frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

My 600 Hours with AI Coding Assistants: A Practical Comparison

2•bv_dev•1y ago
After spending over 600 hours using various AI coding assistants over the past 3 months, I wanted to share my experience for those navigating this rapidly evolving landscape.

What I Mean by "Agentic Mode" First, to clarify: by "agentic mode," I'm referring to the assistant's ability to understand project context, reason through multi-step problems, and autonomously make coherent code changes across files without constant hand-holding. True agency means the tool can maintain context across interactions and execute on high-level directions.

The Current Landscape (May 2025) Augment Code - Current go-to tool despite higher costs

Strengths: Maintains context remarkably well across complex refactors; actually understands project structure; can implement feature requests that span multiple files Weaknesses: More expensive than alternatives ($30/month vs $20 for others); occasional hallucinations when venturing outside codebase context Best for: Complex refactoring tasks and implementing features that span multiple files

Windsurf - Slightly edges out Cursor for agentic capabilities

Strengths: Better context retention than Cursor; decent file traversal; good understanding of code relationships Weaknesses: Can get quite stuck in their full agentic mode as it starts editing things. While they have removed their flow credits part, it is still painful to watch it go completely out of context. Best for: Mid-size projects where you need moderate autonomy

Cursor - Popular but underwhelming for true agentic work

Strengths: Good IDE integration; clean interface; works reasonably well for single-file tasks. I like the ability to Cmd+K and insert a bulk of code in the middle. Also, I like the @Docs feature to bring latest documentation for popular libraries.

Weaknesses: Context falls apart in agentic mode; often loses track of previous instructions; requires excessive prompting Best for: Single-file optimizations and modifications, but not complex cross-file tasks

Claude Code - Declining quality since public beta

Strengths: Used to have superior reasoning and contextual understanding 3 months ago Weaknesses: Super expensive (like always), but recent updates have significantly degraded agentic capabilities; now requires much more hand-holding than before as it goes compleltely off base. Best for: Simple tasks that don't require deep contextual understanding Note: Most disappointing decline in quality - was previously much more capable. I spent $500 in Feb-Mar and thought it was worth.

Cline, Roo, and Aider - Conceptually interesting but practically limited

Strengths: Cline has good terminal integration; Roo offers interesting visualization; Aider has straightforward CLI Weaknesses: All three struggle with maintaining context; limited understanding of project structure; frequent need to repeat instructions Best for: Very simple, isolated coding tasks or experiments

Real-world Performance Differences The gap between these tools becomes most apparent when trying to implement complex features. For example, when asked to "add user authentication with email verification to my Express app":

Augment Code: Identified relevant files, added middleware, routes, and email service integration, then explained how the pieces fit together Windsurf/Cursor: Added authentication to single files I pointed at but needed explicit instructions for each additional component Others: Generally required file-by-file guidance with frequent context reminders

Conclusion If budget isn't a concern, Augment Code currently offers the most truly agentic experience, but still has a long way to go. For more budget-conscious developers, Windsurf slightly edges out Cursor for agentic capabilities, though both still require significant guidance for complex tasks.

Comments

SoMomentary•1y ago
I'm always surprised by people sleeping on GitHub Copilot. Is this because people truly don't find any value in it?
bv_dev•1y ago
I have used Github copilot since their beta release in 2023 and I don't find it anywhere near good these days. Automplete was good, but the industry has moved way beyond 2025. Copilot is slightly worse than Cursor which is itself a pretty average tool now. If you use truly agentic code generation, you won't be able to go back to Github Copilot.
SoMomentary•1y ago
You don't consider copilots agent mode to be agentic? I've had some pretty great results with agent mode + mcp to have it check it's own work.

