frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

Microsoft tops $4T in valuation: Great news for MSFT, not so great for workers

https://www.computerworld.com/article/4032921/microsoft-tops-4t-in-valuation-great-news-for-the-company-not-so-great-for-its-workers.html
68•CrankyBear•2h ago

Comments

anonymars•2h ago
Not so thrilled as a customer either
bediger4000•1h ago
There's never been a better time to leave either
bix6•1h ago
What is your business using instead of Excel?
mschuster91•1h ago
If I were to guess some frankenstein SAP system
OtherShrezzing•1h ago
90% of the business just uses Sheets. There's a few accountants & finance people who still need Excel.
andrewl-hn•52m ago
Depends, really. My exposure to agriculture and manufacturing sectors says everyone is still on Office 365 and Excel while digital marketing and advertising are almost all using Gmail and Sheets. Though it may also be location-dependent. I'm describing Europe, other parts of the world may be very different.
eitally•30m ago
Not necessarily manufacturing. I led a Microsoft takeout at Sanmina (global high-tech contract mfr) all the way back in 2008-2009, and the result was 23,000 users moving to GSuite and mostly just Legal & Finance keeping Office as a fall-back only if LibreOffice wasn't sufficient. At the same time, several thousand Windows laptops were replaced with Chromebooks, and nearly all non-engineering workstations were replaced with ChromeOS devices or thin clients.
bix6•36m ago
So you can’t migrate off then… and how is sheets (Google) better than Microsoft?
kfajdsl•1h ago
Google sheets
epolanski•52m ago
Orange and apples comparison.

Sure, they are both fruits, that's where it ends.

bix6•36m ago
Your accountants are using Google sheets?
the__alchemist•1h ago
Don't mave many options on the OS front. Windows performance gets worse and worse, increasing risk of corp enshittification, my task manager stopped working recently, but... I find Linux's workflow too rooted in multi-user systems and servers.
alexjplant•1h ago
> I find Linux's workflow too rooted in multi-user systems and servers.

Out of genuine curiosity (not *nix/OSS fanboying) - how so? macOS has been a BSD for a quarter of a century and modern Windows was designed by a guy who cut his teeth at DEC on VMS. Virtually all modern computer OSes have roots in time-sharing systems.

the__alchemist•52m ago
The user and permissions system. I struggle with things being set up on the root account vs user and vice versa, occasionally breaking my system by editing config files or with CLI commands. Did that a few weeks ago trying to get my PC to read USB-serial without launching the program from CLI with sudo+pw. I had an extra newline in one of the config files; it didn't like that! I cannot follow the decision-making logic that I would need sudo to talk to my embedded device. I've heard the explanations about connected storage devices, but I cannot agree with it. On windows, the same hardware, and same source code (compiled to a different ABI) just works, because its permission system is not so strict.
bediger4000•27m ago
It's indisputable that Dave Cutler designed both VMS and NT. But Cutler hasn't been involved in years, maybe decades. I'm not a Windows guy, but I am curious. It looks to me like modern Windows has gotten well away from any Cutler design. Has modern Windows retained any Cutler style design?
swarnie•1h ago
If i could even find a comparable OS/Productivity/Communications package to replace the existing i'd lose my own job for proposing it.
bongodongobob•32m ago
Sure, just let me run this multimillion dollar multi-year project past management. Reasoning? "Lol M$ is sux"
missedthecue•38m ago
Their Azure customer service is beyond atrocious. I have 6 days old completely untouched tickets on their paid support plan.
mikestew•1h ago
Well, maybe not so great for ex-workers. Current employees still have RSUs and employee stock purchase plan, so those shares are making bank. OTOH, my Microsoft-employed spouse also says "no significant pay raises this review period", and I think that's the "not so great for workers" part that TFA missed. MSFT is going big guns, but doesn't have money for increased compensation.
knuppar•1h ago
Retention was never a priority at MS. Lower comp compared to G/Meta/Amazon, no refreshers, poor special stock awards, tenure-based promo queue, (...). If RTO becomes a reality I think the calculus of staying at MS will be tipped over for many.
theflyinghorse•1h ago
In this economy the calculus will be “hold on to your job at all costs and hope that next round of quarterly layoffs hiring doesn’t touch you”
mikestew•1h ago
Over 25 years ago MSFT was doing the same thing. Amazon, Google, and Facebook didn't yet exist, so we were losing candidates to Oracle because MSFT paid so little. When Microsoft finally wiped the sleep from their eyes, my next review period saw me getting a 23% raise at review time, some from performance and a lot from Microsoft finally catching up to the rest of the industry because they couldn't hire anyone (I'd say it was also a demonstration of how badly I was getting screwed, but MSFT options were hot back then).

