frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Anthropic disabled my account after payment cancer patient/medical data trapped

82•marichala•2h ago
*Title:* Anthropic disabled my Max account after charging me $106.60 — I’m a cancer patient and my medical documentation is trapped inside

*Post:*

On January 16th, 2025, Anthropic charged me $106.60 for my Max subscription and disabled my account in the same moment. I believe I was flagged because I’m a long-term guest at a Marriott hotel using shared WiFi.

I’m not a bot. I’m not running scripts. I’m not violating terms of service. I’m a 41-year-old woman with MDS (myelodysplastic syndrome) that has converted to leukemia. I’m facing a bone marrow transplant I may not survive.

For months, Claude has been the only thing that actually helped me navigate a medical system that failed me for over a decade. It helped me organize 11 years of medical records, track my labs, draft insurance appeals, and write letters to doctors who wouldn’t listen. That work is what finally got someone to take me seriously.

My last prompt before the ban was asking Claude to help me interpret my October bloodwork. That’s it. That’s the “violation.”

That chat history is my medical documentation. I need it to continue advocating for my care when I’m too sick to remember what happened, what was said, what was missed. Without it, I lose years of work at the worst possible moment.

I have done everything I was supposed to do:

- Submitted appeals through the official form - Emailed support@anthropic.com - Emailed usersafety@anthropic.com - Filed a complaint with the California Attorney General - Filed a complaint with the FTC - DM’d and tweeted at Daniela Amodei, Dario Amodei, Amanda Askell, Jan Leike, and Mike Krieger - Posted in the official Claude Discord #community-help channel

Every response has been automated. The support bot offered me a human agent. I accepted. No human ever came.

It can’t be a content violation — my last prompt was about bloodwork. It can’t be a payment issue — the charge went through. The only explanation is their system flagged my IP because I’m on shared hotel WiFi, and no human has reviewed it since.

I am asking for one of two things:

1. Restore my account 1. Export my complete chat history and send it to me

Anthropic talks constantly about building AI that helps people. Claude helped me. It helped me fight for my life. Now I can’t get a single human being at the company to look at my case.

If anyone here works at Anthropic or knows someone who does, I would be grateful for any help.Thank you.

Comments

MattGaiser•1h ago
I wish companies had a pay $50 to speak to a human option if need be.

No spamming abuser will pay that, but it should easily cover the cost of an overseas support agent to handle edge cases.

LtWorf•1h ago
You know they'd put you in touch with someone who has no clue about anything.
p4coder•1h ago
I think what we really need is Internet user's Bill of Rights. The power and information asymmetry is too great to obtain fair treatment for the user.
nottorp•1h ago
So they will hire a "support agent" that costs $30 and leave their service as buggy as bearable so they make those extra $20 more often.
asmor•1h ago
The problem with rate limiting with money is always that it's also going to be too much for someone else to pay (or too little for others).

I'm so glad ICANN banned silent auctions for the next round of gTLDs.

rschiavone•1h ago
That would cause companies to provide the shittiest possible service in order to monetize their support. And they would still outsource the support for $1/hr.
BrenBarn•49m ago
I wish governments had a "pay $100 million if you don't have a human option for all your customers" option.
nobodywillobsrv•1h ago
Anthropic should do a full inquiry into this and fire people for it. No questions asked. Fire them. And then reply with automated bits.
euazOn•1h ago
I don't know. If this is a real thing, then I'm really sorry for what happened to you.

But this whole post seems a bit fishy to me. Brand new account, and it starts with "Title:" and "Post:", the whole thing being obviously entirely AI generated, and a few other signs.

IshKebab•1h ago
This is one really great thing about the GDPR - you could just file a personal information access request and they legally have to give you all your data.

(Sorry that doesn't help you.)

edarchis•1h ago
I got banned for asking about the yfinance python module. They had an "appeal" but it was a Google Form that probably nobody ever looks at.

My recommendation would be to get in touch with their DPO (Data Protection Officer) and invoke the GDPR rule that you have the right to 1. have an explanation as to why an automated decision was made about you, 2. ask for a human review. You are out of the GDPR scope but the legal contact might not bother checking and just restore your account. Getting your data is also a right under GDPR but getting your account back would be a better option. I wouldn't mention this or they'll jump on it.

user_7832•1h ago
Sorry to hear. (Assuming you don't get help from here) The "best" solution very likely involves Anthropic's legal team.

