frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Berty – an encrypted and offline peer-to-peer messenger with no central server

https://berty.tech/features
42•HelloUsername•3mo ago

Comments

jqpabc123•3mo ago
I imagine the number of simultaneous connections is strictly limited.

For example, can multiple people message one person at the same time?

I'm thinking of local communication among groups of co-workers.

compressedgas•3mo ago
Reminds me of https://briarproject.org/
thomastjeffery•3mo ago
There is too much communication on what Berty doesn't do, and not enough on what it does.

So can it send messages over a network? Do messages have to be sent over a direct connection to the recipient's hardware? If messages can be carried by an intermediate, then who, when, and how? It would help a lot to answer these questions more immediately.

undeveloper•3mo ago
It's over bluetooth directly it seems. No clue why that jack dorsey app "bitchat" wouldn't serve the same purpose
thomastjeffery•3mo ago
They are unclear about it, but from the looks of it, that's optional.

> The main concept of the Wesh Protocol is called the "group", a virtual place where multiple devices can share messages and metadata using OrbitDB, which itself relies on the InterPlanetary File System (IPFS)

I don't really care enough to dig deeper, so I'm not going to bother answering my own questions.

MarsIronPI•3mo ago
What's different about this one compared to Briar, Tox, Scuttlebutt, Cabal.Chat, NomadNet or Chitchatter (to name a few)?

IMO peer-to-peer chat is a mostly-solved problem. I think the problem that needs addressing is not lack of peer-to-peer technology, but lack of adoption. People (mostly) don't care, so they (mostly) won't switch unless you strong-arm them in some way or another, or convince them to care. And either way, if they're not close to you, you basically have no influence on them, so you still end up needing to use non-free, non-private modes of communication. Network effects are rough.

alan_n•3mo ago
Does this support group chats? How does it do encryption if so?
netsharc•3mo ago
I like the "Hey why don't you put your email address in our central database that authorities might find useful when they raid us?" form at the bottom of that page...