I wish they would’ve actually discussed _how_ the hack was accomplished
gwbas1c•3mo ago
Uhm, broadcast on the same frequency? It's not that hard to figure out what frequency Marconi was broadcasting on.
IAmBroom•3mo ago
Those were the early days of radio, as in "Let there be light" kind of early.
Very few people could even build a receiver, much less tune it.
TRiG_Ireland•3mo ago
Nah. He just did a broad spectrum broadcast which any receiver in the area would pick up. Today, it'd probably be illegal. Tom Scott made a video about it, and mentioned that. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sP2qqMegNKA
kbenson•3mo ago
I think what's left unsaid and implied is that the original system wasn't secure in any way, the "tuning" was just choosing a frequency. It's only a "hack" because of the claims that were made.
In a way, that would be like advertising a secure horseback large sign delivery service, where the "security" is that the sender and receiver choose one of a few routes between locations, even though the large sign is easily seen and entirely uncovered, making the courier easily identified and the sign when in transit easily read from a distance. The "hack" for that type of system is ultimately so trivial as to be mostly uninteresting.
estimator7292•3mo ago
It's just a simple AM broadcast. It was only novel at the time because radio was new.
nadis•3mo ago
Being accused of "scientific hooliganism" by a worthy adversary sounds like a new personal goal.
optimalsolver•3mo ago
Title sounds like some kind of LLM prompt injection.
charliebwrites•3mo ago
gwbas1c•3mo ago
IAmBroom•3mo ago
Very few people could even build a receiver, much less tune it.
TRiG_Ireland•3mo ago
kbenson•3mo ago
In a way, that would be like advertising a secure horseback large sign delivery service, where the "security" is that the sender and receiver choose one of a few routes between locations, even though the large sign is easily seen and entirely uncovered, making the courier easily identified and the sign when in transit easily read from a distance. The "hack" for that type of system is ultimately so trivial as to be mostly uninteresting.
estimator7292•3mo ago