frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

Do AI Tutors Empower or Enslave Learners?

https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.06878
11•jruohonen•9h ago

Comments

jruohonen•9h ago
I am not sure whether just shouting "AI literacy" will cut it, given the sad quotes presented.
spwa4•7h ago
The problem with this is similar as I have with every AI criticism. None of these problems are specific to AI. All of these problems ... are money/effort problems.

They start by discussing the difference between teachers who teach a subject ... and teachers who will discuss changing the foundation of a subject and the implications of big changes. Which is of course required for critical thinking.

But that's a BIG step up in skill from what normal teachers bring to the table. At that point you should be so versed in the subject that you can discuss how the subject is constructed, and why (e.g. the connection between calculus and war). Which, at minimum, requires knowledge of the subject itself, it's history including it's failed history (which paths were not taken or abandoned, like say the axiom of Choice, and why they were abandoned), current research directions (like what the arguments are for and against various kinds of large cardinal numbers. Hell, what large cardinal numbers even are, continuum hypothesis, ...).

I have a master's in Math and I've had 4 teachers, in 27 years, who had anything approaching that level of knowledge. I remember each of them vividly. And I agree with the article: with such teachers you learn 10x what you learn with "normal" teachers. But they are so uncommon that they are literally a rarity in pure math university departments (which have also gotten worse by choosing cheaper over better candidates). Frankly if you have that level of knowledge you leave the teaching profession unless you're insane, because you can do so much better.

In other words: AI can be a pretty sizeable improvement on the average teacher and this paper is the traditional argument against AI. The argument goes "AI doesn't (yet) beat the very best humans at X, so it is totally unusable for X", when AI easily beats average humans. If anything, this is an argument to have those very best teachers switch to teaching AIs, and get rid of the average ones.

And of course, there's the undertone in the article that teaching children provides a measure of social control over society. Which of course is also already a problem. Every subject has extremely controversial parts, like the first applications of calculus (which is to calculate ballistic trajectories. In other words, to kill people from as large a distance as possible. THAT is why we founded calculus, that is what it does very, very well). And if it's that controversial for math ... well, in social sciences papers European scholars started arguing for a holocaust (removing bad genes by terminating incurable patients) at the beginning of the 20th century, when Hitler was a baby crying on his mother's lap. In fact, Autism's invention/discovery and popularization by Hans Asperger had the singular purpose to "purify the genes of the great German people", not to help patients suffering from it. His words, not mine. In other words, really discussing a subject requires coldly and matter-of-factly discussing incredibly bad political ideologies, including when such ideologies are held by scientists/teachers (and pointing out just how bad they can get, how much damage they can do, and how science enables such ideologies to incredible damage)

notTooFarGone•6h ago
The main criticism is skill atrophy which you don't recognize and rather talk about literal nazism.

Society is a construct and we teach children to be a part of that. If Society is shit we teach our children shit. That's it.

Can AI retrieve the knowledge for that? I guess that's possible.

Can AI make it meaningful and actually transfer that knowledge?

To learn something and truly take it as your own human contact is very much wired into our DNA. Trying to replace that with some form of text will rob an essential part in learning that has consequences that we can't properly measure. We can only see what happens with humans as they have less contact, increased loneliness and lack of role models which would likely increase.

aleph_minus_one•3h ago
> Frankly if you have that level of knowledge you leave the teaching profession unless you're insane, because you can do so much better.

Honestly: where in the job market is such knowledge or are such skills actually appreciated?

My life experience says that at least in academic teaching these skills are more appreciated than nearly anywhere else in industry, but if you know better, I'm interested to get to know your perspective.

sinenomine•2h ago
«Skunkworks», MIC, three letter agencies, problem-solving contractors, staff-level employees
jjani•3h ago
The title talks about "AI Tutors" yet reading the whole paper it's just very general and obvious statements about use of AI in education/by students in general, nothing to do with "Tutors". If you ask someone else to do your homework and they do it for you, no one would call them a tutor.

Show HN: Pg-when– psql extension for creating time values with natural language

https://github.com/frectonz/pg-when
1•jossephus01•2m ago•0 comments

CoverDrop: Blowing the Whistle Through a News App

https://www.coverdrop.org/
1•todsacerdoti•2m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Engineering hiring managers, what do you consider a good cover letter?

1•fnord77•8m ago•0 comments

Why Did Cars Get So Hard to See Out Of?

