frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Xkcd's "Is It Worth the Time?" Considered Harmful

https://will-keleher.com/posts/its-not-worth-the-time-yet.html
27•gcmeplz•1y ago

Comments

jjk166•1y ago
XKCD's comic is a very simple graphic that tells you whether your automation efforts will reduce the total amount of time for a task.

If your goal is not to reduce time spent, why would you be looking at a chart to determine how much time you're reducing?

Learning is a very good use of time. Choosing to spend extra time to automate something for the sake of learning is a perfectly rational decision. But it's never harmful to know what your choice is costing you. If you wouldn't be willing to automate something in the full knowledge that it's going to take longer than just doing it manually, then the comic is succeeding in stopping you from making a choice you wouldn't want to make.

arcfour•1y ago
My boss would probably prefer—thinking short-term—that I work by that chart. I would prefer to learn something new, and it usually pays off in the long-term, possibly years from now in unexpected and unforeseeable ways.
banku_brougham•1y ago
Yup if I followed team/management guidance I would be nowhere.
jjk166•1y ago
"This may help in unexpected and unforeseeable ways" doesn't sound like the most convincing argument for taking time from your job to learn a new skill.

All the same, you are choosing to learn something new, not to automate something to save time. Learning something new by automating a task which doesn't justify automation is no different from say reading a book or doing coding exercises in the same time - it's potentially a good use of your time, it just doesn't relate to the xkcd chart at all.

patrakov•1y ago
Key sentence from the article:

> Automating the easy things is how you build the skills, mindset, and muscle-memory to automate the hard things.

hicksyfern•1y ago
The counter to that is that going and looking at the call sites to that function would have given the author a better understanding of what those call sites were, why they called the function, etc, thus learning more about the codebase.
abc-1•1y ago
The goal to automate is to reduce suffering. Full stop. It’s not to “save time”. STEM types like to pretend they’re stoic cold calculating robots and everything is objective and they don’t mind doing some repetitive 5 minute task every day, because they saw some xkcd comic about efficiency. Maybe they pretend they don’t mind simply so they can smugly post the xkcd comic every time someone new asks why they’re suffering through some repetitive slog.
banku_brougham•1y ago
exactly. work can be fun and there is so much to learn.
try_the_bass•1y ago
Harmful? No. Good rule of thumb? Yeah. Like any rule of thumb, if followed dogmatically, it loses the nuance that makes it a good "rule of thumb".
add-sub-mul-div•1y ago
Right. Almost nothing should be followed dogmatically, but a major theme of this site is to act like all advice was meant to be taken as gospel and then counter it with mundane exceptions.
karmakaze•1y ago
> ...updating the order of arguments to a function [...] was only in about 10 spots, so it would have only taken a minute to search and fix manually, but instead I spent an hour automating the fix using sed and xargs. And I think that was the right choice.

Spending an hour to learn and use sed/xargs is good use of time. Bringing in the xkcd formula has nothing to do with that. It could/should have been done as a one-off whether manually or scripted. Automation doesn't make sense unless you plan to keep putting me function arguments in an undesired order.

I would have put in time sooner to use a static typed language the can reliably reactor in the IDE with a click.

dontreact•1y ago
The flip side of this is that for some tasks (especially in ml/ai), doing it manually at least a few times gives you a sense of what is correct and a better sense of detail.

For example, spending the time to label a few examples yourself instead of just blindly sending it out to labeling.

(Not always the case, but another thing to keep in mind besides total time saved and value of learning)

more_corn•1y ago
“Considered harmful” is considered harmful
V__•1y ago
> Automating the easy things is how you build the skills, mindset, and muscle-memory to automate the hard things.

I agree with the statement, yet I think it misses the point. Hyperbole: Pressing play on a mp3 robs you of the experience of learning to play all instruments yourself. They key question is whether automating is a task one wants to improve in at all.

phendrenad2•1y ago
I agree. The author spent an hour of trying to use 'sed', and the next time, they thought better and used Python! That's a valuable lesson right there! ;)
al_borland•1y ago
There is also the situation where if it doesn’t get automated, it won’t be done at all. Some things are just too annoying to manually do, especially if it would be nice if they were done more than once.

There is also an aspect of repeatability without mistakes. Assuming the code is good, it removes the human error from the equation, which has value.

atoav•1y ago
This is about tasks you automate to save time, that however isn't the only reason to automate a task.

A big one for me is to ensure consistency of data, intervals, etc.

banku_brougham•1y ago
Every day you are building the foundation for the rest of your career. When I can I execute tasks as though need to scale and be instrumented with alarms.

