frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

A Critical Look at "A Critical Look at MCP."

https://docs.mcp.run/blog/2025/05/16/mcp-implenda-est/
33•palmfacehn•1y ago

Comments

nip•1y ago
> Further, one of the issues with remote servers is tenancy

Excellent write-up and understanding of the current state of MCP

I’ve been waiting for someone to point it out. This is in my opinion the biggest limitation of the current spec.

What is needed is a tool invocation context that is provided at tool invocation time.

Such tool invocation context allows passing information that would allow authorizing, authentication but also tracing the original “requester”: think of it as “tool invoked on behalf of user identity”

This of course implies an upstream authnz that feeds these details and more.

If you’re interested in this topic, my email is in my bio: I’m of the architect of our multi-tenant tool calling implementation that we’ve been running in production for the past year with enterprise customers where authnz and auditability are key requirements.

jensneuse•1y ago
The way we've solved this in our MCP gateway (OSS) is that the user first needs to authenticate against our gateway, e.g. by creating a valid JWT with their identity provider, which will be validated using JWKS. Now when they use a tool, they must send their JWT, so the LLM always acts in their behalf. This supports multiple tenants out of the box. (https://wundergraph.com/mcp-gateway)
Yoric•1y ago
Is this really hard to code?

I mean, converting a tool-less LLM into a tool-using LLM is a few hundred lines of code, and then you can plug all your tools, with whichever context you want.

nip•1y ago
Indeed very easy to code!

My point is about the need for a spec of this mechanism: without a spec, every company / org will roll out their own and result in 500 flavors of the same concept.

That’s where MCP shines: tool calling and tool discovery is already 1.5 years old (an eternity in ai land).

The MCP spec ensures that we can all focus on solving problems with tool calling rather than wasting time in cobbling together services that re not interoperable (because developed without a common spec / standard)

__loam•1y ago
This is an advertisement
tomrod•1y ago
I wish this were critical, but it is an ad for MCP.run.
nip•1y ago
It’s both in my opinion and discussions can stem from the linked article

Many come to HN also for the comments

palmfacehn•1y ago
Personally, I'm not a fan. I thought the proponent's view might stimulate a discussion.
FunnyLookinHat•1y ago
> Server authors working on large systems likely already have an OAuth 2.0 API.

I think this biases towards sufficiently large engineering organizations where OAuth 2.0 was identified as necessary for some part of their requirements. In most organizations, they're still using `x-<orgname>-token` headers and the like to do auth.

I'm not sure that there's a better / easier way to do Auth with this use case, but it does present a signficant hurdle to adoption for those who have an API (even one ready for JSON-RPC!) that is practically ready to be exposed via MCP.

motorest•1y ago
> I think this biases towards sufficiently large engineering organizations where OAuth 2.0 was identified as necessary for some part of their requirements. In most organizations, they're still using `x-<orgname>-token` headers and the like to do auth.

I don't think that's it. Auth is a critical system in any organization, and larger organizations actually present more resistance to change, particularly in business critical areas. If anything, smaller orgs gave an easier time migrating critical systems such as authentication.

hirsin•1y ago
Touching on tenancy and the "real" gaps in the spec does help push the discussion in a useful direction.

https://vulnerablemcp.info/ is a good collection of the immediately obvious issues with the MCP protocol that need to be addressed. A couple low blows in there, that feel a bit motivated to make MCP look worse, but generally a good starting point overall.

owebmaster•1y ago
This post has too many "shameless plugs" to be taken seriously.
smitty1e•1y ago
Serious question:

If doing an extended, service-level session (like a GPT interaction) with a server known beforehand, would it make sense to set up a keypair and manage the interaction over SSH?

Restated: are we throwing away a lot of bandwidth establishing TLS trust for the more general HTTP?

