Ask HN: Which function definition keyword do you prefer, def or fn?

1•winwang•1y ago

I'm curious about what people think of `def` vs `fn`, two short keywords for starting function definitions.

...Or maybe we should subscribe to the church of `df`, haha.

Comments

sitkack•1y ago

def could be for lots of things, fn is for functions. I don't think it matters much as long as you have one. C would have been so much easier to parse. Just copy Zig or Rust.

butlersean•1y ago

def means define, could be used to define all kinds of things

fn isnt a legitimate short form of function

fun doesnt work because of the amusement factor

func is the only alternative we have left

sitkack•1y ago

How about unicode or emojis?

These don't have the full fidelity as hn scrubs emojis

add = (a, b) -> a + b

a, b ⟹ a + b

λ add(a, b): ↪ a + b

johncoltrane•1y ago

"def" is too generic.

"fn" is too cryptic.

"function" is better than the two.

MultifokalHirn•1y ago

Agreed

Reusing existing FUSE daemons as VirtioFSD back end

Wrong Ways to Create Strings

Algorithmic Art: When AI Writes the Code, Where Is the Art?

Smart-contract risk reports that AI agents buy per call over x402

Robots with real-tissue muscle actuators achieve jumping, swimming and walking

Show HN: Nico – a two-agent type personal agent on your Mac

Fyslide – a local desktop app that turns one topic into TikTok slideshows

VMware returns to low-end server virtualization with 'vSphere Express'

Awesome repositories are no longer awesome

Multiple planes diverted as bomb threats to commercial flights reported

Show HN: Mooring, an agentic development environment for Claude Code

Building for agent use without MCP or skills

OpenAI Finds 948 Local Privilege Escalation Bugs in the Linux Kernel

Snitchie: Is Your AI a Nark?

GhostMap Android flaw lets malicious app trigger persistent boot loop

Show HN: Telegram AI assistant with projects, images and background jobs

Bvlgari Octo Finissimo Titanium Lineup at Geneva Watch Days

Nexus-Q: the first commits were a threat model and architecture, not code

Novel AI framework runs on optical hardware

Show HN: Win Stats – open-source system monitoring in the Windows taskbar

Piston – small causal model for time series that can refuse

How WeRateDogs Is Fighting A.I. Slop, One Perfect Puppy at a Time

Palantir CEO says it's pioneering an antiwar movement–while accepting defense $s

Italian chef fired after refusing to put pineapple on pizza

Figxit: Native autocomplete popup for the macOS terminal

Show HN: ChessGrind – Turn missed chess positions into training that sticks

Ask HN: How do small teams pragmatically manage Dependabot fatigue?

Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed

How Chiron Changes AI Incident Investigation on ORCA-bench

DeepSeek Harness [video]