Poe Toaster

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe_Toaster
1•networked•37s ago•0 comments

My Empire of Dirt

https://geohot.github.io//blog/jekyll/update/2026/11/17/my-empire-of-dirt.html
1•bsgada•42s ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Anyone else feeling burnout from agentic coding?

1•lostaccount•5m ago•0 comments

Will AGI benefit the average American? [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSin8S2U5xU
1•newuser94303•9m ago•1 comments

What does Claude thinks of the IPO? [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LvqLsBBL_zY
1•newuser94303•13m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Harness for building/cloning SaaS using open-weight models

https://neander.ai/
1•kushjoy•16m ago•1 comments

We don't need no education platform evolution

https://www.theregister.com/columnists/2026/11/16/we-dont-need-no-education-platform-evolution-he...
1•zombot•18m ago•0 comments

Pi-memory: persistent memory extension for pi

https://github.com/jayzeng/pi-memory
1•_kb•21m ago•0 comments

Adopting AI inside an organization that has to pass a compliance audit

https://zimmergren.net/ai-and-compliance/
2•zimmergren•25m ago•0 comments

AI Slop Spiral

https://nolanfrausto.com/posts/ai-slop-spiral/
2•frausto•25m ago•0 comments

Android Fast Switch looks like Google's answer to iPhone Handoff

https://www.androidauthority.com/android-fast-switch-handoff-3735737/
2•thunderbong•31m ago•0 comments

40-domain study: 80% of Shopify stores expose /API/ucp/MCP, 0% /agents.md

https://verisource.dev/benchmarks/ai-search-readiness-2026
2•kulinichnick•34m ago•0 comments

I built GURU. The open source ultimate hacker tool ANYBODY can use

https://github.com/GuruProduction/GURUbyUnusLumen
3•introducingGURU•34m ago•0 comments

Anyone Uses Perplexity? and for What?

2•aashu_bel•36m ago•0 comments

What Is the Internet?

https://www.tinylogger.com/max/f6DDYMm6gJRDDgXl
1•kurinikku•38m ago•0 comments

Maxwell V1 Flash

https://huggingface.co/maxwell-model/Maxwell-V1-Flash
1•ByteAtATime•39m ago•0 comments

Clarification Statement on Wall Street Journal's Article

https://www.mha.gov.sg/media-room/newsroom/clarification-statement-on-wall-street-journals-article/
2•aurareturn•40m ago•0 comments

15M emails and documents reveal the dark secrets of Deutsche Bank

https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/unternehmen/deutsche-bank-datenleak-inside-deutsche-bank-enthue...
3•doener•41m ago•0 comments

Rex Demo: Remote Copy/Paste, Drag/Drop, and Port Forwarding [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkH_WJApzH0
1•nikolay•41m ago•0 comments

The Productivity Trap

https://lindbakk.com/blog/the-productivity-trap
1•atomfinger•42m ago•0 comments

Claude Code Course: Credits Included

1•feynmansletters•43m ago•0 comments

Mizan bias benchmark: testing AI models

https://mizan.techforpalestine.org/hostage-or-detainee/
1•k1m•44m ago•0 comments

TokenEconomizer: Learning from Experience to Make AI Coding Agents Efficient

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/blog/tokeneconomizer-learning-from-experience-to-make-ai...
1•matt_d•45m ago•0 comments

OVH releases first model with EU public funding and supercomputer access

https://twitter.com/olesovhcom/status/2122573582911869173
6•noplay•48m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Groovyfmt, a fast formatter for Groovy, Gradle and Jenkinsfiles

https://github.com/costajohnt/groovyfmt
1•costajohnt•48m ago•0 comments

Trump's stake in Nvidia grew to as much as $62M before scandal broke out

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2026/11/16/trumps-stake-nvidia-grew-much-62-million-befor...
1•doener•50m ago•0 comments

Sacha Baron Cohen Emails Sheryl Sandberg

https://twitter.com/TechEmails/status/2121994481797136583
2•theanonymousone•50m ago•0 comments

OpenScientist: An Open AI System That Automates Biomedical Research

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-026-04808-6
1•tibastral2•51m ago•0 comments

Building a Rust-Native, Cross-Language Foundation for Agentic ML Compilers

https://tvm.apache.org/2026/11/16/rust-native-cross-language-ml-compiler-foundation
1•matt_d•52m ago•0 comments

Collatz Conjecture (2022)

https://zerolimits.dev/blog/collatz-conjecture
1•sammatilda•55m ago•0 comments