frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

Lianas are taking over the rainforests, and it's visible from space

https://phys.org/news/2025-05-lianas-rainforests-visible-space.html
42•stevenjgarner•3d ago

Comments

verisimi•5h ago
> He attributes this to rising atmospheric CO₂ levels. "All plants grow faster with more CO₂, but lianas benefit even more

And yet this extra growth all around because of co2 means that the will be more co2? This seems incoherent.

Pet peeve - if the article hooks you with a line like 'visible from space' they should provide the imagery so I can see for myself. But there's no picture.

bcraven•5h ago
The previous paragraph explains it:

>Lianas are rapidly expanding their territory in tropical forests, sometimes suppressing tree growth entirely in certain locations. In such areas, forest regeneration halts, and carbon storage can decline by as much as 95%. "That's almost equivalent to deforestation," Visser says.

There's more more CO₂ in the atmosphere; so more lianas grow; they choke out the main tree body; so less CO₂ is absorbed; so there's more CO₂ in the atmosphere, _e.t.c._

credit_guy•1h ago
Still, this does not sound right. You are hinting towards some predator-prey-type of cycle: trees grow (and absorb CO2), lianas infest them (and by the way, they appear to absorb even more CO2), but then trees die, and lianas die with them. But then won't trees grow again, and the cycle would repeat? Maybe overall, this cycle would reduce some CO2 absorption, but by 95%?
bcraven•26m ago
There's some interesting results here[0] but from what I can make out the trees don't necessarily die and take the liana(s) with them. They may continue to stand (dead) or may simply be hugely starved of light.

[0]https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.13...

ucyo•5h ago
Came here for this … “Big foot caught on camera!!” - all text article …
bcraven•5h ago
https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ecy....

Figure 1

seangrogg•5h ago
I don't think that really counts as a "picture from space" in common parlance, but I guess maybe a picture from Euclidean space?
bcraven•4h ago
"visible in satellite imagery" is the quote in the article, which is refined in the paper as:

Stand scale (900-m2 scale) data used satellite imagery from previous studies to contrast liana-infested and liana-sparse forest patches in Bolivia and French Guiana. In both cases, we obtained the original images used, which included a 30-m resolution Landsat Thematic Mapper (L1TP) image (French Guiana) and hyperspectral Hyperion imagery from NASA's EO-1 satellite (Bolivia).

FrustratedMonky•5h ago
I agree, wanted a pic.

But for CO2. Guess they didn't spell it out. If the Lianas kill the tree, and the Lianas absorb less CO2 than a tree, then even though there is an increase in Liana growth, there is also less tree growth, so net less CO2 absorbed.

relaxing•2h ago
It’s not just the tree, it’s everything that grew below the canopy that now can’t because the vines block out all the sunlight.
seszett•5h ago
> And yet this extra growth all around because of co2 means that the will be more co2? This seems incoherent.

If trees die (because of the lianas) faster than they grow, it's not impossible at all.

Nature generally balances itself (with more CO2 getting balanced by more plant growth) on the long term, not necessarily on the short term.

speedgoose•5h ago
Small statistical deviations on satellite imagery isn’t necessarily very sexy for popular science. Especially when it’s in the non visible light spectrum, Landsat and Sentinel-2 satellites have bands that are great for analysing vegetation, but they are not very beautiful when converted to colours visible to humans.

A quick check from the referenced papers only mention a 2008 dataset from Landsat in a meta analysis. And no fancy pictures to look at.

neltnerb•4h ago
Yeah, the article is bait.

The original research just says "Global increase of lianas in tropical forests", the addition of "from space" is to get clicks here.

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/gcb.17485

That's the better link to use for this anyway. It's open access so no reason not to go to the source.

It appears to be heavily statistical and based on scraping many studies for a meta analysis.

"Our meta-analysis resulted in 505 effect sizes (ES) extracted from 39 unique studies (Figure 2). An initial exploratory analysis following the vote counting approach showed a general trend of increasing liana prevalence throughout the tropics is evinced by 333 positive ES (66%) compared to 172 ES (34%) with decreasing or stable trends. After grouping ES per life stage and aggregating the results reported at the species level, 155 ES and their respective standard errors (SE) were obtained. The general increasing pattern and its geographical coverage hold for the reduced dataset, with 112 ES (72%) showing an increasing trend."

ekianjo•3h ago
> But there's no picture.

There is no picture because they are not visible from space. They are refering to a model that estimate their presence from satellite images. Which is not what people understand by "visible".

quaintdev•5h ago
> The leaves that make lianas ultra-efficient reflect more light and infrared radiation than tree foliage.

