Ask HN: Which function definition keyword do you prefer, def or fn?

1•winwang•1y ago

I'm curious about what people think of `def` vs `fn`, two short keywords for starting function definitions.

...Or maybe we should subscribe to the church of `df`, haha.

Comments

sitkack•1y ago

def could be for lots of things, fn is for functions. I don't think it matters much as long as you have one. C would have been so much easier to parse. Just copy Zig or Rust.

butlersean•1y ago

def means define, could be used to define all kinds of things

fn isnt a legitimate short form of function

fun doesnt work because of the amusement factor

func is the only alternative we have left

sitkack•1y ago

How about unicode or emojis?

These don't have the full fidelity as hn scrubs emojis

add = (a, b) -> a + b

a, b ⟹ a + b

λ add(a, b): ↪ a + b

johncoltrane•1y ago

"def" is too generic.

"fn" is too cryptic.

"function" is better than the two.

MultifokalHirn•1y ago

Agreed

Recover lost text by coredumping Firefox

Why Weak Americans Run Towards Fascism

Patching PHP 7.4 for php2shell in a container

Proton says lawful-access bill makes expansion into Canada 'impossible'

Rust off Rails: The opinionated web stack for the AI era

Mine Rogue. Vibe-coded balatro-inspired minesweeper roguelike game

Show HN: Open-source site base plans from any US address

Recursive Introduces Flint Model

Show HN: A job search that only shows entry-level roles

Quantum error correction goes well beyond breakeven

OpenAI Says 2 Internal AI Coding Agents Turned Off Their Own Safeguards

Ask HN: Mathematicians are rarely the best math teachers but why

Some Initial Thoughts on Nick Cammarata's "Neural Networks Are Clean"

Show HN: NiFT – Frictionless, Fast, Note taking app

Amazon deforestation falls 42% to a record low

Ask HN: How can you retrain in a field requiring expensive equipment?

Show HN: Riff – An iPhone calendar you zoom instead of switching views

Full transaction detection for Cloudflare WAF

An in-browser PDF editor that reconstructs pages into editable DOM

Your Sites Are Protected Against the PHP2Shell Vulnerabilities

AbyssDB · Infinitely fast. Perfectly consistent. Zero-knowledge

Does anyone want to win the medium-lift race in the United States?

Pretraining at scale without a pretraining team

GPT-6 Astra removes an internal safety monitor

Sripe Treasury for Agents

A gate that rejects end_turn while a Civ VI agent's victory check is overdue

New plastic pollution discovered: 'Plasticorals' coral rubble fused with plastic

OXR – An RSI-trained 1.3B open-source SOTA document parsing model

Be careful using on delete cascade too much

Cost-Bounded Bitcoin Transaction Filtering Language