frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Is news distorting reality and tearing society apart?

3•akitatanomoshi•1h ago
I’ve been thinking a lot about the gap between reality and the way we consume it as news.

Reality is simple. Something happened. Or nothing did.

But news rarely gives us reality. It gives us a story. And stories aren’t neutral - they spin, they speculate, and they leave things out.

For example: Charlie Kirk's assassination.

What actually happened, at first, was straightforward:

– A person was killed. – Police confirmed it was Charlie Kirk. – No motive was given. – No suspect had been identified.

But the headlines were:

“Assassination sparks fears of political extremism.” “Shooter linked to right-wing groups.” “The rise of campus violence continues.”

The facts were still there, but they became trapped inside the wrapper of story. The wrapper added spin (“sparks fears”), injected narrative (“linked to groups”), and left out what mattered most: no suspect had been named and no motive was confirmed.

Once the wrapper set in, people stopped asking what happened and started fighting over which story to believe. Stories became sides. Right vs left. Us vs them.

This happens every time. The shared ground of truth — what actually happened, what we can all agree on, what could bring us together — gets lost in the distortion of the better story.

I've come to believe that this distortion is dividing us and it's tearing society apart.

Stories are being weaponised by populists who thrive on fear and capitalists who benefit from monetising it. The best storytellers are winning attention and winning power and keeping their power by telling even better stories.

So here is my question.

Is there a way to recover a shared ground of truth? Or are stories too deeply ingrained in how humans process information?

Can we recover from where we are by rejecting news as stories and adopting a different form?

Comments

mrtomservo•1h ago
You've got the crux already:

> Stories are being weaponised by populists who thrive on fear and capitalists who benefit from monetising it. The best storytellers are winning attention and winning power and keeping their power by telling even better stories.

It is increasingly costly to reach an audience (especially one of the size that would be required to have a "shared ground") not only in the sense of cash money, but also the attention cost of convincing that audience that those "better stories" (perhaps more shocking, outraging, etc.) they've been told might not be actually true.

News is becoming yet another industry that rewards the first mover -- write that first shocking headline, and all the other outlets have to work 10 or 100 times as hard to correct it later.

bix6•1h ago
I don’t see it happening. What is truth? A source I find unbiased is incredibly biased to someone who disagrees with me. I believe my truth and they believe theirs. How can we find middle ground in this situation? I just don’t see a way especially when the spin is so much more captivating for people; we crave the craziness.
GuinansEyebrows•1h ago
> Is there a way to recover a shared ground of truth? Or are stories too deeply ingrained in how humans process information?

the older i get, the more i read of history, and the worse things become, the more sympathetic i am to those who argue that armed revolution is the only catalyst for dramatic change.

and i hate that.

i don't want to live in a violent country. i don't want my neighbors to live in fear because of the color of their skin or their nationality or their accent. i don't want to have a reasonable quality of life tied to whatever employer will give me health care. and i don't want to hurt another person - anyone.

but i just don't see a peaceful de-escalation happening; i don't see any kind of de-escalation happening until enough people decide the profit motive is the wrong motive in all situations and that we need to drastically change the way we interact with the world and one another.

:(

appreciatorBus•56m ago
How do you square that with the objectively terrible results of all the times in the last 100 ish years that ppl justified the use of violence to eradicate the concept of profit or self-interest? This time it will be different?

Anyone acting in good faith can find plenty to dislike about markets and prices and systems built on top of them.

But the problem is that anyone acting in good faith can also find plenty to dislike about collective systems built no allowance for markets or pricing.

I hear a lot of people talking about the former, a very rarely do I hear any collectivist or socialists speak openly and honestly about the latter.

Markets and prices are not perfect, but they are useful. Many other concepts are useful too.

As I age, the transformation that I notice in my thinking is simply that I no longer believe there is some perfect socioeconomic system, waiting for us out there. There’s only us, and a bunch of imperfect concepts and ideas. It’s up to us to put them together in ways that work, but I don’t think there’s some perfect arrangement that will solve all our problems for all time.