RollerCoasterTycoonBench: Can Decision Models Manage a Theme Park?

https://www.vals.ai/blogs/building-rctbench
1•valkrieco•3m ago•0 comments

China blocks SoftBank's $5.4B takeover of ABB's robotics division

https://www.reuters.com/business/media-telecom/china-blocks-softbanks-54-billion-takeover-abbs-ro...
2•dingdongditchme•3m ago•0 comments

What people are building, discovered through new domains

https://startups.novumsignals.com/
1•walterschnitzel•5m ago•0 comments

UK fridges secured from hackers in secret nationwide operation

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6eq49zyx7p4o
4•tomnext•7m ago•0 comments

Persistent Incrementality in Rust

https://rust-glancer.github.io/blog/persistent-incrementality-in-rust/
1•joshcsimmons•8m ago•0 comments

Anatomy of an AI-driven attack: What ARTEX looks like in action

https://bitrise.io/artex-incident-report
1•gabornadai•8m ago•0 comments

I Stopped Using Conversation History as My Agents' State

https://medium.com/@ulrich.tan/building-stateful-investigations-with-stateless-ai-agents-2fc9bab3...
1•ulrichxtan•11m ago•0 comments

Anthropic IPO could yield $156B for charity

https://hyper.ai/stories/38cbde179199e5d614e6f2b5abfb0911
1•HyperAI•11m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Deflate X-Ray, See inside a compressed file

https://hrih.si/projects/deflate-xray/
1•DonAtimator•12m ago•0 comments

Agent should not take the cursor

https://minea.minea.workers.dev/cursor
2•sujisss•13m ago•0 comments

Mirror Dimension for Agents: Evaluating Browser-Use Agents Without the Web

https://blog.google/security/mirror-dimension-for-agents/
1•DonAtimator•14m ago•0 comments

Page Transitions are now easy: CSS View Transitions

https://www.irrlicht3d.org/index.php?t=1629
1•irrlichthn•15m ago•0 comments

Microsoft's Agent Framework PyPI package compromised to steal credentials

https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/microsofts-agent-framework-pypi-package-compromise...
2•akyuu•16m ago•0 comments

If you can't explain something in simple terms, you don't understand it (2017)

https://kottke.org/17/06/if-you-cant-explain-something-in-simple-terms-you-dont-understand-it
3•sammatilda•16m ago•0 comments

Exploring the question of whether submarines can swim – by Danielle Boccelli

https://medium.com/@danielle.boccelli/exploring-the-question-of-whether-submarines-can-swim-35876...
1•rbanffy•16m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Reaktiv Workbook – A spreadsheet where every cell is Python

https://workbook.bui.app/
1•buibuibui•17m ago•0 comments

Signal Is Serious About Protecting Your Privacy

https://signal.org/blog/protecting-your-privacy/
1•dotcoma•17m ago•0 comments

AI incidents of 2026: Rogue agents, stolen keys, and other familiar stories

https://www.aikido.dev/blog/ai-incidents-root-causes-patterns
3•chillax•17m ago•0 comments

A real Linux kernel, compiled to WebAssembly

https://github.com/pithings/unkernel
2•nnx•17m ago•0 comments

Energy Wins Driving Optical Computing AI

https://spectrum.ieee.org/optical-computing-ai
2•rbanffy•18m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Did books that went viral on HN publish their manuscript?

1•illidan1000•18m ago•0 comments

Hy4 System Card [pdf]

https://hy.tencent.ai/Hy4_system_card.pdf
1•dvaplima•19m ago•0 comments

Characterizing the Ecosystem of Open-Source Uncensored Large Language Models

https://dl.acm.org/doi/epdf/10.1145/3777912.3839799
1•Betelbuddy•22m ago•0 comments

Singularity Clock

https://www.singularityclock.ai/
3•iamanatom•23m ago•0 comments

CVEs in Plain English

https://tldrcve.com/
3•chillax•23m ago•0 comments

Maintainers don't need more AI bug reports. They need fixes

https://github.blog/open-source/maintainers/maintainers-dont-need-more-ai-bug-reports-they-need-f...
1•Betelbuddy•23m ago•0 comments

Google critical cross-tenant file access in BigQuery Studio and Colab Enterprise

https://docs.cloud.google.com/support/bulletins
1•Betelbuddy•24m ago•0 comments

Britain must not rely on foreign AI, says former military intelligence chief

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/britain-must-not-rely-foreign-180000606.html
3•nephihaha•25m ago•0 comments

Show HN: PlanCity – I find new housing developments across Europe every day

https://plancity.ai/discover/en
1•walterschnitzel•25m ago•0 comments

GTA VI: Who Governs a Global Virtual World?

https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/gta-vi-who-governs-a-global-virtual-world-tickets-2005073126697
1•james_in_the_uk•25m ago•1 comments