Will it happen again a generation later? Depends on how many candidates go to Amazon instead, I guess.

apwell23•51m ago
> tenure-based promo queue

i wouldn't mind this

CobrastanJorji•40m ago
I don't know what a tenure-based promo queue is, but from the name, wouldn't it in fact be extremely focused on retention?
missedthecue•40m ago
And it doesn't seem to be a bad strategy for their market fit, at least not for the last 20 years.
nlawalker•1h ago
Stock price doesn't have any effect on the value of ESPP at Microsoft, but you're right that it does on the RSUs. At least one company exec has directly proposed this as a counterbalance to "no pay raises" (From 2023: https://www.businessinsider.com/microsoft-exec-defends-compa...).

That said, anyone can own Microsoft stock. With respect to current employees - the common wisdom has always been not to own too much stock in your employer, with the rationale that if things aren't going well and the stock is tanking, you're likely to get laid off and then you're even worse off. But these days I'm thinking that the opposite is true, at least in bigtech: The more likely scenario is that you get laid off regardless and the stock goes up in response.

dhruvrrp•1h ago
Well, not that great for current workers either. Microsoft RSUs are usually 20% (compared to 40-80% in other big tech) or less for most employees, and on average msft has 30-50% less total compensation than other big tech.

All this stock upside might put some people's compensation to their true market value, but even that is based on tenure and historical stock vests.

s1artibartfast•1h ago
Would they be better off without the stock upside? I dont think so.
rs186•43m ago
Remember, today we are talking about "stock price is up", but tomorrow the price may be down. What the parent said does not change regardless -- Microsoft employees are not as well compensated compared to other companies, and the layoff is real.
aeternum•1h ago
It's actually been great for ex-workers. Most of their RSUs are much more valuable because the company has pushed for efficiency which has attracted investors and significantly increased market value.

While there have been layoffs, companies are generally still hiring and often employees can overlap severance with a new role.

downrightmike•58m ago
"big guns" aka betting the future on something nebulous and the true price that is costs is still not being given to consumers of that service. Like Azure, they'll lock you in and raise rates. That's the business model
ulfw•43m ago
Until they get laid off next

Please.

mgh2•1h ago
related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44778541
mg•1h ago
If Nadella grows Microsoft into the AI era as fast as Gates did in the Desktop era, it would become a 100 trillion dollar company within the next ten years:

https://www.linkedin.com/posts/marek-gibney_microsofts-story...

pizzathyme•1h ago
That number seems completely arbitrary. Why not $10 trillion or $1 quadrillion?
mg•1h ago
Because, as can be seen in the chart, during the desktop era, Microsoft grew at 60% per year.

Growing at 60% per year for ten years is a factor of slightly over 100.

delecti•31m ago
Microsoft's overall value was also much more tied to their performance in the desktop market. The whole company can grow at 60% yoy if 60% of the company doubles in value. AI is not bringing them any revenue, and double nothing is still nothing.
Andrex•1h ago
Nadella is no Gates and Ballmer wasn't either. There is only one Bill Gates and I doubt history will repeat itself.

It's a fun what if, I guess.

f1shy•43m ago
And even if Gates were there, is his luck still the same: I see constantly attribute to work and intelligence what is also a big chunk of luck and opportunities. Yes he seized it, but could it do it again? How much was luck?

