Texas ranks as No. 1 state with the most people in financial distress

https://dallas.culturemap.com/news/innovation/texas-ranks-as-no-1-state-with-the-most-people-in-financial-distress/

26•paulpauper•5h ago

Comments

chris_wot•4h ago

I do wonder how much of this can be put down to an extremely lax regulatory environment within Texas itself.

crnvbikwblcps•3h ago

> To determine the states with the most financially distressed residents, WalletHub compared all 50 states across nine metrics in six major categories, such as average credit scores, the share of people with "accounts in distress" (meaning an account that's in forbearance or has deferred payments), the one-year change in bankruptcy filings from March 2024, and search interest indexes for "debt" and "loans."

Any state "financial distress" study where California ranks #12, New York #19 and Hawaii #50 is suspicious. The search engine part is especially nonsense.

carefulfungi•3h ago

The methodology is arbitrary and is mostly a measurement of average credit score.

Methodology: https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-the-most-people-in-fin...

This Equifax article lists CA has having a better average credit score than Texas. I did't bother to sort the Equifax to list to see how closely to correlates to the article, though.

https://www.equifax.com/personal/education/credit/score/arti...

toomanyrichies•2h ago

Here's the sorted Equifax list:

Minnesota 730

New Hampshire 727

Wisconsin 727

Vermont 726

Massachusetts 723

South Dakota 722

Washington 722

Colorado 720

Maine 720

Montana 720

North Dakota 720

Nebraska 720

Hawaii 719

Iowa 719

Utah 719

Idaho 718

Connecticut 717

New Jersey 717

Oregon 717

New York 713

Pennsylvania 713

Rhode Island 713

Wyoming 713

California 712

Illinois 712

Kansas 712

Virginia 712

Michigan 710

Alaska 709

Maryland 706

Ohio 706

Delaware 705

Missouri 705

Dist. of Col. 704

Indiana 704

Arizona 703

North Carolina 699

Florida 698

Tennessee 697

Kentucky 695

New Mexico 695

Puerto Rico 695

West Virginia 693

South Carolina 692

Nevada 691

Arkansas 688

Oklahoma 687

Georgia 686

Texas 686

Alabama 685

Louisiana 680

Mississippi 675

ariwilson•1h ago

Any ranking of states that ends with Mississippi is one I can get behind

elevation•2h ago

Credit score is not a useful measure of financial health.

A minimum wage worker living paycheck to paycheck but making minimums on a large credit card balance will have a better score than a retiree who's long since paid off his house and car and pays cash for entertainment and playthings.

toomuchtodo•39m ago

The minimum wage worker will not be making the minimum payment successfully on their credit card balance (bottom sixty percent of Americans cannot afford a basic quality of life [1] [2]). They likely can't produce $500 for an emergency, and use credit products with interest rates as high as ~30-35% with credit lines no larger than a few hundred or thousand dollars. The retiree you mention in your example will have an 800+ FICO credit score due to longevity of their trade lines (decades) and likely no inquiries (because they don't need to seek credit) or missed payments.

Cash flow underwriting would paint this picture better [3], but is still not widely performed outside of an org containing the deposit account (internal underwriting for credit products that don't have to conform for asset backed security sales). So, credit score is a reasonable proxy at this time for household financial health (imho) [4] [5].

[1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cost-of-living-income-quality-o...

[2] https://lisep.org/mql

[3] https://fintechtakes.com/articles/2024-05-22/cash-flow-under...

[4] https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/blog/new-report-exp...

[5] https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_credit-ka...

(day job is in finance/consumer credit)

fragmede•3h ago

Do you have any numbers as to why those rankings should be suspicious, or is it down to preconceived notions about people from those particular states you've met and you're projecting?

malshe•57m ago

> The search engine part is especially nonsense

Maybe you need to read "Everybody Lies": https://www.harpercollins.com/products/everybody-lies-seth-s...

Trump threatens stadium deal unless NFL team readopts Redskins name

U.S.-Based Wells Fargo Banker Blocked from Leaving China

Israel levelling Gaza civilian buildings in controlled demolitions

Delta Air Lines is using AI to set the maximum price you're willing to pay

How Distillation Makes AI Models Smaller and Cheaper

'Flutter': The song that saved raves from a government ban

Cuban Experiences on Computing and Education

The Last SS Guard

Nvidia Bringing CUDA to RISC-V

Mathematical Foundations for Finance

Cloudflare Learning Center

Global hack on Microsoft product hits U.S., state agencies, researchers say

Longevity Expert Breaks Down the Science and Hype of Biological Aging Tests

I Found Myself in the Game Industry

Ask HN: How do I prevent AI from reading/training off my content?

Gwynne Shotwell

Allergies seem nearly impossible to avoid – unless you're Amish

ETH Zürich introduces new policies for spinoffs and startups

More About Jumps Than You Wanted to Know

Beast X for Bayesian phylogenetic, phylogeographic and phylodynamic inference

UK government seeks way out of clash with US over Apple encryption

Kenneth Colley, 87, 'Star Wars' Actor with a Commanding Presence, Dies

After effectively banning porn, Idaho state government shows visitors porn

Show HN: Kara Auto Translate – Free English to ASL Translation, Open Beta

Every hour 100 people die of loneliness-related causes, UN health agency reports

Spending Time With The Casio F-91W (2024)

A Push for More Organ Transplants Is Putting Donors at Risk

Australia Wants to See Your Papers Before You Press Play

BlackRock's Bitcoin ETF Generating More Revenue Than Its Flagship S&P 500 Fund

Peering into the 'Double Black Box' of National Security and AI