Learning Languages with the Help of Algorithms

https://www.johndcook.com/blog/2025/09/17/learning-languages-with-the-help-of-algorithms/
1•ibobev•2m ago•0 comments

Decoding a Disorder at the Interface of Mind and Brain

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/decoding-a-disorder-at-the-interface-of-mind-and-brain/
1•nibblenum•9m ago•1 comments

Engineering Highly Cellularized Living Materials via Mechanical Agitation

https://advanced.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/adfm.202515436
2•PaulHoule•9m ago•0 comments

Meta Ray-Ban Display with Neural Band

https://www.meta.com/ai-glasses/meta-ray-ban-display-glasses-and-neural-band/
2•zhyder•10m ago•1 comments

Ap2 Protocol Documentation

https://ap2-protocol.net/
1•QingWu•13m ago•0 comments

The AI Raj: How tech giants are recolonizing power

https://thebulletin.org/2025/09/the-ai-raj-how-tech-giants-are-recolonizing-power/
1•pseudolus•13m ago•0 comments

How the classic McIntosh lost the battle for Apple supremacy

https://thehustle.co/originals/how-the-classic-mcintosh-lost-the-battle-for-apple-supremacy
1•paulpauper•13m ago•0 comments

White House officials reportedly frustrated by Anthropic's AI limits

https://arstechnica.com/ai/2025/09/white-house-officials-reportedly-frustrated-by-anthropics-law-...
3•duxup•14m ago•2 comments

Meta Ray Ban Display and Neural Interface Announced

https://about.fb.com/news/2025/09/meta-ray-ban-display-ai-glasses-emg-wristband/
7•spot•15m ago•1 comments

Stone-Skimming Contest in Scotland Is Infiltrated by Cheaters

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/16/world/europe/stone-skimming-championship-cheating.html
1•gk1•16m ago•0 comments

ATC Tells Pilot to Get Off iPad and Turn Away from Air Force One Carrying Trump

https://simpleflying.com/spirit-airlines-ordered-turn-away-air-force-one/
2•wslh•20m ago•1 comments

Meta Announces New AI Glasses and Band

https://www.meta.com/ai-glasses/meta-ray-ban-display/
4•dream000•23m ago•0 comments

Meta Ray-Ban Display

https://www.meta.com/blog/meta-ray-ban-display-ai-glasses-connect-2025/
2•bpierre•23m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Hacker News Analyzer – LLM summaries of the most active threads

https://hackernewsanalyzer.com/
1•sahn44•24m ago•0 comments

Everyone has a Chinese peptide dealer now

https://sfstandard.com/2025/09/14/everyone-has-chinese-peptide-dealer-now/
2•pogue•28m ago•1 comments

U.S. sees 5.7M more childless women than expected

https://www.psypost.org/u-s-sees-5-7-million-more-childless-women-than-expected-fueling-a-demogra...
5•geox•32m ago•3 comments

Waze for parking – don't pay the meter

https://parkremark.com/demo
2•benlimner•36m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Visual Prompts for Coding Agents

https://github.com/adiasg/prompt-canvas
1•adiasg•37m ago•0 comments

Most referrals never turn into meetings. Why does this happen?

2•kez_•38m ago•3 comments

Meta Ray-Ban Display: A Breakthrough Category of AI Glasses

https://www.meta.com/fr-fr/blog/meta-ray-ban-display-ai-glasses-connect-2025/
14•martpie•39m ago•5 comments

Meta Ray-Ban Display hands-on: the best I've ever tried

https://www.theverge.com/tech/779566/meta-ray-ban-display-hands-on-smart-glasses-price-battery-specs
8•coloneltcb•42m ago•0 comments

Why Bell Labs Worked (But the Likes of Google and Apple Don't)

https://manganiello.social/notice/AukwkbWFAQDB0uXM80
3•donjoe0•43m ago•0 comments

US Faces Global Free Speech Showdown with Brazil

https://www.newsweek.com/us-free-speech-showdown-brazil-2130732
4•smnthermes•46m ago•0 comments

Xkcd: Free Speech

https://xkcd.com/1357/
9•good8675309•49m ago•2 comments

Is It Time to Rethink Stream Processing?

https://www.epsio.io/blog/on-the-future-of-data-streaming
3•dkgs1998•49m ago•0 comments

Playstation 5 SSD Shrinkflation

https://www.tomshardware.com/video-games/playstation/playstation-5-digital-edition-with-1tb-ssd-d...
2•zdw•50m ago•0 comments

Bitcoin Is Worse Is Better (2011)

https://gwern.net/bitcoin-is-worse-is-better
2•greyface-•50m ago•0 comments

FileFix: A New Attack Hides Malware in Plain Sight

https://securityonline.info/filefix-a-new-attack-hides-malware-in-plain-sight/
3•kPwn•52m ago•0 comments

Stepping Down as Libxml2 Maintainer

https://discourse.gnome.org/t/stepping-down-as-libxml2-maintainer/31398
1•zdw•52m ago•0 comments

Meta: Failed Live AI Demo

https://www.facebook.com/Meta/videos/meta-connect-keynote/1927325824791552/
7•arnab_optimatik•57m ago•4 comments