesting, especially your point about preprocessing and indexing being required to make search outputs good. What was the first sign that made you realize querying live APIs wasn’t enough?

Was it latency, missing data, or just that results weren’t relevant? And when you say preprocessing, what kind of transformations or normalization ended up being most important?

Ask HN: Does anyone have scans of these missing PC Plus issues (1991–1993)?

59•billpg•1w ago•16 comments

Publishing desktop apps via HTML5 canvas

2•string-theory•1h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Our AWS account got compromised after their outage

391•kinj28•1d ago•94 comments

Ask HN: Can you recreate/restore deleted text messages on an iPhone/Android?

4•danielovichdk•50m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How many 9s did AWS lose due to the last outage (us-east-1 incident)?

5•2dvisio•4h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Am I the only one not using AI?

10•acqbu•6h ago•13 comments

Ask HN: Best practices for research code?

11•Eugeleo•14h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Any good books for a layman on history of quantum computing?

19•bmau5•22h ago•6 comments

Ask HN: Would you like some help with your OSS project?

5•seph-reed•9h ago•4 comments

The First Data-Driven Platform That Makes Hosting Comparisons Fair

2•Hostingmoz•11h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: How to stop an AWS bot sending 2B requests/month?

285•lgats•6d ago•181 comments

Ask HN: What are people doing to get off of VMware?

194•jwithington•3d ago•164 comments

Why do LMMs overuse these patterns of speech that aren't overused in the wild?

7•jimbo808•22h ago•16 comments

Ask HN: End-to-end encrypted LLM chat (open- and closed-model)

3•5F7bGnd6fWJ66xN•17h ago•1 comments

MySQL Release Engineering PGP Key for Apt Repos Has Expired

6•scblzn•19h ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Preferred Next.js Alternatives?

2•blinkbat•21h ago•7 comments

Anyone built an email or calendar assistant that syncs and indexes data?

5•Bahushruth•22h ago•8 comments

Did people in the 90s worry about the efficiency of the internet

12•burgiee•1d ago•15 comments

Tell HN: Copilot.microsoft.com redirect to m365.cloud.microsoft, chats gone

7•eitland•1d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How does one build large front end apps without a framework like React?

107•thepianodan•6d ago•187 comments

Programming language agnosticism is the only way to move forward in life

33•amano-kenji•4d ago•21 comments

Ask HN: What are you working on? (October 2025)

347•david927•1w ago•1054 comments

Ask HN: Are you / should we be preparing for "cyberattack"

4•lifeisstillgood•1d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: How do you convince people to use privacy respecting technologies

12•bogomil•1d ago•12 comments

Ask HN: What failed in the AWS outage that should have worked offline?

12•cipz•1d ago•3 comments

HTTP error codes illustrated with stills from Columbo

9•ColinWright•1d ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Abandoned/dead projects you think died before their time and why?

363•ofalkaed•1w ago•891 comments

Ask HN: Why is Bowker's monopoly on ISBNs in the USA legal?

19•blindprogrammer•3d ago•12 comments

You've reached the end!