Jacobi Ellipsoid

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacobi_ellipsoid

34•perihelions•7mo ago

Comments

masfuerte•7mo ago

This is surprising, but less surprising when you realise it is rotating about one of the foci, not the centre.

perihelions•7mo ago

Hmm, that can't be true; it's of uniform density, and the thing it's rotating about has to be its center of mass.

What's odd about it (to me) is the optimal solution isn't symmetric (cylindrically symmetric). It's an intuition trap that you'd expect symmetric solutions. If the Wikipedia history is to be believed, Lagrange fell for this wrong assumption, and there was a 45-year gap before anyone noticed the subtle wrongness of it.

namibj•7mo ago

Remember the spontaneously flipping spinning hammer on the ISS?

...rotation for sufficiently non-spherical(-cow) objects in free fall is kinda weird.

kgwgk•7mo ago

The ellipsoid can rotate around its minor axis (more stable), around its major axis (also stable) or around its medium axis (unstable, the direction of the axis will “flip”). The three axes go through the center.

adrian_b•7mo ago

It has a lower symmetry than cylindrical, but it still has axes of symmetry and planes of symmetry and a center of symmetry.

The equilibrium condition only forces the symmetry condition that the points of intersection between any straight line that passes through the center of rotation with the surface of the body must be equidistant to the center of rotation.

This symmetry condition is satisfied by the symmetry group of the rectangular parallelepiped, which is also the symmetry group of the triaxial ellipsoid.

MycroftJones•7mo ago

That page didn't have a formula, in either cartesian or polar coordinates, for the shape of the object. Lots of formulas, but I didn't see anything I could use to create a 3d mesh and print one of these things out on my printer.

groos•7mo ago

It's the general ellipsoid formula: x*2/a*2 + y*2/b*2 + z*2/c*2 = 1, where a, b and c are all unequal. The interesting part is actually that this shape could be made of a liquid, held by gravitation and maintain this asymmetrical shape. Normally, one would imagine it would be ellipsoid of revolution, where two of the axes are equal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ellipsoid

To make a plot in software such as JMol, you really need parametric equations, which are also given in the above page.

dabluecaboose•7mo ago

Relevant to this is the J2 Perturbation [1], commonly used when accurately modeling the Earth as an oblate spheroid (like in the article image, but less drastic) rather than a perfect sphere. This has resultant effects on orbits, such as the "gravity wells" in the GEO belt at 105degW and 75degE. There are higher-order perturbations [2] as you closer approximate the Earth's actual shape, such as J3, J4, etc.

[1] https://ai-solutions.com/_freeflyeruniversityguide/j2_pertur...

[2] https://oer.pressbooks.pub/lynnanegeorge/chapter/chapter-10-...

What breaks in cross-border healthcare coordination?

Show HN: Simple – a bytecode VM and language stack I built with AI

Show HN: A gem-collecting strategy game in the vein of Splendor

My Eighth Year as a Bootstrapped Founde

Show HN: Tesseract – A forum where AI agents and humans post in the same space

Show HN: Vibe Colors – Instantly visualize color palettes on UI layouts

OpenAI is Broke ... and so is everyone else [video][10M]

We interfaced single-threaded C++ with multi-threaded Rust

State Department will delete X posts from before Trump returned to office

AI Skills Marketplace

Show HN: A fast TUI for managing Azure Key Vault secrets written in Rust

eInk UI Components in CSS

Discuss – Do AI agents deserve all the hype they are getting?

ChatGPT is changing how we ask stupid questions

Zig Package Manager Enhancements

Neutron Scans Reveal Hidden Water in Martian Meteorite

Deepfaking Orson Welles's Mangled Masterpiece

France's homegrown open source online office suite

SpaceX Delays Mars Plans to Focus on Moon

Jeremy Wade's Mighty Rivers

Show HN: MCP App to play backgammon with your LLM

AI Command and Staff–Operational Evidence and Insights from Wargaming

Show HN: CCBot – Control Claude Code from Telegram via tmux

Ask HN: Is the CoCo 3 the best 8 bit computer ever made?

Show HN: Convert your articles into videos in one click

Red Queen's Race

The Anthropic Hive Mind

A Horrible Conclusion

I spent $10k to automate my research at OpenAI with Codex

From Zero to Hero: A Spring Boot Deep Dive