Related: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=dz2vRqxf0HI&pp=0gcJCccJAYcqIYz...

gberger•1h ago
If I place a grain of rice on the first square of a chess board and double the amount on each step, I'd have 18 quintillion grains of rice.
mg•1h ago
It happens.

Life started with self-replicating molecules. And ramped up all the way to structures like the human body which consists not just of quintillions of molecules but of billions of quintillions of molecules.

vaenaes•1h ago
https://frinkiac.com/meme/S08E11/289555.jpg?b64lines=SUYgVEh...
buyucu•57m ago
Nadella is a glorified excel salesman. He has no vision about the future of technology.
moooo99•45m ago
I have my doubts that any big tech leadership has visions for technology anymore. We seem to be heading straight to a boring tech dystopia, at least if the current enshittification trajectory continues.
kevinventullo•54m ago
Windows Desktops were basically a monopoly. There are currently no monopolies in the AI era, and I wouldn’t even consider MS a first-tier competitor.
epolanski•51m ago
So Microsoft would be multiple times the GDP of the biggest economy in the world?
mg•38m ago
GDP is not static.

In the 80s, when Microsoft went public, the US GDP was under 5 Trillion.

epolanski•25m ago
So it's 6x since then and people expect Microsoft to 25x.
tonyhart7•48m ago
Microsoft lose their chance at mobile/ads era, they better get shit together if they didn't want to be next IBM
ryanackley•1h ago
Is it <waves hands towards the sky> AI? or is it years of overhiring?

There was a great article I found on HN recently about how the recent layoffs in big tech are actually the result of overhiring for years in a talent arms race.

Like, is AI now doing the former work of 25,000 people at Microsoft? Probably not.

pm90•41m ago
Almost certainly not AI, just more users going from hosted windows solutions to azure + office upsell (eg with Teams). Microsoft pretty much dominates the non Apple Desktop ecosystem and is used heavily by healthcare, defense and manufacturing industries.
SilverElfin•1h ago
Not so great news for smaller companies either. MS continues to use their muscle to gain from each super cycle without having to work for it the way smaller companies do. Their size alone makes competition unfair.
vouaobrasil•56m ago
Companies shouldn't ever be allowed to be so wealthy or powerful. This sort of power allows them to bypass legal regulations, squash small companies (something MS has been doing for a long time), force technology on people faster than they can react (think of the average clueless user that will just use anything MS puts on Windows), and create a true state of anti-competition (what kind of small company can compete with MS and not be bought out).

The only reason why they do exist is because the people with the money are the people with the power.

betaby•39m ago
> Companies shouldn't ever be allowed to be so wealthy or powerful.

I see MS as a US gov approved monopoly. I didn't check their SEC filings, but I suspect that US gov is a number one buyer, while various EU countries combined make number two. That's a coercion to me, not software business.

vouaobrasil•37m ago
I would agree with that. And if that is so, it makes it even more apparent how broken our system is. The United States after all was built on decent values but without mechanisms to safeguard the average American from the interplay and long-term effects of very advanced technology interacting with the free market economy.
01HNNWZ0MV43FF•28m ago
I wonder if a more-organized democracy would buy them out and make them state-owned.

Terms like

- You won, Windows is very popular, we are going to buy it and open source it, no more ads, no more opt-out telemetry

- Same with Office

- Same with Github

- Maybe they can keep running Azure, since it's unpopular

- XBox and Kinect and all the hardware stuff can stay private since it's not a monopoly and not de-facto public infrastructure

I wish I could live to see government that is both good and powerful, you know

vouaobrasil•27m ago
That sounds like a good partial solution. Unfortunately, it's easier for governments to use tax dollars to expand, create more comfortable positions for federal civil servants, and watch the money roll in.
thewebguyd•19m ago
I would think so, given how important (whether we at HN like it or not) their stack has become, it's basically critical infrastructure at this point for a lot of industries.

