Adding keyword parameters to Tcl procs

https://world-playground-deceit.net/blog/2025/04/adding-keyword-parameters-to-tcl-procs.html

58•BoingBoomTschak•2mo ago

Comments

andrewshadura•2mo ago

Tcl is the shell done right. Simple, logical, consistent.

BoingBoomTschak•2mo ago

Well, it's certainly much better, especially now that we have dicts to replace arrays. But the specter of https://wiki.tcl-lang.org/page/exec+ampersand+problem (cf https://core.tcl-lang.org/tips/doc/trunk/tip/424.md) still looms.

grewsome•2mo ago

Tcl does appear to be a command language done right, I don't think there is a better one. As it was designed after bash etc, I guess the Tcl developers could see the inconsistencies there, which helped them do Tcl right.

IshKebab•2mo ago

Well... Yes and no. It's definitely better than most shells, but that's a very low bar. It's pretty awful compared to any "real" programming language, which is a problem because it's used in places where a real programming language would be much more appropriate.

grewsome•2mo ago

Tcl is a real programming language, but it depends on what you are doing with it. There are a lot of people who have never come into contact with command languages, and so there are plenty that look at it and have a negative response. For a lot of people though, Tcl is as easy to program in as Python or any other scripting language. It's a heck of a lot _easier_ to program in than a lot of so called real programming languages. I've found Ousterhout's dichotomy to be true, using two languages for a codebase is very efficient, but again, it'll depend on what you're doing.

IshKebab•2mo ago

It depends what you mean by easy. There are fewer features sure, but it's kind of like saying building a house with just a hand saw and a hammer is easy. Sure there are fewer tools to learn if you don't use CAD, power tools, laser levels, etc. But it's a bit dubious to say it's easier.

grewsome•2mo ago

Tcl doesn't have fewer features, it packs in a lot, probably because of its maturity, to a similar level as other mature scripting languages (OO, coroutines, event loop, slave interps, etc, etc). But it's poor when you want something to run quick, or if you want to carefully manage memory because you have a lot of data. Also there is no typing, and for large code bases that is detrimental. But by using two languages you can get the best of both worlds. But then you need to program competently in two languages, and that takes a surprising amount of experience, and the hand saw and hammer analogy isn't accurate in this case.

tracnar•2mo ago

I implemented something very similar a while ago, it's indeed too bad it's not built-in. I don't think you need such a "quasiquote" function, [list {*}$args] can escape a single command, and then it's a matter of joining multiple commands using a newline. IIRC that's how I did it.

I also had further fun with wrapping "proc" by implementing a "pyproc" which called out to Python while looking like a normal Tcl proc.

BoingBoomTschak•2mo ago

The problem is mainly the square brackets that force one to go through strings, in my experience. Can't build something like "set foo [cmd $bar]" purely by using [list ...] shenanigans, since list will quote stuff you don't want quoted.

tracnar•2mo ago

True, I believe I mostly worked around that limitation by splitting off quoted from unquoted code into separate commands. So in your example "[cmd $bar]" would be in a separate unquoted command, probably putting it in a temporary variable, which can cause problems as it's hard to have a private scope when doing metaprogramming. You can also use "[list]" in the middle of code, but it gets more error prone, for example "set foo \[[list cmd \$bar]\]"

For sure there is a lack of proper "code as data" constructs in Tcl, like you would find in Lisp.

BoingBoomTschak•2mo ago

Actually, you can see the "backslash hell" version here if you want to estimate the clarity gains: https://git.sr.ht/~q3cpma/tcl-misc/tree/f613898c3dcfa3ca958a...

blacksqr•2mo ago

The OpenACS web server toolkit has a lot of useful Tcl utilities, including the ad_proc procedure, which wraps proc and allows adding of switches, inline docs, and more.

I think it would be very useful to turn ad_proc into a built-in command and incorporate it into TCL.

https://nstcl.sourceforge.net/docs/nstcl-core/ad_proc.html

shawn_w•2mo ago

Personally I'm a fan of TEPAM from tcllib, which does much the same (and tcllib is available through many OS's package managers making it more readily available)

https://core.tcl-lang.org/tcllib/doc/trunk/embedded/md/tclli...

grewsome•2mo ago

For incorporating into Tcl I'd prefer something simpler that would also work with existing procs. Building on {*}, maybe {@} could work (to skip over arguments to a specified argument}. e.g. when calling a function: someFunc someVal anotherVal {@}someArgName yetAnotherVal

jrapdx3•2mo ago

As a search of the Tcl wiki shows, attempts to add named-argument capability to the Tcl proc command have been around for several years.