Depending on how much time, energy, and money you have, you can either draft a (simple) email to their customer support CC'ing legal (with ChatGPT/Gemini thinking's help), or ideally get a lawyer to do the same (easier if one of your friends is one).

If you don't get a response to the email, send a certified letter, ideally with a lawyer's help.

I'm not sure on what legal grounds you could sue (I'm sure a good lawyer would find a few - not providing your data for a Cali resident seems an obvious one to me) - but getting legal involved is often enough to "wake up" large cos into getting a human in the loop. A certified letter needs acknowledgement of the recepient, again mandating a human.

Best of luck.

smca•1h ago
(I work at Anthropic) I’ll exhaust every option to have this fixed for you.

If you can pass along at least some way to get in touch (link your Twitter account or similar) that would be helpful.

jwrallie•1h ago
If this is real, best of luck to get your data back.

So many companies are operating with basically no support nowadays, so for the end user you just hope everything works perfectly (until it doesn't).

I don't even blame the bots, I've had human interactions in the past where, while they could perfectly understand my problems, they couldn't do anything because they worked on a script and have limited agency. It is basically the same flow, you just talk until it either escalates to someone that does have the ability to help or it loops back to the beginning and you try again.

Ask HN: Does Hacker News pull posts about Greenland from the front page?

7•subjektivation•1h ago•20 comments

Does changing DNS make internet faster

2•higiga7487•2h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Share your personal website

935•susam•4d ago•2370 comments

Ask HN: Is it still worth pursuing a software startup?

182•newbebee•2d ago•221 comments

Ask HN: How many local logins do you have on your computer?

6•bahmboo•8h ago•8 comments

Ask HN: 1 year from today what will have been the worst behavior from AI corps?

3•keepamovin•5h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: How are you doing RAG locally?

409•tmaly•4d ago•156 comments

Ask HN: How can we solve the loneliness epidemic?

785•publicdebates•3d ago•1220 comments

Ask HN: How to bullet proof yourself from AI?

15•max_•17h ago•12 comments

Ask HN: What did you find out or explore today?

217•blahaj•4d ago•426 comments

Ask HN: How to get a job after a career break?

9•shivajikobardan•19h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Claude Opus performance affected by time of day?

38•scaredreally•2d ago•36 comments

Tell HN: Poshmark instantly leaked my email to scammers

6•hardenedmetapod•17h ago•8 comments

Tell HN: YouTube gave my username switzerland to a half government organization

38•faebi•2d ago•9 comments

Ask HN: One IP, multiple unrealistic locations worldwide hitting my website

42•nacho-daddy•3d ago•25 comments

Ask HN: Iran's 120h internet shutdown, phones back. How to stay resilient?

115•us321•5d ago•100 comments

Ask HN: Are cross-platform UI frameworks suitable for camera apps?

2•Austin_Conlon•15h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Is replacing an enterprise product with LLMs a realistic strategy?

6•chandmk•1d ago•6 comments

Tell HN: The way I do simple data management for new prototypes

12•AndreyK1984•2d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: How have you or your firm made money with LLMs?

10•bwestergard•2d ago•9 comments

Ask HN: How do you safely give LLMs SSH/DB access?

83•nico•4d ago•106 comments

Ask HN: Browser extension vs. native app for structured form filling?

5•livrasand•2d ago•5 comments

The $LANG Programming Language

265•dang•5d ago•70 comments

Ask HN: What are your best purchases under $100?

83•krishadi•3d ago•234 comments

Ask HN: Who's using DuckDB in production?

7•yakkomajuri•2d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: How to make spamming us uncomfortable for LinkedIn and friends?

12•zx8080•3d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Distributed SQL engine for ultra-wide tables

23•synsqlbythesea•4d ago•20 comments

Ask HN: Why is Google tolerating impersonation of Gmail from it's own domain?

6•dvh•1d ago•1 comments

Why are websites trying to talk at me?

2•LeratoAustini•1d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: ADHD – How do you manage the constant stream of thoughts and ideas?

121•chriswright1664•5d ago•148 comments