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-07-10/why-did-cars-get-so-hard-to-see-out-of-blame-the-a-pillars
2•upofadown•10m ago•0 comments

Rudy: A Toolchain for Rust Debuginfo

https://www.samjs.io/blog/rudy
2•samjs•13m ago•0 comments

What makes a good 1-on-1 (and where some managers get it wrong)

https://taoem.com/chapters/6/1-1s-the-most-powerful-management-tool
1•jampa•14m ago•0 comments

Microsoft Touts $500M AI Savings While Slashing Jobs

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/microsoft-touts-500-million-ai-171149783.html
2•Michelangelo11•14m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Optiverse – Evolving Code with LLMs

https://mathieularose.com/optiverse-evolving-code-with-llms
1•larose•16m ago•0 comments

"AI slop" is in the eye of the beholder

https://www.axios.com/2025/04/24/ai-slop-studio-ghibli-barbie-deepfakes
2•Bluestein•16m ago•0 comments

Claude Code: GitHub Actions Integration

https://twitter.com/alexalbert__/status/1943332121814405412
1•tosh•16m ago•0 comments

Past aquifer responses to climate recorded by fossil groundwater

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adu7812
3•PaulHoule•16m ago•0 comments

Varda raises $187M in funding to make drugs in orbit

https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/10/space-startup-varda-medicine-orbit.html
2•Bluestein•18m ago•0 comments

Semaphore Enterprise Edition is free for small teams

https://semaphore.io/blog/enterprise-ci-cd-free
1•tomfern•18m ago•1 comments

Show HN: I built an AI tool to retrieve technical achievements from your GitHub

https://git-achievements.com
1•davidngugi•19m ago•0 comments

Token Hygiene – AI context window curation

https://www.marlin-verlag.de/post/token-hygiene-how-to-curate-long-sessions-and-keep-the-ai-context-window-small
1•Klozeitung•19m ago•0 comments

Salmon Chaos

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salmon_chaos
2•ipnon•19m ago•0 comments

New Sudo CVE

https://github.com/pr0v3rbs/CVE-2025-32463_chwoot
1•stephc_int13•20m ago•1 comments

AI Generated Memes: What will you meme today?

https://www.bustameme.com/
1•nbstme•21m ago•1 comments

Chemical used in plastics has erupted as latest fentanyl adulterant

https://arstechnica.com/civis/threads/weird-chemical-used-in-plastics-has-erupted-as-latest-fentanyl-adulterant.1508267/
2•Bluestein•21m ago•1 comments

Free DNS domain name of zz.ac

https://tao.zz.ac/dns/free-zz-domain-name.html
2•unclet•21m ago•1 comments

Vibe Coding: Trend or Security Disaster Waiting to Happen?

https://xygeni.io/blog/vibe-coding-trend-or-security-risk/
1•fatidevrel•22m ago•0 comments

Signaling Cursor AI Completion with a File Watcher and Screen Flasher

https://blog.bbs-software.com/blog/2025/05/29/desktop-image-flashing-on-cursor-ai-response-completion/
1•petercooper•23m ago•0 comments

A Giant Planet and a Small Star Are Shaking Up Conventional Cosmological Theory

https://www.wired.com/story/a-giant-planet-and-a-small-star-are-shaking-up-conventional-cosmological-theory/
1•Brajeshwar•24m ago•0 comments

Ancient river systems reveal Mars was wetter than we thought

https://phys.org/news/2025-07-ancient-river-reveal-mars-wetter.html
2•Brajeshwar•24m ago•0 comments

Bret Victor on why current trend of AIs is at odds with his work

https://dynamicland.org/2024/FAQ/#What_is_Realtalks_relationship_to_AI
2•prathyvsh•24m ago•0 comments

Scientists discover ice in space isn't like water on Earth after all

https://www.space.com/astronomy/scientists-discover-ice-in-space-isnt-like-water-on-earth-after-all
1•Brajeshwar•24m ago•0 comments

Blocking internet on smartphones improves sustained attention, mental health

https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/4/2/pgaf017/8016017
2•carabiner•25m ago•0 comments

Data-Star.dev – v1 and Beyond

https://data-star.dev/essays/v1_and_beyond
1•vyrotek•28m ago•0 comments

Google AI's new trick: Turn any image into a brief video

https://www.axios.com/2025/07/10/google-veo-3-ai-videos-still-images
2•amirkabbara•30m ago•0 comments

Autonomous agent to query the Reddit hive mind

https://github.com/jashvira/reddit-consensus
1•soz404•32m ago•0 comments