My own nxproc extension is more comprehensive. (See wiki [0].)

The extension enables named arguments, regular positional arguments, and 'rest' arguments, nxargs and nxunknown. Nxproc also provides (optional) type-checking of procedure arguments. (Types: string, number, bool and enumerated. Enums are lists of values restricting what the arg can contain.)

Nxproc supports TclOO with nxcontructor and nxmethod commands -- same feature set as "plain" nxproc. Also provides case-insensitive '-ci' variants, and runtime display of named-argument default/actual values and types.

Nxproc is a Tcl C extension. Bundle has Windows, Linux binaries. Compiles easily on other platforms.

[0] https://wiki.tcl-lang.org/page/nxproc

sigzero•2mo ago

That looks very nice!

RicoElectrico•2mo ago

Synopsys tools (either CosmosScope or Custom Wave view) do it by the way of names following values. Like:

    measureFoo $signal threshold 0.9 edge last

Nothing's Untestable

Show HN: I made a social media platform

How to write Rust in the kernel part 1

CEOs Start Saying the Quiet Part Out Loud: AI Will Wipe Out Jobs

Debian on Apple M1/M2: status and call for testers

GitHub Copilot coding agent now has a Playwright web browser

Show HN: Piskvor Prime: a five-in-a-row iOS game with a reactive AI opponent

Show HN: Wyntk.ai – anti horseless carriage email

Give Footnotes a Spec

Braess Paradox [video]

TPC-DS Benchmark: Trino 476, Spark 4.0.0, and Hive 4 on MR3 2.1

Show HN: GenZ AI – Your Voice, but Fluent in Gen Z

Ask HN: Building for Joy vs. Building for Scale

OpenAI to Sponsor Driver Alex Palou at Mid-Ohio IndyCar Race

Learning F# with Falco: Response Localization

Why the superyachts are getting bigger and bigger

Aphrodisiac

Natasha Lyonne reveals David Lynch was a supporter of AI

Accelerate Legacy Application Modernization 4 times faster

Third Interstellar Object Discovered

David Romero's Digital Models of Frank Lloyd Wright's Unrealized Buildings

You People Keep Contradicting Yourselves

Windows 11 Start menu uses a 15 MB JSON for categories

2025 AsiaLLVM Developers' Meeting Talks

Open Co-Scientist Agents: Recreating Google's AI Co-Scientist in LangGraph

The Mechanic Johnny Cash and Elvis Would've Wanted (Toolbox Tour) [video]

What happens to your brain when you watch videos online at faster speeds

Is that a Lululemon Scuba hoodie or Costco dupe? No one has to know

Has Xbox Considered Laying One Person Off Instead of Thousands

Mr. Abrego's Account of Torture at CECOT in El Salvador

Adding keyword parameters to Tcl procs

Comments

Nothing's Untestable

Show HN: I made a social media platform

How to write Rust in the kernel part 1

CEOs Start Saying the Quiet Part Out Loud: AI Will Wipe Out Jobs

Debian on Apple M1/M2: status and call for testers

GitHub Copilot coding agent now has a Playwright web browser

Show HN: Piskvor Prime: a five-in-a-row iOS game with a reactive AI opponent

Show HN: Wyntk.ai – anti horseless carriage email

Give Footnotes a Spec

Braess Paradox [video]

TPC-DS Benchmark: Trino 476, Spark 4.0.0, and Hive 4 on MR3 2.1

Show HN: GenZ AI – Your Voice, but Fluent in Gen Z

Ask HN: Building for Joy vs. Building for Scale

OpenAI to Sponsor Driver Alex Palou at Mid-Ohio IndyCar Race

Learning F# with Falco: Response Localization

Why the superyachts are getting bigger and bigger

Aphrodisiac

Natasha Lyonne reveals David Lynch was a supporter of AI

Accelerate Legacy Application Modernization 4 times faster

Third Interstellar Object Discovered

David Romero's Digital Models of Frank Lloyd Wright's Unrealized Buildings

You People Keep Contradicting Yourselves

Windows 11 Start menu uses a 15 MB JSON for categories

2025 AsiaLLVM Developers' Meeting Talks

Open Co-Scientist Agents: Recreating Google's AI Co-Scientist in LangGraph

The Mechanic Johnny Cash and Elvis Would've Wanted (Toolbox Tour) [video]

What happens to your brain when you watch videos online at faster speeds

Is that a Lululemon Scuba hoodie or Costco dupe? No one has to know

Has Xbox Considered Laying One Person Off Instead of Thousands

Mr. Abrego's Account of Torture at CECOT in El Salvador