Ask HN: Which function definition keyword do you prefer, def or fn?

1•winwang•11mo ago

I'm curious about what people think of `def` vs `fn`, two short keywords for starting function definitions.

...Or maybe we should subscribe to the church of `df`, haha.

Comments

sitkack•11mo ago

def could be for lots of things, fn is for functions. I don't think it matters much as long as you have one. C would have been so much easier to parse. Just copy Zig or Rust.

butlersean•11mo ago

def means define, could be used to define all kinds of things

fn isnt a legitimate short form of function

fun doesnt work because of the amusement factor

func is the only alternative we have left

sitkack•11mo ago

How about unicode or emojis?

These don't have the full fidelity as hn scrubs emojis

add = (a, b) -> a + b

a, b ⟹ a + b

λ add(a, b): ↪ a + b

johncoltrane•11mo ago

"def" is too generic.

"fn" is too cryptic.

"function" is better than the two.

MultifokalHirn•11mo ago

Agreed

Helium Is Hard to Replace

Show HN: I created a leaderboard converting your LOC into garrytans. COPE

Born Private: Reserve your child's first email address with Proton

Show HN: Quillium, Inline Branching for Prose

Anthropic's warning about its own product

Prototyping with LLMs

Agents.md is the highest-leverage code you're not testing

List of Dead or Missing Scientists 'Suspicious' as Ninth Case Raised

Déjà Code: How LLMs Cheat on Repos They've Seen

RAG retrieves fragments. HPAR retrieves meaning

Wargaming the Hormuz Crisis: Deterrence vs. Recession

The Code Is Not the Law: Why Claude's Constitution Misleads

Go CLI tool for AWS S3 security verification

The AI bubble isn't new – Marx explained the mechanisms behind it 150 years ago

What to expect from the fiery, 14-minute return of Artemis II

Comparison Shopping Is Not a (Computer) Crime

Logic of Self vs. Logic of Role (and Why Confusing the Two Is a Trap)

Cohn's "Privacy's Defender"

But What about K?

UMR: Save LLM model disk space

Show HN: Kubbo – build a medieval city with your daily habits

Let's Talk about LLMs

Explaining the Failures of Obesity Therapy

Claude Mythos Is Everyone's Problem

Not all index scans are equal: How we cut query latency by over 99%

Finding your investment lodestar: In search of an investment philosophy

CIA to embed AI «co-workers» in every analytic platform within two years

NASA's Dragonfly mission will send a nuclear-powered flying drone to Titan

Show HN: Wealth Curve – Financial forecasting with local storage and E2EE

Show HN: IBANforge – Free IBAN/BIC validation API with compliance data