Can Management Be Outsourced?

9•ymanagers•1d ago

We’re investigating a controversial hypothesis. We’ve seen almost every major function move outside the building: Marketing → Agencies Sales → SDR firms Legal → External counsel Product → Dev shops.

The pattern is clear. But does it stop at Management?

We honestly don’t know.

Is the "execution" side of management something that must stay in-house forever? Or is it the next function to be decoupled?

We’re running a survey to gather the data: “Can Management Be Outsourced?”

We want to hear from everyone—skeptics, believers, and the undecided. Help us build the dataset. We’ll share the raw findings with everyone who participates.

Link: https://forms.office.com/r/7LxYpzHqKd

Time: 2 minutes.

Comments

kentich•1d ago

I don't think so. In my experience a position of a manager is more political one than the one requiring a skill.

nrhrjrjrjtntbt•1d ago

So... management consultants?

codingdave•1d ago

Management Consulting has been a thing for decades. so has more generic consulting. The whole current trend for "fractional" C-level roles is just a new marketing spin on the same old "consulting".

You always need a leader who sets the vision. Beyond that top-level board or exec, sure, you can outsource everything else. There are pros and cons to it. If I were you, I'd go research the history, successes, and failures of various consulting models before you try to start something new. Because it absolutely can work, but if you don't find the giant shoulders to stand on, you are ignoring decades of lessons learned and will sound like someone who doesn't know their own industry.

ymanagers•23h ago

And regarding team management, do companies need to retain internal staff to oversee them? Could they dispose of internal team leads, product managers, etc?

zug_zug•22h ago

My immediate manager for my US remote SRE team was based out of Poland. He was a good manager.

rawgabbit•22h ago

That is how a lot of US government contracts works. E.g., airports, prisons, even nuclear weapons maintenance.

https://cgfa.ilga.gov/Upload/2006Gov_Privatization_Rprt.pdf

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consolidated_Nuclear_Security

ferguess_k•21h ago

Isn't management always "outsourced" by hiring someone who might not even have the industrial experience? DEC hired someone from Pepsi I think. And I know many higher level managers are contractors in the companies I worked for.

cpach•19h ago

Interesting question. If you would ask Deming I believe he would say “no”.

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving

SQL Still Wins: Why It's Not Going Anywhere

Ask HN: Type 1 Hypervisor for use on a laptop?

Ask HN: What open source projects are you grateful for?

Ask HN: Hearing aid wearers, what's hot?

Ask HN: What Are You Thankful For?

Vibro-Braille for Deaf-Blind

Ask HN: Do AIs reply with numerous em dashes to save money somehow?

Why is OpenAI lying about the data its collecting on users?

Color.io Is Going Offline

Can Management Be Outsourced?

Enterprise security can be messy: Building a Security-Aware Culture

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving

Ask HN: Scheduling stateful nodes when MMAP makes memory accounting a lie

Ask HN: Good resources to learn financial systems engineering?

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving – Grateful

Ask HN: Should account creation/origin country be displayed on HN profiles?

Ask HN: What's your go-to strategy for programmatic SEO in 2025?

Ask HN: Would you use a fast/cheap "prior art" service instead of a patent?

Tell HN: Stall AI progress for the benefit of humanity

Ask HN: What is the best Christmas movie?

Ask HN: What work problems would your company pay to solve?

Ask HN: What did Stripe change (Value Add)?

Ask HN: Opinions on facial recognition at air ports?

Tell HN: Wanted to give dang appreciation

Google attacking human thought with Gemini in Google Keep

Should R ecosystem be a choice for longer-term projects?

Ask HN: TCP/IP Illustrated, v2 2e?

A logging loop in GKE cost me $1,300 in 3 days – 9.2x my actual infrastructure

Tell HN: Cursor charged 19 subscriptions, won't refund

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving

SQL Still Wins: Why It's Not Going Anywhere

Ask HN: Type 1 Hypervisor for use on a laptop?

Ask HN: What open source projects are you grateful for?

Ask HN: Hearing aid wearers, what's hot?

Ask HN: What Are You Thankful For?

Vibro-Braille for Deaf-Blind

Ask HN: Do AIs reply with numerous em dashes to save money somehow?

Why is OpenAI lying about the data its collecting on users?

Color.io Is Going Offline

Can Management Be Outsourced?

Enterprise security can be messy: Building a Security-Aware Culture

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving

Ask HN: Scheduling stateful nodes when MMAP makes memory accounting a lie

Ask HN: Good resources to learn financial systems engineering?

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving – Grateful

Ask HN: Should account creation/origin country be displayed on HN profiles?

Ask HN: What's your go-to strategy for programmatic SEO in 2025?

Ask HN: Would you use a fast/cheap "prior art" service instead of a patent?

Tell HN: Stall AI progress for the benefit of humanity

Ask HN: What is the best Christmas movie?

Ask HN: What work problems would your company pay to solve?

Ask HN: What did Stripe change (Value Add)?

Ask HN: Opinions on facial recognition at air ports?

Tell HN: Wanted to give dang appreciation

Google attacking human thought with Gemini in Google Keep

Should R ecosystem be a choice for longer-term projects?

Ask HN: TCP/IP Illustrated, v2 2e?

A logging loop in GKE cost me $1,300 in 3 days – 9.2x my actual infrastructure

Tell HN: Cursor charged 19 subscriptions, won't refund

Can Management Be Outsourced?

Comments