frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Generative AI failed to replace SaaS

3•AIFairy•1d ago
Satya Nadella & others preached about GenAI replacing the "Business Logic" or the "Middle Tier" layer of various SaaS services. The idea was that users would interact with a GenAI model (via a chat interface), and then the model would interact directly with a database. This would have obviously mooted the need for almost all SaaS applications.

What's been happening instead is that GenAI has been moving up the "stack," further and further away from the database. No one's talking about replacing SaaS anymore. Instead, GenAI has become a sort of garnish, something that you sprinkle ON TOP of existing SaaS applications without truly replacing any of their pre-existing features.

This shift "up the stack" speaks volumes to the impotence of our current models. They are so incapable and unreliable that they couldn't replace a single part of Excel, for example. Instead, all Microsoft did was "slap GenAI on top", placing the burden on users to "figure out" how to make it useful. We went from "replace it with a chat agent" to "just slap a chat agent on top and hope for the best." In other words, we actually made our SaaS applications MORE complicated instead of consolidating their features and therefore simplifying them.

Comments

wolfejam•1d ago
very true, most end-users don't care what we call it or how it works--most drivers don't know how their brakes work, but they better

simplify with AI hasn't quite caught on lol

spenceXu•1d ago
This is a spot-on observation about 'AI as a garnish.' In my own work, I've seen many teams rush to add a chat interface just to say they have AI, without solving any core user problems. It often does make the product more complicated. I wonder if the path to true replacement starts in smaller, vertical niches rather than trying to overhaul giants like Excel from day one?

Ask HN: How far has "vibe coding" come?

4•pigon1002•4h ago•8 comments

The Anti-Pomodoro Technique: Focus on Taking Breaks, Not Watching the Timer

4•kentich•1h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Books to learn 6502 ASM and the Apple II

97•abkt•2d ago•67 comments

Ask HN: Who do you follow via RSS feed?

67•znpy•2d ago•51 comments

Designing programming languages beyond AI comprehension

4•mr_bob_sacamano•15h ago•6 comments

Ask HN: DDD was a great debugger – what would a modern equivalent look like?

56•manux81•3d ago•60 comments

Ask HN: What recent UX changes make no sense to you?

29•superasn•1d ago•34 comments

Ask HN: Has Show HN become LLM-prompt-centric?

8•piratesAndSons•15h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: What's the Point Anymore?

60•fnoef•1d ago•73 comments

Ask HN: Gmail spam filtering suddenly marking everything as spam?

210•goopthink•4d ago•122 comments

Ask HN: Where to find cool companies to work for?

5•truetaurus•16h ago•4 comments

How much recurring income do you generate in 2026 and from what?

9•djshah•1d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: What's the current best local/open speech-to-speech setup?

256•dsrtslnd23•6d ago•61 comments

Ask HN: Vibe Researching" with AI – Anyone Using It for Real?

8•spenceXu•1d ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Notification Overload

7•fractal618•2d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: European alternative to Vercel/Cloudflare for hosting

11•vldszn•1d ago•14 comments

Where can I find startups looking for fractional product leads?

6•stulogy•1d ago•3 comments

How to DeGoogle Myself?

12•neuralkoi•1d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How to prevent Claude/GPT/Gemini from reinforcing your biases?

29•akshay326•2d ago•22 comments

I built a C++ runtime with immutable objects and no GIL

5•gamarino•1d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: How much emphasis to put on unit testing and when?

9•theturtlemoves•2d ago•18 comments

Tell HN: I cut Claude API costs from $70/month to pennies

40•ok_orco•3d ago•25 comments

Ask HN: If Everyone Can "Build" a SaaS, What Becomes Valuable?

10•spenceXu•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Can a MMO be vibe coded?

3•radicalethics•20h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: What usually happens after a VC asks for a demo?

12•stijo•4d ago•7 comments

Tell HN: JumpCloud 2FA appears to be down

2•sgammon•1d ago•0 comments

Why did the developer go broke?

7•oxqbldpxo•1d ago•6 comments

Generative AI failed to replace SaaS

3•AIFairy•1d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: What's something interesting you learned from training your own GPT?

2•amadeuswoo•1d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: If OpenAI stops its free Web service (ChatGPT)

3•JPLeRouzic•1d ago•2 comments