frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

How does a "you interview for US company, we do the work" scam work?

17•marttilaine•3h ago•18 comments

Ask HN: What are you buying your kids for Christmas?

29•JamesSwift•13h ago•22 comments

Revolutionizing Lighting: How Smart LEDs Are Transforming Homes and Businesses

2•emmasuntech•4h ago•0 comments

AI coding is sexy, but accounting is the real low-hanging automation target

23•bmadduma•15h ago•12 comments

Ask HN: How can I delete a Substack account in Australia?

4•freefrog334433•5h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Should "I asked $AI, and it said" replies be forbidden in HN guidelines?

957•embedding-shape•2d ago•460 comments

Practical Tips for Gemini 3

5•xiaoru•1d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Can someone explain why OpenAI credits expire?

3•jemiluv8•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Relatively SoTA LLM Agents from Scratch?

2•solsane•18h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: What hard problems are still underexplored?

11•brihati•1d ago•18 comments

Why are "remote" jobs in late 2025 still limited to hiring in US/CA/UK/DE?

19•ftonato•2d ago•12 comments

Ask HN: Has anyone been able to renew their IEEE this month?

8•chrisaycock•22h ago•0 comments

Console.text() – SMS alerts when code executes

5•Noel04•1d ago•7 comments

Ask HN: End of Year Book Recommendations

12•marai2•1d ago•5 comments

Is any of you using LLMs to create full features in big enterprise apps?

6•not_that_d•2d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: What are young technically minded people reading?

17•drdec•2d ago•27 comments

Ask HN: How do small businesses handle phone calls?

4•duckkg5•1d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: Is there a "good" (non-privacy horror) aftermarket HUD for your car?

3•xrd•1d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: How can I learn smartphone repair online?

4•rishikeshs•2d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Are there any viable Android phones for a power user to buy nowadays?

12•gooob•3d ago•8 comments

What's Next? Clippy Copilot?

8•johnnyballgame•2d ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Is it still worth learning a new programming language?

11•xparadigm•2d ago•17 comments

Cursor and Claude Opus 4.5 is a game changer

18•seinecle•4d ago•11 comments

Ask HN: Is it just me or techno-optimism died in the past few years?

37•shubhamjain•5d ago•37 comments

You've reached the end!

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Can someone explain why OpenAI credits expire?

3•jemiluv8•1d ago
I was surprised to find out only recently that some credits I bought about a year a go were unusable because they had expired. I find this a bit concerning because it seems as though I'm being forced to use the credits.

In my part of the world, that tactic is used by telcos to sell "broadband data". You buy internet bundle of about $1 and they give you expiry of about a week. This drives up the "real" price of these purchases because of the time constraint. Ultimately, if you had 1GB of data left after a week, it is all gone and you have to purchase again - further driving sales. Since this is a third world country we're talking about and telco's tend to be oligopolies and tend to also do some form of price collusion among themselves, it was generally accepted as "just how things were".

But I always found it to be unfair because people should be allowed to take their time consuming whatever product they purchased.

I wonder if this is general practice for all llm apis? Am I missing something? Is this really how things should be? I can't seem to fathom why "purchased" llm credits should have an expiry date - however generous. Especially when the same credits can be used to access any of their available models.

Comments

klez•1d ago
> This drives up the "real" price of these purchases because of the time constraint.

I'd say you answered your own question.

> telco's tend to be oligopolies and tend to also do some form of price collusion among themselves, it was generally accepted as "just how things were"

So are LLM companies, at this stage

> Am I missing something?

Not really

> Is this really how things should be?

No, this is how thing are. I'm more than interested in ways to change the status quo, though.

7bit•1d ago
Because someone at openAI decided it so and the CEO approved it.
gus_massa•23h ago
For accounting it's better to give things an expiring date. Perhaps 5 year would have been better than 1 to keep people happy, but I don't know why they decided 1 year (or whatever is the exact number).
_wire_•22h ago
- Skirts credit speculation and arbitrage

- Prevents hoarding

- Allows freedom for sales promotions while controlling service commitments

- Marginally increases revenue per unit of service

- Provides stable pricing in shorter term while accommodating price changes over longer term

- Excites engagement

jamessb•2h ago
> - Skirts credit speculation and arbitrage

> - Provides stable pricing in shorter term while accommodating price changes over longer term

How? If you pre-pay $5, your account is credited by $5, and when you make an API request you get charged at whatever the rate is for the model you called at the time you used it. You aren't buying some virtual currency or locking in a specific price.

> - Excites engagement

More accurately, irritates customers by keeping their money without providing any service in return.

Bender•22h ago
Can someone explain why OpenAI credits expire?

Just guessing but probably to bring it up to par with a coin operated car wash to get more monies.

- Insert Duckets [1]

- Start Washing Car

- Insert More Duckets to Rinse Car.

[1] - slang, Items of a lootable nature, usually looted off fools.

That, or they don't want criminals building up a cache of credits from stolen credit cards, stolen accounts and reselling the credits / accounts but I prefer to think it's to be a car wash.

jaredsohn•4h ago
My guess is this is so OpenAI can treat it as annual recurring revenue which helps with their stock valuation. I've seen non-LLM API vendors do this with their credits as well.