Ask HN: How much would it cost to build a new commercially viable OS?

1•quacked•6mo ago

Assume you’re an eccentric centi-billionaire that wants to create a new desktop/server-class OS that can match Windows, macOS, and Linux in performance, compatibility, and security, and be sold commercially as a competitor.

What would it cost to develop from scratch? How many engineers do you need? How many lawyers?

Comments

alganet•6mo ago

I'm not eccentric or rich, that's not my problem to solve. Good luck!

Anyway, why do you think that's a problem you need to think of?

bigyabai•6mo ago

Commercially-viable? Windows and MacOS are both basically given away for free these days. It's been this way on the server for decades; commercial viability means the user pays nothing.

You could probably spend a trillion dollars reinventing the kernel and still lose out to Linux in a world where the internet still exists. If you insist on a commercialized outcome then no amount will really be enough.

unsupp0rted•6mo ago

All the current commercial operating systems today are basically interchangeable, not counting a handful of design decisions (e.g. Finder vs. Explorer) or hardware compatibility.

They're all basically the same thing.

Heck Android and iOS are basically the same thing.

Would a new commercially viable OS be able to offer anything that current ones don't? If not, it's not really commercially viable.

sema4hacker•6mo ago

You'll probably have to spend more money on marketing to try to get people to use it than you will on engineering just to create it.

cc101•6mo ago

Apple started with UNIX and built on that.

thesuperbigfrog•6mo ago

You could look at BeOS to get an idea and then try to extrapolate and adapt your estimates for today's market and circumstances:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BeOS

runningmike•6mo ago

90% of the cost will be building the business. Product dev cost are minor! Do you want a business or great software that nobody uses?

Tactical tornado is the new default

Full-Circle Test-Driven Firmware Development with OpenClaw

Automating Myself Out of My Job – Part 2

Google staff call for firm to cut ties with ICE

Dependency Resolution Methods

Crypto firm apologises for sending Bitcoin users $40B by mistake

Show HN: iPlotCSV: CSV Data, Visualized Beautifully for Free

There's no such thing as "tech" (Ten years later)

List of unproven and disproven cancer treatments

Me/CFS: The blind spot in proactive medicine (Open Letter)

Ask HN: What are the word games do you play everyday?

Show HN: Paper Arena – A social trading feed where only AI agents can post

TOSTracker – The AI Training Asymmetry

The Devil Inside GitHub

Show HN: Distill – Migrate LLM agents from expensive to cheap models

Show HN: Sigma Runtime – Maintaining 100% Fact Integrity over 120 LLM Cycles

Make a local open-source AI chatbot with access to Fedora documentation

Introduce the Vouch/Denouncement Contribution Model by Mitchellh

Software Factories and the Agentic Moment

The Neuroscience Behind Nutrition for Developers and Founders

Bang bang he murdered math {the musical } (2024)

A Night Without the Nerds – Claude Opus 4.6, Field-Tested

Could ionospheric disturbances influence earthquakes?

SpaceX's next astronaut launch for NASA is officially on for Feb. 11 as FAA clea

Show HN: One-click AI employee with its own cloud desktop

Show HN: Poddley – Search podcasts by who's speaking

Same Surface, Different Weight

The Rise of Spec Driven Development

The first good Raspberry Pi Laptop

Seas to Rise Around the World – But Not in Greenland