Companies whose level of respect for user privacy is well-known.
Also, perhaps significantly, the passed version of the bill removes "sole" from "for the sole purpose of providing..."
I would never suggest that we ignore the law. I would suggest, however, that my vibe-coded tool that lets people track time and create invoices does not need to gather the age of anyone.
Common sense should be an emergent property of this new systemic regulation, and we should all aim for that.
k310•3mo ago
I've read this and it bamboozles me (IANAL) and I don't see a size threshold, nor a floor, as in "free". IMNSHO, overreaching, without limits.
And when kids are writing vibe apps, will they be nailed for $2500+?
JohnFen•3mo ago
It doesn't seem nearly as oppressive as you fear. It age-gates online services. The only impact to software is indirect: "covered manufacturers" of devices must provide a mechanism during setup to collect the user's age. This is to be used to send a signal about age to online services.
By my reading, that's about it. Am I missing something?
musicale•3mo ago
Surely that information could never leak out, or be used for other purposes.
k310•3mo ago
Tell me how this exempts linux systems, the distro authors, and every app developer for said operating systems.
So, an IT director might have to certify that all sysadmins and developers are over 18?
And what if a child has access to email or other service run on that system. Tomorrow, I'll give some thought to wi-fi and other routers.
I see nothing excepted.
YMMV
JohnFen•3mo ago
There's nothing to exempt. If the OS is preinstalled on a device, this will require the device to ask the user's age during initialization. That's all.
> So, an IT director might have to certify that all sysadmins and developers are over 18?
I see nothing in the law that even hints at this.
> And what if a child has access to email or other service run on that system. Tomorrow, I'll give some thought to wi-fi and other routers.
I also see nothing in the law that addresses this.
dabockster•3mo ago
From what I understand, CA wants some kind of age field at the operating system/browser level that can be set once by a parent and trusted to work on every website out there - instead of the current system of needing to manually set an age on every individual website.
aitchnyu•3mo ago
dabockster•3mo ago