> "Tree leaves tilt, allowing light to reach lower neighbors—even the forest floor gets some sunlight. But lianas leave almost nothing for others."

But that seems like a mechanism that could help reduce rising temperature

casey2•5h ago
Trees have nothing to do with global warming. It is entirely caused by coal and oil. The only meaningful carbon storage would be pumping it back into the ground.

Let's not personify and demonize vines as a casus belli to destroy the environment in the name of saving it, please.

adammarples•4h ago
Trees have a lot to do with it, they are made of carbon and they absorb tons of it. They also pump it back into the soil.
thom•4h ago
The article ends:

> Can anything be done about the liana problem? Should we start cutting them down? Definitely not, says Visser. "We shouldn't intervene until we fully understand their ecological role. They bear fruit year-round and are vital for rare monkey and bird species." The only necessary action, he insists, is halting climate change, which will also slow the expansion of lianas.

sigmaisaletter•4h ago
> Trees have nothing to do with global warming

Citation needed

>Let's not personify and demonize vines

who is personifying and demonizing vines? again, citation needed

MrBuddyCasino•3h ago
Trees are our best bet: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43936450
nenadg•4h ago
Can't wait to pay taxes on lianas
sebmellen•4h ago
Tapeworms of the rainforest… ugh.
metalman•3h ago
There is a tree that survives lightning strikes, and thrives, because the lightning kills all the surrounding lianas, and also other competing trees. https://www.npr.org/2025/04/11/nx-s1-5357412/lightning-tree-...
arthurofbabylon•3h ago
Useful context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liana

> “The word liana does not refer to a taxonomic grouping, but rather a habit of plant growth – much like tree or shrub.“

ekianjo•3h ago
> it's visible from space (phys.org)

Misleading headline again (this is a pattern), they are not visible from space, they can be estimated based on satellite images using a complex model. That's not at all what common people understand by "visible".

jachac•3h ago
I'm also just about visible from space at 30cm resolution

https://microsites.maxar.com/30cm/

padjo•3h ago
Lots of things are visible from space, it’s just a question of magnification.
bregma•2h ago
Zoom. Enhance.
defrost•1h ago
> they are not visible from space, they can be estimated based on satellite images using a complex model.

Much like a human brain estimates or imagines an image based on a complex model transformation of sensor data from various cones arrayed within the eyes.

Here we have a straightforward, readily pipelined, multispectral transformation that combines 'colours' from the non (human) visible part of the greater spectrum and creates a shifted blended colour image in the human eye visible part of the spectrum such that target vegetation is prominent.

In the remote sensing domain calling such things visible has been common parlance for three decades.

It's similar to that trope scene in action films that has a sniper using a thermal filter to enhance body heat for better target imaging.

graemep•2h ago
> "All plants grow faster with more CO₂, but lianas benefit even more."

I have read other articles (by climate scientists) that say that the increase on CO₂ is not sufficient for this to be significant.

> "We shouldn't intervene until we fully understand their ecological role"

Given the dramatic damage he says it is doing in some areas, surely cutting them in at least those areas would make sense?

vasco•2h ago
> Given the dramatic damage he says it is doing in some areas, surely cutting them in at least those areas would make sense?

You being personally convinced about something doesn't mean you can't be aware of your own limitations and want to be careful about implementing solutions too early to limit their impact of you're wrong.

The difference is clear when you give an opinion about someone else's problems and how they should proceed vs when you have to decide about your own life. It's harder to implement change when you have to live with the consequences.

graemep•2h ago
Yes, but which is the lesser risk then?

There seems to be a bias to do nothing rather than do something even if there are known benefits to doing something.

There are definitely lots of consequences to lots of things we have done with regard to climate change and pollution. If we avoided everything with consequences the only action is do nothing.

> The difference is clear when you give an opinion about someone else's problems

The global environment is everyone's problem, surely?

vasco•2h ago
> The global environment is everyone's problem, surely?

That's my point, it falls in the "you have to live with it" category.

adrian_b•1h ago
The effect depends on the plant and on its environment.

While more CO2 is good for plants, the associated changes in temperature and humidity can be bad and they can counterbalance the effect of increased CO2.

There has been a recently published study, for which I cannot remember a link, which has evaluated the current effects of the climate change for 7 major plant crops. For 3 of them, including rice, increased CO2 has resulted in higher productions, but for other 4, including maize, the associated changes in air temperature and humidity has determined lower productions, despite the higher availability of CO2.

austin-cheney•2h ago
I have observed the exact same scenario in the southern US all my life except the vines are mustang grapevines.

Show HN: Printstack – I'll print and post your Substacks to you

https://printstack.net/for-readers
1•mbanerjeepalmer•2m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How do early-stage builders solve the distribution problem in a AI era?

