Coding assistants are slow. So we multitask

3•brunaxLorax•10h ago

Coding assistants are slow.

Obviously they are extremely fast in comparison to the best human programmers, but they are still too slow to be our one-to-one enhanced pair programmer. Our current solution is multi-instances, toggling between tasks. However, Multitasking is known to be a poor method, with low productivity and causing harm as it increases cognitive load, stress and fatigue levels.

I am sure that this is temporary and we will soon have coding assistants fast enough for deep focus on single tasks. What do you think?

Comments

PaulHoule•9h ago

Personally I'm careful about multitasking. If you had two agents working on things in parallel you are going to have more problems stomping on each other's work even if they are working in two different checkouts of the same code. Also in terms of your effort supervising them if you are going back from one to the other you're more likely to get confused.

I wouldn't say "never multitask" but I think you should think carefully about a portfolio of things you can work on that don't conflict with each other.

One possibility to to race analysis of situations with an LLM. For instance punch in a prompt asking if it can figure out the cause of a bug and go off and try figuring it out yourself in the debugger. Or read or write documentation when it is off on a mission.

brunaxLorax•9h ago

With git worktrees you can you have your agents working on literally different folders so they don't step up on each other.

PaulHoule•8h ago

that solves the problem of "stomping on things" in the short term but it might not be trivial to merge these later. depending on what kind of tasks you're giving them and the style in which they do them it could be anything from "no problems" to "lots of headaches" -- the same is true for human developers.

(I've definitely seen 20 developer teams that were spinning their wheels because they were stomping on each other despite using version control as well as teams that had code rot because they had a "no refactoring/don't touch a file you can possible avoid touching" policy)

brunaxLorax•7h ago

I agree. However as you said, you can consider code agents like human contributors. My feedback is that an army of Claude Code instances with a strict CLAUDE.md file is more rigorous than a human team.

tjr•9h ago

Genuinely curious: how quickly do you need new code written? What kinds of things are you working on that still aren’t being done fast enough?

feastingonslop•9h ago

Why build software slower than possible? Do you just enjoy wasting people’s time?

brunaxLorax•9h ago

How quickly? There is no limit to that. If I can do my day of work in few hours I would be glad to take the afternoon off or to go twice as fast (importunately that's more the second!)

brunaxLorax•9h ago

I recently came across https://claudecode.run/ (not affiliated). There are currently several similar products that help that multi-instance Claude Code layout

Ask HN: Gmail spam filtering suddenly marking everything as spam?

Ask HN: What's the current best local/open speech-to-speech setup?

Ask HN: Have we confused efficiency with "100% utilization"?

Ask HN: What usually happens after a VC asks for a demo?

Ask HN: Do you have any evidence that agentic coding works?

Ask HN: Career transition question – assistance, MLOps guidance

Ask HN: May an agent accept a license to produce a build?

Tell HN: 2 years building a kids audio app as a solo dev – lessons learned

Ask HN: Seeeking help to reverse engineer a PCB

Ask HN: Why does the number of datasets on data.gov vary so much?

Ask HN: Thinking about memory for AI coding agents

Ask HN: What are some good unintuitive statistics problems?

Ask HN: Rust and AI builders interested in local-first, multi-agent systems?

Coding assistants are slow. So we multitask

Ask HN: How to redeem a gift card without risking lock-out?

Ask HN: Weekend Social: Top two programming languages and what they can borrow?

Ask HN: Where is society heading, is there a plan for a jobless future?

Ask HN: Why are so many rolling out their own AI/LLM agent sandboxing solution?

Ask HN: General purpose search engine that will respect special characters?

Ask HN: How do you AI code from your phone?

Ask HN: Do you "micro-manage" your agents?

Ask HN: Revive a mostly dead Discord server

Locked out of my GCP account for 3 days, still charged, can't redirect domain

Ask HN: Where do you look for semiconductor jobs?

Ask HN: Does DDG no longer honor "site:" prefix?

Ask HN: LLMs for new job categories?

Ask HN: Best practice securing secrets on local machines working with agents?

Tell HN: AI is all about the tools (for now)

ChatGPT has no real-time clock – time awareness is essential

Ask HN: How do you authorize AI agent actions in production?

Ask HN: Gmail spam filtering suddenly marking everything as spam?

Ask HN: What's the current best local/open speech-to-speech setup?

Ask HN: Have we confused efficiency with "100% utilization"?

Ask HN: What usually happens after a VC asks for a demo?

Ask HN: Do you have any evidence that agentic coding works?

Ask HN: Career transition question – assistance, MLOps guidance

Ask HN: May an agent accept a license to produce a build?

Tell HN: 2 years building a kids audio app as a solo dev – lessons learned

Ask HN: Seeeking help to reverse engineer a PCB

Ask HN: Why does the number of datasets on data.gov vary so much?

Ask HN: Thinking about memory for AI coding agents

Ask HN: What are some good unintuitive statistics problems?

Ask HN: Rust and AI builders interested in local-first, multi-agent systems?

Coding assistants are slow. So we multitask

Ask HN: How to redeem a gift card without risking lock-out?

Ask HN: Weekend Social: Top two programming languages and what they can borrow?

Ask HN: Where is society heading, is there a plan for a jobless future?

Ask HN: Why are so many rolling out their own AI/LLM agent sandboxing solution?

Ask HN: General purpose search engine that will respect special characters?

Ask HN: How do you AI code from your phone?

Ask HN: Do you "micro-manage" your agents?

Ask HN: Revive a mostly dead Discord server

Locked out of my GCP account for 3 days, still charged, can't redirect domain

Ask HN: Where do you look for semiconductor jobs?

Ask HN: Does DDG no longer honor "site:" prefix?

Ask HN: LLMs for new job categories?

Ask HN: Best practice securing secrets on local machines working with agents?

Tell HN: AI is all about the tools (for now)

ChatGPT has no real-time clock – time awareness is essential

Ask HN: How do you authorize AI agent actions in production?

Coding assistants are slow. So we multitask

Comments