Verifying formal models of Raft implementations

https://antithesis.com/blog/2026/verifying-formal-models/
1•alpaylan•1m ago•0 comments

The Future Will Be Quaint

https://www.frontporchrepublic.com/2026/11/the-future-will-be-quaint/
1•pr337h4m•1m ago•0 comments

Coding agents obey the rules that can fail the build, and none of the others

https://kevin-denotariis.medium.com/building-gitmoap-01-43-my-coding-agents-obeyed-every-rule-tha...
1•kevindenotariis•2m ago•0 comments

Removing Binder.c

https://lwn.net/Articles/1102982/
1•birdculture•2m ago•0 comments

There are now more satellites over most towns than stars you can see

https://www.techspot.com/news/114638-there-now-more-satellites-over-most-towns-than.html
1•speckx•4m ago•0 comments

Language Models Can Rewrite Their Own Weights

https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.21885
2•lwhsiao•5m ago•0 comments

Bozzetto – collaborative docs for software design

https://bozzetto.dev/
2•cirrasphere•6m ago•1 comments

A Data Center Was Coming. The Town Had a Message: Stay Out

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/19/nyregion/data-centers-opposition-towns.html
2•ChrisArchitect•7m ago•1 comments

Voyager 1 Engineers Analyze Data Issue, Ready to Confirm Light-Day

https://science.nasa.gov/blogs/voyager/2026/11/18/voyager-1-engineers-analyze-data-issue-ready-to...
1•titusblair•8m ago•0 comments

De Brujin Torus [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QiLxzlQH-jE
2•ivanjermakov•8m ago•0 comments

Depth Pro 2: Sharp and Temporally Consistent Metric Monocular Depth

https://huggingface.co/papers/2611.26603
2•hamburglar1•9m ago•0 comments

Aria Magic Voice – The First 100% Offline, Privacy-First Input Engine

https://ariamagicvoice.com/apps/
1•andywu1206•9m ago•0 comments

Apple's Executive in Charge of the iPhone's Camera App Has Left

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-11-19/apple-s-iphone-camera-and-photos-software-chie...
2•elffjs•10m ago•0 comments

The Fate of the Riemann Hypothesis(Aug 2026) [pdf]

https://www.math.brown.edu/reschwar/Stories/AI.pdf
3•num42•12m ago•0 comments

Show HN: LarpLess, open-source study tracker detecting distractions locally

https://larpless.app/
2•maergune•13m ago•0 comments

The AI Forecasting Agenda

https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/the-ai-forecasting-agenda
1•toomuchtodo•13m ago•0 comments

Show HN: A lightweight SOAP client for macOS and Linux, built with Rust

https://github.com/yedhukrishnan/soap-client
1•yedhukrishnan•13m ago•0 comments

Pssst: Your Agents Aren't Actually Sandboxed

1•txase•13m ago•0 comments

Gestalt AI Model (Stealth): Who Made It, Release Date and What We Know

https://teamorouter.com/blogs/gestalt-ai-model
3•doener•14m ago•0 comments

Debian Linux Forms Gaming Hardware Team for Handheld and Edge Hardware Testing

https://www.techpowerup.com/355046/debian-linux-forms-gaming-hardware-team-for-handheld-and-bleed...
2•losgehts•15m ago•0 comments

What does an internet-free week in New Mexico have in common with Moby-Dick?

https://longreads.com/2026/11/17/new-mexico-with-no-internet-and-moby-dick/
1•mooreds•17m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Minard's 1869 map of Napoleon's Russian campaign, animated day by day

https://minard1812.org/
2•pstomi•17m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Vaire, Run PostgreSQL 18 on your own VPS (1.0 RC1)

https://github.com/mbvlabs/vaire
1•mbvisti•17m ago•0 comments

On taking developments in software engineering personally

https://www.sicpers.info/2026/11/on-taking-developments-in-software-engineering-personally/
3•mooreds•17m ago•0 comments

Send Us Thine Asteroid, O Lord [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkTgYiMDRHY
1•Bluestein•17m ago•0 comments

Linux/EasyShell, a new Rust RAT implant and beacon aims Linux and macOS

https://blog.malwaremustdie.org/2026/11/mmd-073-2026-linuxeasyshell-new-rust.html
1•speckx•18m ago•0 comments

The AI side effects we're not talking about

https://speaking.marcusnoble.co.uk/WbXSpV
1•mooreds•18m ago•0 comments

Haru-4B: Open Multilingual Full-Duplex Speech Model

https://blog.higurashi.ai/melte/haru4b/
2•sheepscreek•20m ago•0 comments

Camping Isn't for Everyone

https://cinemasojourns.com/2026/11/20/camping-isnt-for-everyone/
1•jjgreen•20m ago•0 comments

Orca released the bots and is like coming back to the office

https://twitter.com/aaitor/status/2123809670024380606
1•aaitor•20m ago•1 comments