frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

AI has failed to replace a single software application or feature

6•cadabrabra•3h ago
I can’t name a single software application or software feature that has been mooted by AI. Zero. Take Excel as an example. Not only has AI failed to replace Excel in its entirety, but it has also failed to replace any of its features. AI was simply appended as an additional feature in the form of an agentic chatbot. This has been the trend across the entire industry, and it’s why AI has failed to fundamentally transform any of our exiting software application.

Now you might ask: what about AI native applications? Well, as it turns out, most of them are essentially clones of existing software but with a chatbot slapped on top. Because of the error prone nature of AI, any application that leverages it also has to surface all of the controls required to override all of its decisions. So you end up with a traditional software application plus AI.

AI promised to transform and even replace software applications, but all it did instead was augment them with an unreliable chatbot. All of the old fields and buttons are still there, but now there’s an additional text field that you can type into and hope for the best.

Comments

PaulHoule•2h ago
Conventional web search: I use Google's AI Mode almost exclusively when I use Google.

Refactoring tools in my IDE: In some cases where I could use the refactoring tools in my IDE I will ask the assistant to do something for me instead, of course it will also make changes that the refactoring tools won't do such as tear apart a complicated if-then-else ladder.

Photo retouching: there are plenty of photo retouching jobs that can be done easily with AI or with the tools built into Photoshop, which one is better depends on the situation. I really wish I had an AI tool to make masks ("cut out the person") that I could then use with the other tools or with AI generation.

tacostakohashi•2h ago
Nobody uses Excel anymore, now everyone uses Microsoft 365 Copilot!
falcor84•2h ago
The big one for me is shell scripting and working with the terminal in general. For everything except for the simplest commands, I find myself preferring to ask in plain English, and while imperfect, it has both saved me time and decreased the number of times I've accidentally deleted/broken things, compared to me doing it manually.
dyingkneepad•2h ago
AI has completely killed Google Translate. It is significantly superior in every way.

GT often uses the wrong word or changes the tone of a message. AI always gets the intent right and always seems to use the most appropriate words given the original intent/meaning (or at least something way better than what GT does). And, whenever there is doubt, I can argue with it, so AI is happy to explain the nuances and differences between the possibilities.

Edit: I recently had to send a semi-formal email requesting something from a government employee in a different country (using a language I'm a beginner at), and AI was immensely helpful in getting the right tone (neither informal or too formal) and everything else right. The Google Translate version of what I had originally written was miles and miles and miles worse than what AI helped me craft.

nextos•1h ago
True, but Google Translate was already "AI". They previously used LSTMs. And before LSTMs, it was ML-like statistical translation.
Jeremy1026•1h ago
This is certainly a take.
wxw•1h ago
Transitions take time. 0 -> 1 replacement of existing interfaces is (1) not easy and (2) not a practical approach to market adoption.

"slapping on a chatbot" is a v0 attempt at re-imagining what software looks like. It's not very inventive and sometimes it sucks, but it's easy to understand and implement and we're very early in this era.

The distribution of change also isn't uniform. Excel might not have changed dramatically, but software engineering apps are evolving rapidly. Clawdbot/moltbot hint at new forms of personal computing. Look for the future where the optimism is.

segmondy•54m ago
I'm so sorry to hear that you are falling behind. With this attitude you are going to keep falling behind. Good luck.

Waypoint 1.1, a local-first world model for interactive simulation

8•lcastricato•2h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Notification Overload

39•fractal618•3d ago•73 comments

AI has failed to replace a single software application or feature

6•cadabrabra•3h ago•8 comments

AI creates over-efficiency. Organizations must absorb it

5•eriam•3h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Ergo wireless keyboard with mouse for coding?

2•MarcelOlsz•3h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Junior getting lost

39•TheRegularOne•1d ago•32 comments

Ask HN: Why the OpenClaw hype? What's so special?

2•anon_anon12•1h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How are you managing secrets with AI agents?

2•m-hodges•4h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Is free identity theft protection after a data breach worth the bother?

2•daoboy•5h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How do you reset an AppleID?

9•OhMeadhbh•18h ago•22 comments

Ask HN: How do you market a side project?

4•ruairidhwm•8h ago•6 comments

The preposterous notion of AI automating "repetitive" work

6•cadabrabra•14h ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Books to learn 6502 ASM and the Apple II

101•abkt•3d ago•69 comments

Ask HN: Who do you follow via RSS feed?

67•znpy•3d ago•52 comments

Ask HN: How do you force yourself to take breaks while coding?

2•glidea•16h ago•10 comments

Ask HN: DDD was a great debugger – what would a modern equivalent look like?

56•manux81•4d ago•60 comments

Ask HN: Is archive.is currently broken for WSJ links?

7•bigwheels•1d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: How are devtool founders getting their paying users in 2026?

7•yasu_c•19h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How far has "vibe coding" come?

11•pigon1002•1d ago•26 comments

Tell HN: Beeper deletes inactive accounts without notice

4•kldx•1d ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What's the Point Anymore?

63•fnoef•3d ago•79 comments

Designing programming languages beyond AI comprehension

6•mr_bob_sacamano•1d ago•10 comments

Ask HN: What recent UX changes make no sense to you?

31•superasn•2d ago•35 comments

How much recurring income do you generate in 2026 and from what?

12•djshah•2d ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Vibe Researching" with AI – Anyone Using It for Real?

8•spenceXu•2d ago•5 comments

Where can I find startups looking for fractional product leads?

7•stulogy•2d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: How to prevent Claude/GPT/Gemini from reinforcing your biases?

29•akshay326•4d ago•22 comments

Tell HN: I cut Claude API costs from $70/month to pennies

40•ok_orco•4d ago•25 comments

Ask HN: European alternative to Vercel/Cloudflare for hosting

12•vldszn•3d ago•19 comments

Ask HN: How much emphasis to put on unit testing and when?

9•theturtlemoves•3d ago•18 comments