Researchers experimented on Reddit users with AI-generated comments

https://www.engadget.com/ai/researchers-secretly-experimented-on-reddit-users-with-ai-generated-comments-194328026.html

13•devrandoom•9mo ago

Comments

devrandoom•9mo ago

Reddit is furious, understandably.

I wonder if other groups are using AI to post on Reddit too?

feraloink•9mo ago

I wonder if other groups are using AI to post on HN too?

(Seems less likely than on reddit... TBQH)

krapp•9mo ago

Seems more likely to me. Reddit has a far broader userbase, whereas HN is primarily made up of the sort of people who would post with AI. And HN has a non rate-limited API (even though most people here probably use Algolia.)

And people already do paste comments from AI, it's becoming more and more common. At least they have the courtesy of pointing it out but I expect that will stop before the AI comments do.

morkalork•9mo ago

While I do love seeing the comments starting with "I asked ChatGPT..." get absolutely eviscerated in the replies and negatively voted, it is probably sending the wrong signal.

bigbadfeline•9mo ago

Bot farms rule the web. Bot-authored comments are everywhere, no less than 50%, regardless of site. Keep in mind, human-assisted bots have been used for the past 20 years but now the bots are a lot more productive thus the human part is largely quality control.

Fretting at the rare researchers who admit to their bot activity is like fretting at the criminals who admit guilt and praising those who don't.

feraloink•9mo ago

More seriously now, the Zurich researchers were very creepy. I'm reading the article further and saw that they stalked some of the past history of redditors first before trying to influence them in r/change my views or whatever it is called.

I wouldn't want to be a guinea pig for that purpose.

jrvieira•9mo ago

you already are

remram•9mo ago

I'm of two minds about this.

On the one hand, this is egregious and should not happen. People should not be stalked and lied to, and communities should not be manipulated at this scale.

On the other hand, it certainly already happens as it is incredibly easy for any group to use LLMs and do this. So the process and effectiveness should be studied and reported to the public... There might be a better way to do it though?

remram•9mo ago

Discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43806940 (238 points, 168 comments)

IAmGraydon•9mo ago

Reddit is nothing more than a social manipulation platform, and their feigned outrage at this is hilarious. They are absolutely complicit in allowing this very thing by allowing signups without any identity verification. They don't stop it because they know that a large percentage of their traffic is bots, and doing so would negatively impact the value of the company. So once again, the right thing is set aside for money.

Rewriting Pycparser with the Help of an LLM

Lobsters Vibecoding Challenge

E-Commerce vs. Social Commerce

Avoiding Modern C++ – Anton Mikhailov [video]

Show HN: AegisMind–AI system with 12 brain regions modeled on human neuroscience

Zig – Package Management Workflow Enhancements

AI-powered text correction for macOS

AppSecMaster – Learn Application Security with hands on challenges

Fibonacci Number Certificates

AI Overviews are killing the web search, and there's nothing we can do about it

City skylines need an upgrade in the face of climate stress

1979: The Model World of Robert Symes [video]

Satellites Have a Lot of Room

1980s Farm Crisis

Show HN: FSID - Identifier for files and directories (like ISBN for Books)

Show HN: Holy Grail: Open-Source Autonomous Development Agent

Show HN: Minecraft Creeper meets 90s Tamagotchi

Show HN: Termiteam – Control center for multiple AI agent terminals

The only U.S. particle collider shuts down

Ask HN: Why do purchased B2B email lists still have such poor deliverability?

Show HN: Remotion directory (videos and prompts)

Portable C Compiler

Show HN: Kokki – A "Dual-Core" System Prompt to Reduce LLM Hallucinations

Software Engineering Transformation 2026

Microsoft purges Win11 printer drivers, devices on borrowed time

Lunch with the FT: Tarek Mansour

Old Mexico and her lost provinces (1883)

'AI' is a dick move, redux

The source code was the moat. But not anymore

Does anyone else feel like their inbox has become their job?