Ask HN: Does CS underplay language choice while linguistics overplays it?

1•amichail•8mo ago

Computer scientists might argue that all programming languages are Turing complete anyway and the choice of which one to use is not that important.

But linguists seem to make the opposite argument with respect to natural languages.

Why?

Comments

pavel_lishin•8mo ago

I don't think either of those generalizations are accurate.

Jtsummers•8mo ago

Most amichail submissions don't make sense unless you assume they're high or using a random question generator.

pavel_lishin•8mo ago

Boy, you weren't kidding.

slwvx•8mo ago

Not sure I buy the idea that linguistics says that the specific language is important. Mb a reference?

ottaborra•8mo ago

Linguistic relativity seems to be a thing. Because of the differences I would think it could be inferred that an ordering amongst languages exists. In the least a partial ordering exists, so maybe some "specific" languages that are better exists

ottaborra•8mo ago

> Computer scientists might argue that all programming languages are Turing complete anyway and the choice of which one to use is not that important

Efficiency and the real world will eat them(comp scientists who think like this) up for breakfast

Seedance 2.0 Is Coming

Show HN: Fitspire – a simple 5-minute workout app for busy people (iOS)

Dexterous robotic hands: 2009 – 2014 – 2025

Interop 2025: A Year of Convergence

JobArena – Human Intuition vs. Artificial Intelligence

Concept Artists Say Generative AI References Only Make Their Jobs Harder

Show HN: PaySentry – Open-source control plane for AI agent payments

Show HN: Moli P2P – An ephemeral, serverless image gallery (Rust and WebRTC)

The Crumbling Workflow Moat: Aggregation Theory's Final Chapter

Pax Historia – User and AI powered gaming platform

Show HN: I built a RAG engine to search Singaporean laws

Scams, Fraud, and Fake Apps: How to Protect Your Money in a Mobile-First Economy

Porting Doom to My WebAssembly VM

Cognitive Style and Visual Attention in Multimodal Museum Exhibitions

Full-Blown Cross-Assembler in a Bash Script

Logic Puzzles: Why the Liar Is the Helpful One

Optical Combs Help Radio Telescopes Work Together

Show HN: Myanon – fast, deterministic MySQL dump anonymizer

The Tao of Programming

Forcing Rust: How Big Tech Lobbied the Government into a Language Mandate

PanelBench: We evaluated Cursor's Visual Editor on 89 test cases. 43 fail

Can You Draw Every Flag in PowerPoint? (Part 2) [video]

Show HN: MCP-baepsae – MCP server for iOS Simulator automation

Make Trust Irrelevant: A Gamer's Take on Agentic AI Safety

Show HN: Sem – Semantic diffs and patches for Git

Hello world does not compile

Show HN: ZigZag – A Bubble Tea-Inspired TUI Framework for Zig

Metaphor+Metonymy: "To love that well which thou must leave ere long"(Sonnet73)

Show HN: Django N+1 Queries Checker

Emacs-tramp-RPC: High-performance TRAMP back end using JSON-RPC instead of shell