frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Project 1511 – Why we should train separate AIs – one for thruth, one for art

2•Wydmuh•1y ago
Project 1511: The AI Dichotomy Initiative.

At the beginning i will mark, that text was written with the help of AI, my english is not as good as i thought .

Why i think we should split AI into two distinct, non-overlapping systems:

1. Kalkul (Logic Engine)

   - Puprouse: pure factual accuracy (STEM, law, medicine).  

   - Rules: No metaphors, no "I think" – only verifiable data.  

   - *Example Input:* "Calculate quantum decoherence times for qubits." → Output: Equations + peer-reviewed sources.  
2. Bard (Creative Agent)

   - Purpose: Unconstrained abstraction (art, philosophy, emotion).  

   - Rules: No facts, only meaning-making. Flagged disclaimers (e.g., "This is poetry, not truth").  

   - Example Input: "Describe grief as a physical space." → Output: "A room where the walls are made of old phone calls..."
The 8+2 Rule: Why Forcing Errors in Creative AI ('Bard') Makes It Stronger" We’re trapped in a loop: We train AI to "never" make mistakes, then wonder why it’s creatively sterile. What if we did the opposite?

The 8+2 Rule for "Bard" (Creative AI)

For every 10 responses, Bard generates: - 8 "logically sound" answers (baseline).

   - 2 *intentional errors* (wrong conclusions, flawed syllogisms, or "poetic" math).  
Errors are tagged (e.g., " Fallacy: Affirming the consequent") but not corrected. Users dissect errors to see how Bard breaks logic—and why it’s useful. Example: Question = "Explain democracy"

8 Correct Responses:

1. "A system where power derives from popular vote."

2. "Rule by majority, with protections for minorities."

[...]

2 Intentional Errors:

1. "Democracy is when two wolves and a sheep vote on dinner."

   - Error: False equivalence (politics ≠ predation).  

   - Value: Exposes fears of tyranny of the majority.  
2. "Democracy died in 399 BC when Socrates drank hemlock."

   - Error: Post hoc fallacy.  

   - Value: Questions elitism vs. popular will.  
Why This Works

Trains users , not just AI: - Spotting Bard’s errors becomes a "game" (like debugging code).

   - Users learn logic faster by seeing broken examples (studies show +30% retention vs. dry lectures).  
Bard’s "personality" emerges from flaws: - Its "voice" isn’t sanitized—errors reveal biases (e.g., libertarian vs. collectivist slant).

Safeguards "Kalkul": - By confining errors to Bard, Kalkul stays *pristine* (no hallucinations in medical advice).

3. Hybrid Bridge (Optional Legacy Mode)

   - Purpose: Temporary transition tool.  

   - Mechanics: ONLY merges pre-generated outputs from Kalkul/Bard without adding new content.  
Why It Matters

- Efficiency: 40-60% lower compute costs (no redundant "bridging" layers).

- Trust: eliminates hallucination risks in critical domains.

- Creative Freedom: Bard explores absurdity without algorithmic guilt.

- Education: Users learn to distinguish logic from artistry.

Technical Implementation

- Separate fine-tuning datasets:

  - Kalkul: arXiv, textbooks, structured databases.  

  - Bard: Surrealist literature, oral storytelling traditions.  
- UI with a physical toggle (or app tabs): `[FACT]` / `[DREAM]` / `[LEGACY]`.

Cultural Impact

- For Science: Restores faith in AI as a precision tool.

- For Art: Unleashes AI-aided creativity without "accuracy" constraints.

- For Society: Models intellectual honesty by not pretending opposites can merge.

Call to Action

I seek:

- Developers to prototype split models (e.g., fork DeepSeek-MoE).

- Philosophers to refine ethical boundaries.

- Investors who value specialization over artificial generalism.

Project 1511 isn’t an upgrade—it’s a rebellion against AI’s identity crisis.

Comments

henjodottech•1y ago
Cool idea. I think LLMs aren’t built for intentional error. They’re wired to optimize meaning—next tokens chosen from attention scores, beam search. You can’t just flip logic and get creativity. You either get coherence or gibberish. If you want poetic mistakes, train on surreal input—but I wouldn’t expect avant-garde results.
Wydmuh•1y ago
it was just my idea, assuming that biggest players will not give a f..ck. With premeditation i am using rule 8+2 with many diffrent AIs, and asking same question for the same. If with same coding answers are way diffrent and intersting

Why ClickHouse and Agents Are a Great Combo

https://blog.exe.dev/meet-exe-finops-the-custom-tool-i-built-for-our-billing-data
1•pradeepchhetri•9s ago•0 comments

Windows Narrator LockScreen Bypass 0day

https://github.com/MSNightmare/FastUnlock
1•taspeotis•3m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Does AI slop require more marketing in the future?

