frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: LLM is useless without explicit prompt

4•revskill•5mo ago
After months playing with LLM models, here's my observation:

- LLM is basically useless without explicit intent in your prompt.

- LLM failed to correct itself. If it generated bullshits, it's an inifinite loop of generating more bullshits.

The question is, without explicit prompt, could LLM leverage all the best practices to provide maintainable code without me instruct it at least ?

Comments

ben_w•5mo ago
Your expectations are way too high.

> - LLM is basically useless without explicit intent in your prompt.

You can say the same about every dev I've worked with, including myself. This is literally why humans have meetings rather than all of us diving in to whatever we're self-motivated to do.

What does differ is time-scales of the feedback loop with the management:

Humans meetings are daily to weekly.

According to recent research*, the state-of-the-art models are only 50% accurate at tasks that would take a human expert an hour, or 80% accurate at tasks that would take a human expert 10 minutes.

Even if the currently observed trend of increasing time horizons holds, we're 21 months from having an AI where every other daily standup is "ugh, no, you got it wrong", and just over 5 years from them being able to manage a 2-week sprint with an 80% chance of success (in the absence of continuous feedback).

Even that isn't really enough for them to properly "leverage all the best practices to provide maintainable code", as archiecture and maintainability are longer horizon tasks than 2-week sprints.

* https://youtu.be/evSFeqTZdqs?si=QIzIjB6hotJ0FgHm

revskill•5mo ago
It's not as high as you think.

LLM failed at the most basic things related to maintainable code. Its code is basicaly a hackery mess without any structure at all.

It's my expectation is that, at least, some kind of maintainable code is generated from what's it's learnt.

ben_w•5mo ago
Given your expectation:

> It's my expectation is that, at least, some kind of maintainable code is generated from what's it's learnt.

And your observation:

> LLM failed at the most basic things related to maintainable code. Its code is basicaly a hackery mess without any structure at all.

QED, *your expectations* are way too high.

They can't do that yet.

The US Shouldn't Need Another Warning on Rare Earths

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2025-10-27/us-shouldn-t-need-another-warning-on-china-...
1•wslh•50s ago•1 comments

Private loan credit ratings may be 'systematically' inflated, warns BIS

https://www.ft.com/content/9d1f4e49-5edc-4815-9efb-d4ef41756d72
1•zerosizedweasle•1m ago•1 comments

Agile and the Long Crisis of Software

https://logicmag.io/clouds/agile-and-the-long-crisis-of-software/
1•fanf2•3m ago•0 comments

LLMs Forget. Redprint Remembers

1•FlameArchitect•4m ago•0 comments

Joe Rosensteel: 'Creative Neglect: What About the Apps in Apple?'

https://sixcolors.com/post/2025/10/creative-neglect-what-about-the-apps-in-apple/
1•Bogdanp•4m ago•0 comments

The Core Components of Modern LLMs and the Models Beyond Transformers [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lONyteDR4XE
1•ModelForge•5m ago•0 comments

Fame Creator

https://www.fame-creator.com
1•bellamoon544•6m ago•1 comments

Stanislaw Lem's Imaginary Magnitude

https://www.superdoomedplanet.com/blog/2025/06/22/on-stanislaw-lems-imaginary-magnitude/
1•speckx•6m ago•0 comments

TARmageddon Compromises Rust Security: A Developer's Guide

https://thenewstack.io/how-tarmageddon-compromises-rust-security-a-developers-guide/
1•CrankyBear•8m ago•0 comments

Qualcomm announces new chips for AI accelerators

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-10-27/qualcomm-unveils-chip-to-rival-nvidia-in-ai-ac...
3•imaginaryunit01•9m ago•0 comments

The PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program

https://www.reddit.com/r/Python/s/n632qP1DwH
1•csoham•14m ago•1 comments

Austrian Power Giants

https://www.apg.at/en/projects/austrian-power-giants-1/
1•geox•14m ago•0 comments

Zhao's Binance Aided Trump Family Crypto Venture Before Pardon

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-10-27/pardon-of-cz-how-binance-founder-aided-trump-f...
11•zerosizedweasle•15m ago•2 comments

Kilauea's lava soared as high as a skyscraper during a 6-hour eruption

https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/kilauea-is-erupting-again-on-hawaii-s-big-island-21078749.php
1•PaulHoule•16m ago•0 comments

History's first public hack: rats, rats, rats

https://www.rigb.org/explore-science/explore/blog/historys-first-public-hack-rats-rats-rats
1•ohjeez•16m ago•0 comments

Cirrus Labs Enforces Its Fair Source License

https://tart.run/blog/2025/10/27/press-release-cirrus-labs-successfully-enforces-its-fair-source-...
3•latexr•16m ago•0 comments

Show HN: I Made My First Movie About a Tech Startup for $2,045 [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ottt_qTr2No
2•andreas-schrade•16m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Whatdidido – CLI to summarize your work from Jira/Linear

https://github.com/oliviersm199/whatdidido
2•olism•17m ago•0 comments

The Renaissance of written coding conventions: Because AI reads manuals, too

https://www.brokenrobot.xyz/blog/the-renaissance-of-written-coding-conventions/
2•ulimn•17m ago•0 comments

Western Union says its core business of money transfers in the U.S. is down

https://www.npr.org/2025/10/24/nx-s1-5584062/western-union-says-its-core-business-of-money-transf...
4•nonethewiser•17m ago•0 comments

It's insulting to read your AI-generated blog post

https://blog.pabloecortez.com/its-insulting-to-read-your-ai-generated-blog-post/
6•speckx•18m ago•0 comments

I thought cheap products get more users. I was wrong

2•nookeshkarri7•18m ago•0 comments

Could Covid-19 mRNA vaccines also fight cancer?

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/10/27/could-covid-19-mrna-vaccines-help-fight-cancer
2•RankingMember•18m ago•0 comments

AI guardrails for Terraform. Create using natural language. Enforce in the PR

https://tryterracotta.com
4•gtlpanda•19m ago•0 comments

Review of "Stop the machines: The rise of anti-technology extremism"

https://jacobin.com/2025/10/anti-technology-ecofascism-lubrano-review
1•scythe•19m ago•1 comments

Can We Fix Social Media? Testing Prosocial Interventions Using Social Simulation

https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.03385
1•JnBrymn•21m ago•0 comments

What little I want out of web "passkeys" in my environment

https://utcc.utoronto.ca/~cks/space/blog/web/PasskeysWhatIWant
1•speckx•22m ago•0 comments

Image-generating AIs are being used for fake expense reports

https://arstechnica.com/ai/2025/10/ai-generated-receipts-make-submitting-fake-expenses-easier/
1•alecco•23m ago•0 comments

Nomoji – replace emojis in text with SVG images

https://github.com/pakastin/nomoji
1•pkstn•23m ago•1 comments

We Need More Programmers, Not Fewer

https://juanreyero.com/article/ai/we-need-more-programmers
2•juanre•24m ago•0 comments