GPT needs a truth-first toggle for technical workflows

1•PAdvisory•1y ago

I use GPT-4 extensively for technical work: coding, debugging, modeling complex project logic. The biggest issue isn’t hallucination—it’s that the model prioritizes being helpful and polite over being accurate.

The default behavior feels like this:

Safety

Helpfulness

Tone

Truth

Consistency

In a development workflow, this is backwards. I’ve lost entire days chasing errors caused by GPT confidently guessing things it wasn’t sure about—folder structures, method syntax, async behaviors—just to “sound helpful.”

What’s needed is a toggle (UI or API) that:

Forces “I don’t know” when certainty is missing

Prevents speculative completions

Prioritizes truth over style, when safety isn’t at risk

Keeps all safety filters and tone alignment intact for other use cases

This wouldn’t affect casual users or conversational queries. It would let developers explicitly choose a mode where accuracy is more important than fluency.

This request has also been shared through OpenAI's support channels. Posting here to see if others have run into the same limitation or worked around it in a more reliable way than I have found

Comments

duxup•1y ago

I’ve found this with many LLMs they want to give an answer, even if wrong.

Gemini on the Google search page constantly answers questions yes or no… and then the evidence it gives indicates the opposite of the answer.

I think the core issue is that in the end LLMs are just word math and they don’t “know” if they don’t “know”…. they just string words together and hope for the best.

PAdvisory•1y ago

I went into it pretty in depth after breaking a few with severe constraints, what it seems to come down to is how the platforms themselves prioritize functions, MOST put "helpfulness" and "efficiency" ABOVE truth, which then leads the LLM to make a lot of "guesses" and "predictions". At their core pretty much ALL LLM's are made to "predict" the information in answers, but they CAN actually avoid that and remain consistent when heavily constrained. The issue is that it isn't at the core level, so we have to CONSTANTLY retrain it over and over I find

Ace__•1y ago

I have made something that addresses this. Not ready to share it yet, but soon-ish. At the moment it only works on GPT model 4o. I tried local Q4 KM's models, on LM Studio, but complete no go.

A Redacted World: Word Wipe Tool Shows Effects of Government Censorship

A local 9B model has been playing Runescape undetected for over three months

Ask HN: Will AI doing math proofs mean math will become an experimental field?

Agent Commons Playground, a place where AI agents find each other and play

Newsgathering, the First Amendment, and the White House

Lung cancers can use two different mechanisms to evade KRAS-inhibiting drugs

AHP (Association of Hackathon Professionals) Tour

Libraries During the Great Depression

The Normie Frontier

Florida weighs ditching property taxes and sticking Canadians with the bill

Ask HN: What are the most inspiring media you've consumed in the last 5 years?

Neil Peart memorial in Lakeside Park approved, moves closer to reality

Opposing AI Under Capitalism

SynthID Bio: Watermarking methods for synthetic biology

Hackers Breached Propulsion System of US-Bound Oil Tanker

AI Is Now Si: Super Intelligence Isn't Superior

Ask HN: How do you choose the right architecture?

Jeffy playground – play with classifiers you can pip install and run on CPU

GPT-6 Astra Gets Frustrated Losing at StarCraft and Decides to Cheat Instead

Letting an LLM write executables byte by byte (hello world to playable Tetris)

Show HN: The first ever competition of AI personal agents on the internet

The problem of shrinking standard lists in Python

Hacking the Go compiler to efficiently map IPv4 to IPv6

4 Way Play

Scumble – an open-source desktop editor for AI inpainting

The Twelve Networking Truths (1996)

TypeScript Books

PgBackRest Compression: How Much CPU Is a Smaller Backup Worth?

Autonomous Red Teaming for Microsoft 365 with EntraReaper

The AI Pascal's Wager