1•tesnorindian•7m ago•0 comments

Animated Steller's Jay, a beautiful AI benchmark

https://grady.dev/projects/steller/
1•gbdubs•9m ago•0 comments

Senate passes BAAJA permitting reform bill backed by AI, energy sectors

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/20/baaja-bill-senate-passes-permitting-reform.html
2•rexbee•11m ago•0 comments

Vardexil ReviEwS (2026): We Tried It My Honest Review

https://open.spotify.com/episode/2LPdJb7tJRxPhDzrDC6oWz
1•hanopasi•12m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Night Shift – A browser based incident response game

https://play.snowops.net/
1•sagarchhabra02•13m ago•0 comments

Show HN: A Personality Test for Engineers

https://engtest.dev/
1•lucastech•20m ago•0 comments

Ant needs –$602B in revenue to hit 20% ROIC comparable to peers; Apple has $478B

https://www.ft.com/content/ea8434c7-59d9-42cf-afd4-97cf42544c59
1•dreadsword•22m ago•0 comments

Show HN: LarkTune: Just Song

https://larktune.com
1•rNetAi•23m ago•2 comments

Expanding Transparency: Google and Alphabet VRP Disclosure Policy Update

https://blog.google/security/expanding-transparency-google-alphabet-vrp-disclosure-policy-update/
1•erbbysam•29m ago•0 comments

Germany in real time

https://adlerlicht.de
1•lvnfg•32m ago•1 comments

Baaja: Who's in Favor and Who's Opposed?

https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2026/11/baaja-whos-in-favor-and-whos-opposed/
1•thereader12•34m ago•0 comments

UCSF QBI Awarded $46M to Translate Landmark Autism Map into Precision Therapies

https://www.genengnews.com/topics/omics/ucsf-qbi-awarded-46m-to-translate-landmark-autism-map-int...
1•gmays•36m ago•0 comments

Muslims will outnumber Christians worldwide by 2035, report says

https://www.npr.org/2026/11/19/nx-s1-6043018/muslims-will-outnumber-christians-worldwide-by-2035-...
2•geox•37m ago•1 comments

Free Short Stories

https://www.astoryperweek.com/
1•HerveyDeyo•39m ago•1 comments

Giraffebench 1.0 – The quality of local and cloud LLMs in a way you can see

https://keno303.github.io/giraffebench/index.html
2•bj-rn•43m ago•0 comments

LLVM Wraps Up Relicensing

https://discourse.llvm.org/t/wrapping-up-llvms-relicensing-effort/92906
3•qtqtqt•44m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Agent Driven Slide Decks

https://github.com/steamfield/decks
1•RileyHilliard•45m ago•0 comments

Locked out of X, for not being human

https://boussejra.com/2026/11/20/locked-out-of-x-not-human.html
2•malikolivier•45m ago•0 comments

White House national cyber director is leaving the administration

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/white-house/national-cyber-director-sean-cairncross-leaving-kirs...
2•MadrasThorn•47m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Do you find Windows font rendering jagged?

1•qtqtqt•47m ago•0 comments

South Park Character Maker – Create original paper-cut cartoon avatars

https://southparkmaker.com/
1•cadcraft•47m ago•0 comments

Why created a great product isn't enough for healthcare startups

https://davidngo1562.substack.com/p/its-not-about-the-money-until-it
1•illidan1000•47m ago•0 comments

Xenohumanist

https://sofiechan.com/u/xenohumanist
1•jerlendds•50m ago•1 comments

FFmpeg 9.1 'Gauss'

https://ffmpeg.org/download.html#release_9.1
5•gyan•50m ago•1 comments

I Built the Largest Commentary in the History of Persian Poetry

https://dev.arman.ac/posts/largest-commentary-in-the-history-of-persian-poetry/
1•armanj•51m ago•0 comments

The Wicked Reason Removing Code Beats Better Scheduling

https://infrequently.org/2026/08/notes-on-performance-remediation-strategies/
2•fagnerbrack•51m ago•1 comments

GIMP now has UI tests

https://www.gimp.org/news/2026/11/16/gimp-ui-tests/
7•qtqtqt•52m ago•0 comments

Show HN: GhostFleet: A Battleship game with an advanced AI opponent

https://ghostfleet.in/play?mode=wraithAI
1•anirbanhere•53m ago•0 comments