As the article says, human genetic difference is very real, and is clustered. Can we not then call these clusters races?
There is more genetic diversity within the Africa than in the rest of the world combined. If white and Asian are genetic races, then there are hundreds of different African races. If black is a genetic race then a better name for it is Homo Sapiens -- we're all black.
If black is a race and Europeans aren't black, then race isn't genetic, it's cultural.
Having said that, is this not what the entire world has been doing recently? Does BLM not fall for exactly the same fallacy? Is "person of colour" not an egregiously bad phrase to define a person? As if we are white, unless somehow tainted? Is this not something that should concern us all whether it is done with good intentions or not?
BrandoElFollito•9mo ago
Now, coupled with the fact that it may give you advantages, say at the university, what stops a guy like me (blond, fair haired) to claim that he is Asian, Black or whatever "race" is the most interesting in that case at that moment?
Will someone tell me I am not Latino enough?
api•9mo ago
The definition has expanded considerably already. Originally it was just WASPs of Northern European origin. It excluded many Southern Europeans, Slavs (hilarious that so many white nationalists love Russia now), Irish, and of course Jews.
So let’s skip another century or two and just say everyone is white. Humans are much less genetically diverse than most other mammals anyway, so compared to canines or squirrels we absolutely are all the same race, and everyone is interbreeding and blending characteristics even more.
An alien invasion of hominids with truly “Vanta black” skin would help but we can probably meme this into existence without it.
Edit: I’ve got it. Someone make an AI browser plugin that randomizes ethnicity in all photos and videos.
BrandoElFollito•9mo ago
I think that races are a way to describe people that unfortunately went south. You usually say the big, high, clever, ... black guy. The first three are neutral, the last one (possibly the most descriptive) is scary.