frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

Orchestra Conductors Are Prompt Engineers

https://blog.charliemeyer.co/orchestra-conductors-are-prompt-engineers/
4•csmeyer•21h ago

Comments

PaulHoule•21h ago
Is it AI Slop or is it "Slop about AI?" Stop the insanity.
thesuperbigfrog•20h ago
This is a poor analogy.

Orchestras play music that was written and arranged by a composer. The musicians in the orchestra do not generate music solely based on the pieces they have studied and direction from the conductor. They play the music written by the composer with the conductor acting as a leader to synchronize and "flavor" the performance.

There is no equivalent to a musical score in prompting an LLM to generate something. The musical score is exactly what music should be played with the specific how it should be played being left to the style and taste of the musicians and conductor. It is "execution" or "exercise" of the musical score. Two different orchestras can play "Eine kleine Nachtmusik" and the results will be similar enough for listeners to recognize that it is the same music. The musical score guides the execution so that the resulting performance is mostly deterministic.

Prompt engineering and LLM generation are an imprecise approximation of what is wanted. Results from similar or even identical prompts will vary considerably depending on the LLM doing the generation, each LLM's respective training dataset, and what probability wickets are hit during the generation process. The generated results lack the determinism that the musical score provides an orchestra.

kazinator•14h ago
The analogy holds a bit better in the world of Mr. Bean:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wra2l6z7sdc

He's able to elicit a transfer of jazz style onto a Christmas carol.

mock-possum•3h ago
If anything, LLM is more like improv - you noodle around, sometimes you have something specific in mind that you’re looking for, every once in a while you hit upon something really good and you try to remember jt to save for later. You rarely just sit down and write a song from scratch beginning to end - much more often, you play around with lots of little bits, refining until you get what you want, something that feels good, original, complete.
bgwalter•18h ago
This is a strained metaphor that appeals to the egos of those who self-identify as prompt engineers.

A sewage worker analogy might be more appropriate.

throwawayoldie•17h ago
I see where you're going with this, but I disagree: sewage workers have to know how their tools work, and if they all quit their jobs tomorrow, we'd all be in big trouble.
os2warpman•15h ago
Sewage workers perform tasks that are important and have value.

The comparison is not apt.

Brightest explosion ever seen is still baffling astronomers

https://www.popsci.com/science/biggest-gamma-ray-burst-boat/
1•Bluestein•3m ago•0 comments

Subagents.sh – Share and discover Claude Code sub-agents

https://subagents.sh/
1•augmnt•5m ago•1 comments

Bbor62 – A compact binary-to-text compressor

https://github.com/goudvuur/bbor62
1•beligum•7m ago•1 comments

Top Anonymous Email Services for Privacy Lovers

https://cyble.com/knowledge-hub/anonymous-email-services-for-privacy/
1•cybleinc•12m ago•0 comments

Fujitsu starts development of 10000 plus superconducting quantum computer

https://global.fujitsu/en-global/newsroom/gl/2025/08/01-01
1•donutloop•12m ago•0 comments

I built a free, open-source security scanner with shareable dashboards

https://github.com/Huluti/Secrover
1•hugoposnic•13m ago•1 comments

US Energy Department misrepresents climate science in new report

https://phys.org/news/2025-08-energy-department-misrepresents-climate-science.html
1•OutOfHere•16m ago•0 comments

The Art of Parsing and Comparing Version Strings

https://secalerts.co/news/the-art-of-parsing-and-comparing-version-strings/7bVWMEyNBrMIbBmixgGVsI
2•louisstow•17m ago•0 comments

One diet soft drink daily may increase diabetes risk by more than a third

https://www.monash.edu/news/articles/one-can-of-artificially-sweetened-soft-drink-daily-may-increase-diabetes-risk-by-more-than-a-third
2•t0lo•18m ago•1 comments

Isle FPGA Computer

https://projectf.io/isle/fpga-computer.html
1•z303•20m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How do I sandbox Gemini Code Assist on Mac from accessing other files?

1•nuker•25m ago•0 comments

China struggles to break its addiction to manufacturing [Financial Times]

https://www.ft.com/content/f7979a8f-874a-4b47-8304-d93d30171980
1•wuschel•32m ago•1 comments

Why Japanese Developers Write Code Differently – Why It Works Better

https://medium.com/@sohail_saifi/why-japanese-developers-write-code-completely-differently-and-why-it-works-better-de84d6244fab
1•zdkaster•34m ago•0 comments

Ubiquiti users report having access to others' UniFi routers, cameras (2023)

https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/ubiquiti-users-report-having-access-to-others-unifi-routers-cameras/
1•janandonly•35m ago•0 comments

How to Grow Human Bones

https://nautil.us/how-to-grow-human-bones-1227312/
1•dnetesn•43m ago•0 comments

Windows 10 at 10: How Microsoft led developers round in circles

https://www.theregister.com/2025/08/01/windows_10_dev_comment/
3•rntn•43m ago•0 comments

The First Lunar Road Trip

https://nautil.us/the-first-lunar-road-trip-1227738/
1•dnetesn•44m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Built sth that makes social media suck less

https://mc-web-feedme.framer.website/feedme
1•cbpark•46m ago•0 comments

OpenIPC is an alternative open firmware for your IP camera

https://openipc.org/
1•janandonly•46m ago•0 comments

Asdfg

https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/
1•vihavo•47m ago•0 comments

Show HN: A App Helped Me Climb Out of a Deep Burnout

https://serenesound.app/
2•cunjieliu•51m ago•0 comments

Ecumenism Sau Înșelare

1•hetzel•56m ago•0 comments

Pride Versioning 0.3.0

https://pridever.org/
4•laacz•57m ago•0 comments

Agendafs: A filesystem for syncing notes to your calendar

https://sr.ht/~marcc/agendafs/
2•todsacerdoti•58m ago•0 comments

Microsoft catches Russian hackers targeting foreign embassies

https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2025/07/microsoft-catches-russian-hackers-targeting-foreign-embassies/
2•jnord•59m ago•0 comments

China Sees Gaps in US Cyber Defenses, Ousted National Security Official Says

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/29/us/politics/timothy-haugh-nsa-cyber.html
2•ironyman•1h ago•1 comments

Build a Parking sensor with ESP32 board, LEDs and Ultrasonic distance sensor

https://www.poeticoding.com/build-a-parking-sensor-with-esp32-board-leds-and-ultrasonic-distance-sensor/
1•Bogdanp•1h ago•0 comments

New quantum state of matter found at interface of exotic materials

https://phys.org/news/2025-07-quantum-state-interface-exotic-materials.html
2•janandonly•1h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What's your take on companies that send technical test before interview?

1•shadowjones•1h ago•0 comments

Pyret Programming Language

https://pyret.org/index.html
2•xrayarx•1h ago•0 comments