1•grandimam•4m ago•0 comments

Clearly Incorrect

https://quarter--mile.com/Clearly-Incorrect
1•surprisetalk•7m ago•0 comments

A MAZE. / Berlin – 14th international games and playful media festival

https://2025.amaze-berlin.de/
2•jansan•7m ago•0 comments

Psalm v6 Deep Dive: Copy-on-Write and dynamic task dispatching

https://blog.daniil.it/2025/05/11/psalm-v6-deep-dive-copy-on-write-dynamic-task-dispatching/
1•danogentili•8m ago•0 comments

Wrkspace – 1-Click Dev Environments That Boot in Under 5 Seconds

https://wrkspace.co
1•mfcmatheus•9m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Save hours after networking events with this AI business card organizer

https://www.cardviz.com/
1•VarunGuptaHAI•9m ago•1 comments

CatDoes – Words to Native Apps

https://catdoes.com/
1•nafisehamiri•10m ago•1 comments

Psalm v6 Announcement

https://blog.daniil.it/2025/05/11/psalm-v6-announcement/
1•danogentili•11m ago•0 comments

An Infinite Number of Leaflike Skins: How Nadar Captured Paris

https://worldhistory.substack.com/p/an-infinite-number-of-leaflike-skins
1•crescit_eundo•12m ago•0 comments

OpenAI negotiates with Microsoft to unlock new funding and future IPO

https://www.ft.com/content/8d9e5149-7e4f-4886-a035-9d200204972a
2•Alezz•19m ago•0 comments

AI Revolution vs. Industrial Revolution

https://machinocene.substack.com/p/ai-revolution-vs-industrial-revolution
1•gHeadphone•20m ago•0 comments

Wisdom Without Words

https://fakepixels.substack.com/p/wisdom-without-words
3•jger15•20m ago•0 comments

The New Pope Wants to Take on AI

https://gizmodo.com/the-new-pope-wants-to-take-on-ai-2000600652
4•rntn•20m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Vector Charts – Add Nautical Charts to Your Web App

https://vectorcharts.com/
2•chrisdalke•22m ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Examples of continuous work agent templates

1•viraptor•29m ago•0 comments

AI Growth Strategies for Founders and Solopreneurs

1•businessmate•29m ago•1 comments

Claim of alien life on distant world meets swift scientific pushback

https://www.science.org/content/article/claim-alien-life-distant-world-meets-swift-scientific-pushback
3•merksittich•30m ago•0 comments

The Joint Commission and Palantir Technologies Announce Strategic Partnership

https://investors.palantir.com/news-details/2025/The-Joint-Commission-and-Palantir-Technologies-Announce-Strategic-Partnership-to-Elevate-Patient-Safety-and-Healthcare-Standards/
1•bookofjoe•34m ago•0 comments

Palantir built the ultimate founder factory – Nabeel S. Qureshi

https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/inside-palantir-nabeel-qureshi
1•jger15•36m ago•0 comments

Trump admin poised to accept luxury jet as gift for Trump from Qatar

https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/trump-administration-poised-accept-palace-sky-gift-trump/story?id=121680511
6•jaredwiener•41m ago•3 comments

CForge v2.0.0-beta: Rust Engine Rewrite in C++

https://old.reddit.com/r/cpp/comments/1kjrt90/cforge_v200beta_rust_engine_rewrite/
1•npalli•42m ago•1 comments

Genes Play a Key Role in Timing of Baby's First Steps

https://geekoo.news/genes-play-a-key-role-in-timing-of-babys-first-steps/
1•lentoutcry•44m ago•0 comments

Still Using Calendly Links?

https://schedo.app/
5•chetansorted•48m ago•4 comments

The Transaction Concept: Virtues and Limitations (1981) [pdf]

https://jimgray.azurewebsites.net/papers/thetransactionconcept.pdf
1•pramodbiligiri•48m ago•0 comments

Show HN: MobileAnalytics.io - I fixed App Store Connect

https://mobileanalytics.io/
3•mbelen•52m ago•1 comments

Implementing a Shared Mutex for ActiveJob

https://shivam.dev/blog/activejob-mutex
1•shivam-dev•53m ago•0 comments

Critique my (minimalist) personal webpage

https://www.timokats.xyz/
2•furrball010•57m ago•7 comments

Klarna flip from AI-first to hiring people again, Survey Reveal AI projects fail

https://fortune.com/2025/05/09/klarna-ai-humans-return-on-investment/
15•amarcheschi•58m ago•4 comments

Ask HN: I want to give coding AIs a fair shot, where do I start?

3•thiht•1h ago•1 comments