frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving

750•prodigycorp•1d ago•185 comments

SQL Still Wins: Why It's Not Going Anywhere

2•browsejobs5•1h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Type 1 Hypervisor for use on a laptop?

3•jaitaiwan•6h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: What open source projects are you grateful for?

20•jayzalowitz•19h ago•25 comments

Ask HN: Hearing aid wearers, what's hot?

354•pugworthy•4d ago•209 comments

Ask HN: What Are You Thankful For?

8•nerdsniper•20h ago•8 comments

Vibro-Braille for Deaf-Blind

2•Billiamdan•15h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Do AIs reply with numerous em dashes to save money somehow?

6•amichail•23h ago•8 comments

Why is OpenAI lying about the data its collecting on users?

16•kypro•1d ago•12 comments

Color.io Is Going Offline

23•hilti•2d ago•15 comments

Can Management Be Outsourced?

9•ymanagers•1d ago•8 comments

Enterprise security can be messy: Building a Security-Aware Culture

2•rezliant•20h ago•7 comments

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving

2•turkeyboi•21h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Scheduling stateful nodes when MMAP makes memory accounting a lie

23•leo_e•3d ago•20 comments

Ask HN: Good resources to learn financial systems engineering?

137•_1tan•4d ago•28 comments

Tell HN: Happy Thanksgiving – Grateful

4•emreb•22h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Should account creation/origin country be displayed on HN profiles?

26•megraf•2d ago•36 comments

Ask HN: What's your go-to strategy for programmatic SEO in 2025?

3•liquid99•3h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Would you use a fast/cheap "prior art" service instead of a patent?

5•shaheeniquebal•1d ago•6 comments

Tell HN: Stall AI progress for the benefit of humanity

9•blutoot•1d ago•14 comments

Ask HN: What is the best Christmas movie?

6•johnsillings•13h ago•7 comments

Ask HN: What work problems would your company pay to solve?

16•aryanchaurasia•3d ago•16 comments

Ask HN: What did Stripe change (Value Add)?

7•dzonga•2d ago•9 comments

Ask HN: Opinions on facial recognition at air ports?

5•bjourne•2d ago•30 comments

Tell HN: Wanted to give dang appreciation

64•razodactyl•4d ago•5 comments

Google attacking human thought with Gemini in Google Keep

9•fellowniusmonk•2d ago•1 comments

Should R ecosystem be a choice for longer-term projects?

3•northlondoner•2d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: TCP/IP Illustrated, v2 2e?

7•mayureshkathe•1d ago•0 comments

A logging loop in GKE cost me $1,300 in 3 days – 9.2x my actual infrastructure

9•nthypes•3d ago•4 comments

Tell HN: Cursor charged 19 subscriptions, won't refund

16•devtailz•3d ago•7 comments
Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Would you use a fast/cheap "prior art" service instead of a patent?

5•shaheeniquebal•1d ago
We’re exploring a tech-focused IP platform that helps startups publish fast, affordable “prior art” disclosures. The goal is to protect inventions without the cost or delay of patents, especially in this AI age where things move quickly.

The core proposition is: for a few hundred dollars, you get a timestamped, public disclosure that blocks others from patenting your idea.

We're trying to validate if this is truly valuable for early-stage founders.

Would you consider this a valid alternative to a low-value patent?

What would make you trust a platform offering this?

Is the $250-$500 price point compelling?

We also have a completely anonymous 60-second survey if you prefer that format: https://forms.gle/KSSWGc68RkNT9G8n6

We'll share a summary of the results here afterward. All perspectives are appreciated.

Comments

incomingpain•1d ago
It's not so much for founders. Founders should just do the idea; see if others are doing it first. Form the LLC that can roll over and die if it smacks into a patent.

Your customers are the patent lawyers who need to do that research.

Your competitor is every AI.

brudgers•23h ago
There is no poor man’s patent.

Invention might not require them, but “patent” always means lawyers because patents are entirely a legal construct. Good luck.

stevenalowe•23h ago
If I remember correctly, one has a year to patent an invention once it is publicly disclosed so I don’t see how this service offers any protection
l___l•22h ago
How does disclosing an invention protect it? Protect it from what and for how long? If a patent isn't filed eventually then competitors can file.

Why not publish the invention on a blog?

Why not keep the invention a secret?

bruce511•9h ago
"Disclose" is kinda ambiguous here.

One of the hindrances to getting a patent is prior art. Meaning that the thing you're trying yo patent already exists.

After a patent is issued lots of people typically say "but that's obvious". Ok, so let's capture the obvious before someone patents it.

Equally, I might be doing something which is patentable, but I have no interest in patenting it. By registering it somewhere I make it easy for the patent office to search, thus turning down a patent application. Thus preventing me being sued by some new patent holder.

But to answer the question, no I wouldn't use a service like this. Partly because I wouldn't spend the money and partly because (in isolation) the service doesn't work. Unless the patent office is involved and actively using it, bad patents still get granted.

Yes, it might add some weight to a court case where I'm being sued, but honestly if I get there I've already lost. And my code backups show the same thing anyway.

Plus, which of the thousands of things I am doing, should I register? Am I supposed to trawl through my code deciding on each line if it's novel? If I do all this work I might as well just get a patent. That can at least be used in cross-licencing agreements.

Yes, software patents are a blight, but I'm not sure this is really a solution.

vunderba•12h ago
This sounds vaguely like a "patent equivalent" of places like Copyright House. I think the biggest thing you'd have to convince people of is why they'd use your service versus just self-publishing the patent notes on their blog which counts as self-disclosure and should (operative word) give you a year's grace to file for the actual patent.

https://copyrighthouse.org