Some people say AI IDEs might summarize or even trim prompt to reduce token input.
For example, the mentioned graph has "initial prompt with iterative tweaks", followed by iterations of 'starting from scratch'. -- I don't understand why you'd think "this is an ineffective way of doing things", and then keep doing it.
Describing LLMs as "slot machines" seems like the author has no curiosity about the shape of what LLMs can/can't do.
Answer is useful as is, and needS to be factually correct: Bad
This has often drawn similarities to a slot machine, the way it is not deterministic what code will come out, and what changes to which files will be made.
> AIs are sometimes good for code, sometimes not so good. I put some money in but don't know what code will come out, and it's so easy to put more money in. My friend told me to use Windsurf instead of Cursor, and it's easy to switch IDEs, they have no moat. Where's the moat?
AFAICT, that's the whole article.
In agent mode (need to enable it manually in settings), did anyone test forcing Copilot to run unit tests after code changes and fix code to pass tests if they break?
Arn_Thor•2h ago
jmisavage•2h ago
bitpush•2h ago
Isn't the situation similar to Brave et al built on top of Chromium but supports Chrome extensions?
elashri•2h ago
Hasnep•2h ago
There are open source alternatives, the basedpyright extension is better than Pylance and I've heard the clangd extension is good.
almostdeadguy•2h ago
RobinL•2h ago
jmisavage•2h ago
TuxSH•1h ago
For completion models: no, they retired gpt-35-codex, leaving only 4o-copilot.
From my experience (GH Copilot Pro with engaged_oss SKU, ie. for free), after they announced their "pricing changes", they also made the performance worse. The completions went from good, to actively distracting. tldr; they enshittified it / did a rugpull.
Right now, it is not worth paying for. ChatGPT Plus is far better value for money if you don't care about autocompletions/pure vibe coding.
graylien•2h ago
On the other hand, I think MS are pretty much cloning the good stuff from Cursor, like agent mode: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dutyOc_cAEU
Leaves me thinking VS Code might be the best in the long long run, but for now they're all kinda similar?
codelikeawolf•1h ago
Arn_Thor•2h ago
graylien•2h ago
Maybe Cursor/Windsurf could've just been plugins? Only Zed.ai seems really different of the popular IDEs
Arn_Thor•2h ago