I think I could see that happening to several companies, not just MS as well - once something gets so huge that it would be detrimental to the survival of a nation if it failed, it gets nationalized.

> - Maybe they can keep running Azure, since it's unpopular

That I'm not sure about though. Azure is unpopular with SaaS, but it's increasingly popular with non-tech enterprises, as well as basically anyone that remotely competes with Amazon. Good chance that if a company's core product isn't SaaS, they are on Azure.

sylens•46m ago
As someone who has been looking to lessen my reliance on all things Microsoft, the hardest thing for me to quit has been C# and .NET. It's just a great combination of developer experience, speed, and features. It's also probably the least problematic part of Microsoft to continue using, but it still doesn't feel great.
jjice•40m ago
dotnet has gone pretty open source these days, no? I guess it may depend on the rest of your environment - maybe the Windows specific stuff like forms and WPF are still under them?

Other than that, I think you don't need too much dependence on them, depending on how you look at them controlling it. It being OSS personally gives it more stability since it can always be forked if they pull some nonsense.

fHr•46m ago
More H1B visas eh? Very bad for American tech workers.
wonderwonder•45m ago
Compound AI layoffs with outsourcing and its a dangerous time to be a software engineer in the US. I look at the current job environment with dismay. I really don't like my current role and it provides almost no benefit to my resume as i work in such a specialized niche industry but it pays well and I see no alternative. So I just clock in each day, do what i have to do and clock out dreading the next morning when I have to clock in again. I have maybe 2 years until this position winds down so am trying to do whatever I can to prepare for whats next.
benreesman•29m ago
Insulate your house with cash as much as possible, I understand better than most that saving is possible sometimes and not others, but to the degree possible? Stack it up.

Cash on hand is leverage in tech employment just like anywhere, but amolified during periods of structural demand shift. If one can get a year or three of easy runway, one can reskill/upskill into stuff with demand shifting into it. Right now I'm screwing around with Jetson boards and stuff like that: LLMs may cone and go but robots are here to stay.

And even the BATNA of "I'll go do OSS full time for a year" is leverage with your current employer. People with options are less likely to be fucked with in the first place.

Perplexity Plagiarized Our Story About How Perplexity Is a Bullshit Machine

https://www.wired.com/story/perplexity-plagiarized-our-story-about-how-perplexity-is-a-bullshit-machine/
1•rbanffy•2m ago•0 comments

The Trolley Solution: the internet's memed moral dilemma becomes a video game

https://www.theguardian.com/games/2025/aug/04/the-trolley-solution-the-internets-most-memed-moral-dilemma-becomes-a-video-game
1•mitchbob•2m ago•0 comments

Circadian Justice

https://eprints.lse.ac.uk/112431/
1•anigbrowl•3m ago•0 comments

Scientists Discovered a Way to Reverse Time–and Possibly Erase Mistakes

https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a65593746/time-travel-in-the-quantum-realm/
1•Bluestein•4m ago•0 comments

Wasps may hold the secret to slowing down the aging process

https://le.ac.uk/news/2025/july/wasp-aging-leicester-biological
2•gmays•4m ago•0 comments

Engineer restores pay phones for free public use

https://www.npr.org/2025/08/04/nx-s1-5484013/engineer-restores-pay-phones-for-free-public-use
2•lentoutcry•5m ago•0 comments

The General Theory of Enshittification

https://paulkrugman.substack.com/p/the-general-theory-of-enshittification
5•INGELRII•6m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Procrastination disguised as preparation for moment that exists in futr

https://turquoise-cicily-87.tiiny.site/
1•yantrams•7m ago•0 comments

Indeed recruiter text scam: I responded to one of the "job" messages

https://slate.com/technology/2025/08/indeed-job-recruiter-text-message-scam.html
4•tortilla•7m ago•0 comments

Genetic Hotspots for Stuttering Origins

https://news.vumc.org/2025/07/28/large-scale-study-defines-genetic-architecture-of-stuttering/
1•gmays•10m ago•0 comments

