Creating a pan-European legal entity, the right way

32•whyoh•7mo ago

Comments

dleeftink•7mo ago

How about instead of scaling up, try scaling-in? Promise superior internal market services and local storage/processing instead of competing on the global square. Kagi's subscription model comes to mind.

The myth of infinite start-up scaling is just that, a myth. We need a more pragmatic, context sensitive startup market, not one chasing scale-up stories.

saubeidl•7mo ago

That works until the American megacorp comes along, copies your business idea and outscales you.

dleeftink•7mo ago

A unique strategy (and sign) of the times, let's see how many start-ups are willing to get bought out.

lo_zamoyski•7mo ago

This is a good point. Too much emphasis is placed on conquering THE WORLD (tm). This encourages a mindset of domination in which either you beat them by conquering the world, or join them by becoming an employee. Not everything has to be "global". It also produces a world of centralized services and products instead of flexible ecosystems that can cooperate.

Another benefit of decentralization is resilience to global market forces. As an example, look at Polish economic growth in 2008. It was the only EU member to avoid the recession. Why? Because of a strong domestic market.

47282847•7mo ago

Maybe I’m overthinking it, but don’t see this happening. Not now, not by 2028. 2050 maybe, and I don’t know if I would like the centralized United States of Europe that I see as requirement for this to happen in any meaningful way. Federation and independence has its downsides, but to me the benefits of the European way of plurality are much more preferable.

(Co-founder of various European and US entities)

mytailorisrich•7mo ago

What would be the benefit?

Right now you can incorporate a company anywhere in the EU, where-ever is the most advantageous, and do business anywhere.

I think the same goes in the US and that does not seem to slow them down...

DrJokepu•7mo ago

In the US, you actually have to register your business as a foreign entity in every state you operate in (foreign in this context means “out-of-state”) and it’s a minor annoyance, it can and does delay business.

mytailorisrich•7mo ago

Well, the argument is that EU start-ups are lagging because of the lack of EU-level legal entity, which is obviously not true...

In fact the best way for the EU to help start-ups is to stay out of the way as much as possible (a big ask...)

cjbenedikt•7mo ago

Indeed. I'd say a major annoyance. After all it includes filing taxes and sometimes you have to "align" your company name if for example you apply for federal grants.

cm277•7mo ago

This reminds me of the old XKCD about inventing new standards... fine, you get an EU Inc corporate model. What's the labor law applied for employees? what is the tax regime, and which countries will take in taxes? what about oh, I don't know liability, insurance, debt and bankruptcy, etc, etc.?

A company is a legal person within a jurisdiction --of which all of the laws apply to every person. You can't have an EU Inc without a federal EU. Heck even the US doesnt have a US Inc. This is naive at best.

saubeidl•7mo ago

Doesn't this already exist?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Societas_Europaea

That's the legal form Airbus and SAP are using, as examples.

esbranson•7mo ago

Those must have minimum capital of €120,000, likely one of many onerous requirements.

saubeidl•7mo ago

That doesn't seem like a crazy amount of capital to me?

dadoum•7mo ago

It makes me wonder what is a Societas Europaea then. I thought it was some kind of pan-European legal entity, even though it's probably not suited for startups at all, as it looks quite complicated to set-up from what I read on Wikipedia. If anyone has more insights, I am interested to learn more about that.

cprecioso•7mo ago

IIRC basically the SE is indeed complicated and has a bunch of requirements that would not make sense for a startup. Plus, it isn’t really a common denominator for different corporate laws, but they kinda add together so now you need to know about laws in Germany AND laws in Spain AND etc, wherever you operate.

esbranson•7mo ago

Per the Wikipedia article, the "SE must have a minimum subscribed capital of €120,000 as per article 4(2) of the directive".[1] Note that it's the regulation, not the directive, with the requirement.[2] It appears the OP's article discusses an alternative 28th regime model suitable for startups.[3] See also the recent European Commission project group on the subject.[4]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Societas_Europaea#Minimum_capi...

[2] https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2001/2157

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/28th_regime

[4] https://commission.europa.eu/document/download/7f3e1d1e-e406...

Pensions Are a Ponzi Scheme

Divvy.club – Splitwise alternative that makes sense

Betterment data breach exposes 1.4M customers

MIT Technology Review has confirmed that posts on Moltbook were fake

Epstein Science: the people Epstein discussed scientific topics with

Bambuddy – a free, self-hosted management system for Bambu Lab printers

Every Failed M4 Gun Replacement Attempt

China ramps up energy boom flagged by Musk as key to AI race

Show HN: ClawBox – Dedicated OpenClaw Hardware (Jetson Orin Nano, 67 Tops, 20W)

Ask HN: AI never gets flustered, will that make us better as people or worse?

Show HN: HalalCodeCheck – Verify food ingredients offline

Student makes cosmic dust in a lab, shining a light on the origin of life

In the Australian outback, we're listening for nuclear tests

'Hermès orange' iPhone sparks Apple comeback in China

Show HN: Goxe 19k Logs/S on an I5

The async builder pattern in Rust

(Golang) Self referential functions and the design of options

Show HN: Model Training Memory Simulator

Claude Code Controller

Software design is now cheap

Show HN: Are You Random? – A game that predicts your "random" choices

Poland to probe possible links between Epstein and Russia

Effectiveness of AI detection tools in identifying AI-generated articles

Warsaw Circle

Reverse Engineering Raiders of the Lost Ark for the Atari 2600

The AI4Agile Practitioners Report 2026

Digital Independence Day

What a bot hacking attempt looks like: SQL injections galore

Show HN: FlashMesh – An encrypted file mesh across Google Drive and Dropbox

Show HN: AgentLens – Open-source observability and audit trail for AI agents

Pensions Are a Ponzi Scheme

Divvy.club – Splitwise alternative that makes sense

Betterment data breach exposes 1.4M customers

MIT Technology Review has confirmed that posts on Moltbook were fake

Epstein Science: the people Epstein discussed scientific topics with

Bambuddy – a free, self-hosted management system for Bambu Lab printers

Every Failed M4 Gun Replacement Attempt

China ramps up energy boom flagged by Musk as key to AI race

Show HN: ClawBox – Dedicated OpenClaw Hardware (Jetson Orin Nano, 67 Tops, 20W)

Ask HN: AI never gets flustered, will that make us better as people or worse?

Show HN: HalalCodeCheck – Verify food ingredients offline

Student makes cosmic dust in a lab, shining a light on the origin of life

In the Australian outback, we're listening for nuclear tests

'Hermès orange' iPhone sparks Apple comeback in China

Show HN: Goxe 19k Logs/S on an I5

The async builder pattern in Rust

(Golang) Self referential functions and the design of options

Show HN: Model Training Memory Simulator

Claude Code Controller

Software design is now cheap

Show HN: Are You Random? – A game that predicts your "random" choices

Poland to probe possible links between Epstein and Russia

Effectiveness of AI detection tools in identifying AI-generated articles

Warsaw Circle

Reverse Engineering Raiders of the Lost Ark for the Atari 2600

The AI4Agile Practitioners Report 2026

Digital Independence Day

What a bot hacking attempt looks like: SQL injections galore

Show HN: FlashMesh – An encrypted file mesh across Google Drive and Dropbox

Show HN: AgentLens – Open-source observability and audit trail for AI agents

Creating a pan-European legal entity, the right way

Comments