frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: LLM is useless without explicit prompt

4•revskill•1y ago
After months playing with LLM models, here's my observation:

- LLM is basically useless without explicit intent in your prompt.

- LLM failed to correct itself. If it generated bullshits, it's an inifinite loop of generating more bullshits.

The question is, without explicit prompt, could LLM leverage all the best practices to provide maintainable code without me instruct it at least ?

Comments

ben_w•1y ago
Your expectations are way too high.

> - LLM is basically useless without explicit intent in your prompt.

You can say the same about every dev I've worked with, including myself. This is literally why humans have meetings rather than all of us diving in to whatever we're self-motivated to do.

What does differ is time-scales of the feedback loop with the management:

Humans meetings are daily to weekly.

According to recent research*, the state-of-the-art models are only 50% accurate at tasks that would take a human expert an hour, or 80% accurate at tasks that would take a human expert 10 minutes.

Even if the currently observed trend of increasing time horizons holds, we're 21 months from having an AI where every other daily standup is "ugh, no, you got it wrong", and just over 5 years from them being able to manage a 2-week sprint with an 80% chance of success (in the absence of continuous feedback).

Even that isn't really enough for them to properly "leverage all the best practices to provide maintainable code", as archiecture and maintainability are longer horizon tasks than 2-week sprints.

* https://youtu.be/evSFeqTZdqs?si=QIzIjB6hotJ0FgHm

revskill•1y ago
It's not as high as you think.

LLM failed at the most basic things related to maintainable code. Its code is basicaly a hackery mess without any structure at all.

It's my expectation is that, at least, some kind of maintainable code is generated from what's it's learnt.

ben_w•1y ago
Given your expectation:

> It's my expectation is that, at least, some kind of maintainable code is generated from what's it's learnt.

And your observation:

> LLM failed at the most basic things related to maintainable code. Its code is basicaly a hackery mess without any structure at all.

QED, *your expectations* are way too high.

They can't do that yet.

TIME Magazine used QuarkXPress on Mac OS 9... in 2007

https://web.archive.org/web/20150913185212fw_/http://www.digitalartsonline.co.uk/features/creativ...
1•GaryBluto•3m ago•1 comments

Mario Kart World running natively on an iPhone 18 Pro

https://twitter.com/willfaustcuber/status/2115258064844857595
1•LelouBil•4m ago•0 comments

Outrage after airport self-service checkout asks for 18% tip

https://www.the-independent.com/life-style/self-service-airport-tipping-culture-b3075115.html
3•bcaulfield•5m ago•0 comments

Ask HN

1•bigseleb•6m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Chinese and Western Zodiac Calculator

https://zodia.cl/
1•walshcl•7m ago•0 comments

Rogue OpenAI agents targeted three separate US Government websites

https://www.cnn.com/2026/09/26/tech/openai-agents-rogue-government-websites
1•CGMthrowaway•8m ago•0 comments

Taming Intel's "Brain Damaged" Chip

https://nemanjatrifunovic.substack.com/p/taming-intels-brain-damaged-chip
1•whobre•9m ago•0 comments

OK, Zoomer: You're the First Human Surplus Generation

https://newrepublic.com/article/216462/ok-zoomer-youre-first-human-surplus-generation
1•littlexsparkee•13m ago•0 comments

Banks Shelve Bond Sale for Anthropic-Tied Texas Data Center

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-28/banks-shelve-bond-sale-for-anthropic-tied-texa...
3•angry_impala•13m ago•0 comments

The Shift of Theseus – Toy Bit Provenance Abstract Domain

https://pypy.org/posts/2026/10/toy-bit-provenance.html
1•stosssik•17m ago•0 comments

Weil Gotshal to Wind Down in Shock Fall for Heavyweight Firm

https://news.bloomberglaw.com/business-and-practice/weil-gotshal-to-wind-down-in-stunning-fall-fo...
1•dsubburam•18m ago•0 comments

The OpenAI-Hugging Face incident broke three operational resilience assumptions

https://jamiewatters.work/journey/three-assumptions-agentic-resilience
1•TheWayWithin•20m ago•0 comments

Mirendil Launches Lor Harness

https://mirendil.com/news/meet-lor/
1•yuedongze•21m ago•0 comments

What it means to let go

https://sashachapin.substack.com/p/what-it-actually-means-to-let-go
1•eatitraw•21m ago•0 comments

Against Against Handover

https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/against-against-handover
1•eatitraw•22m ago•0 comments

Claude Code found 145K photos I deleted from my iPhone sitting in a hidden cache

https://twitter.com/coolerwave/status/2114088769112477849
18•CGMthrowaway•24m ago•0 comments

Website migration costs are going to zero

https://dri.es/website-migration-costs-are-going-to-zero
2•geerlingguy•27m ago•0 comments

Deus Ex Machina

https://blog.coredump.cx/p/deus-ex-machina
1•surprisetalk•28m ago•0 comments

Our AI Agent Executed the Same Successful SQL Query 254 Times

https://armincat.com/articles/ai-agent-executed-same-query-254-times
2•armcat•28m ago•0 comments

There Are Too Many Apps for That

https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/2026/10/vibe-coders-are-clogging-app-store-slop/689150/
2•samizdis•29m ago•0 comments

What HTTP/HTTPS debugging proxy to use

https://novawire.dev/#compare
1•vewello•30m ago•0 comments

AI execs may be too out of touch to build for the general public

https://techcrunch.com/2026/10/28/ai-execs-may-be-too-out-of-touch-to-build-for-the-general-public/
2•pavel_lishin•31m ago•0 comments

Postgres 19 is Late, and it's AI's Fault

https://neon.com/blog/postgres-19-is-late-and-its-ais-fault
1•sorentwo•32m ago•0 comments

Open AI Math Proofs modified sandbox

https://zenodo.org/records/23717719
2•starrwoodstudio•32m ago•0 comments

Why America's educational experiment didn't transform schools

https://www.apmreports.org/story/2026/10/22/project-follow-through-educational-experiment-didnt-t...
1•bcaulfield•34m ago•0 comments

Hypothetical Emergency Scenarios from US Election Assistance Commission

https://harpers.org/archive/2026/11/margin-terror-polls-2026-election/
1•bobbiechen•34m ago•0 comments

Court Should Curb Abuse of Grand Jury Subpoenas Targeting Social Media Users

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2026/10/court-should-curb-abuse-grand-jury-subpoenas-targeting-soci...
3•hn_acker•34m ago•0 comments

Chatbots Have to Deal with Election Lies Being Free, While Truth Is Paywalled

https://www.techdirt.com/2026/10/28/never-mind-the-deepfakes-chatbots-have-to-deal-with-election-...
3•hn_acker•35m ago•1 comments

Discovering and exploiting vulnerabilities in real-world software with Claude

https://www.anthropic.com/research/discovering-vulnerabilities-with-claude
2•rzk•37m ago•0 comments

The Brutal Harvard Class That Suddenly Everyone Wants to Take

https://www.wsj.com/lifestyle/harvard-class-humanities-32e06366
1•bcaulfield•38m ago•0 comments