Tesla Gives Musk Some Stock

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/newsletters/2025-08-04/tesla-gives-musk-some-stock
3•ioblomov•11m ago•0 comments

World in $1.5T 'plastics crisis' hitting health from infancy to old age

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/aug/03/world-in-15tn-plastics-crisis-hitting-health-from-infancy-to-old-age-report-warns
2•mitchbob•12m ago•0 comments

I Sent 0.00000888 BTC Back to Satoshi's Address

https://lightcapai.medium.com/why-i-sent-0-00000888-btc-to-satoshis-address-18e3c15c671f
2•WASDAai•13m ago•1 comments

Markdoc and OpenAPI/Swagger spec generator

https://scheduleddowntime.com/p/why-we-built-our-own-openapi-to-markdoc
1•ewf•15m ago•0 comments

Global M&A hits $2.6T boosted by AI and quest for growth

https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/global-ma-hits-26-trillion-peak-year-to-date-boosted-by-ai-quest-growth-2025-08-04/
2•andrew_lastmile•16m ago•0 comments

Tesla awards Musk $29B in attempt to "keep Elon's energies focused on Tesla"

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2025/08/tesla-awards-elon-musk-29-billion-after-much-larger-pay-plan-blocked-in-court/
5•unsnap_biceps•19m ago•0 comments

Trends in LLM-Generated Citations on ArXiv

https://spylab.ai/blog/hallucinations/
2•jxmorris12•19m ago•0 comments

The Generativity Pattern in Rust

https://arhan.sh/blog/the-generativity-pattern-in-rust/
2•todsacerdoti•21m ago•0 comments

Avoiding Ultraprocessed Foods Might Double Weight Loss

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/08/04/well/eat/avoiding-ultraprocessed-foods-might-double-weight-loss.html
5•2OEH8eoCRo0•23m ago•2 comments

Steveyegge/efrit: A native elisp coding agent running in Emacs

https://github.com/steveyegge/efrit
1•Despacito2019•23m ago•0 comments

I should have loved biology

https://jsomers.net/i-should-have-loved-biology/
2•bilsbie•24m ago•0 comments

Central Asian Nation's Crypto Boom Sparks International Alarm

https://oilprice.com/Geopolitics/International/Central-Asian-Nations-Crypto-Boom-Sparks-International-Alarm.html
1•PaulHoule•25m ago•0 comments

Meta places order for its next ASIC-powered AI servers with Broadcom and Quanta

https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/meta-places-order-for-its-next-gen-asic-powered-ai-servers-partners-with-broadcom-and-quanta-computer/
2•giuliomagnifico•26m ago•0 comments

An attempt at a standardized description of consciousness

https://drive.google.com/file/d/18GEVyw7QTAX-0pxYWBrGm_zta-d6okmN/view?usp=drivesdk
1•Trenthug•26m ago•1 comments

Tesla board awards $29B of shares to Elon Musk

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/aug/04/tesla-board-awards-elon-musk-30bn-worth-of-shares
2•f1shy•27m ago•1 comments

Photo Editor: Pixoate Free Online Photo Editing

https://pixoate.com
1•issc•27m ago•0 comments

Who Am I in the Eye of AI?

https://lightcapai.medium.com/who-am-i-in-the-eye-of-ai-9d2b58ac53d3
1•WASDAai•28m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Tech Talks Weekly: all the latest conference talks in your inbox

https://www.techtalksweekly.io/p/what-is-tech-talks-weekly
1•techtalksweekly•29m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Trolley Problem Simulator Using Flash Lite

https://moral-compass-v4-868570596092.us-west1.run.app/
1•yantrams•29m ago•0 comments

CrowdStrike: North Korean spies posing as remote workers in 100s of companies

https://techcrunch.com/2025/08/04/north-korean-spies-posing-as-remote-workers-have-infiltrated-hundreds-of-companies-says-crowdstrike/
4•rntn•29m ago•0 comments