.arpa, rDNS and a few magical ICMP hacks

62•caminanteblanco•3mo ago

Comments

possiblelion•3mo ago

super interesting. the early days of military networks always fascinate me, especially the legacy holdovers like .arpa

ectospheno•3mo ago

Between resolver.arpa, ipv4only.arpa, and the fact that your email won't be delivered to anywhere you actually care about without in-addr.arpa I'm not sure I'd call it legacy.

caminanteblanco•3mo ago

I didn't even realize that half of the parts of the stack mentioned here existed. I'm going through the process of setting up a home server, and this is definitely giving me some ideas for nonsense to implement.

anonymousiam•3mo ago

Reverse delegation (RFC 2317) is the way IP-to-FQDN lookups are usually done now. Before this was popular, you could get your ISP to defer to your DNS for reverse records directly, versus them using a set of individual PTR records.

Even though the RFC was written in 1998, it took a while for it to catch on. For years, my DNS servers were using both methods.

Both methods make use of the .in-addr.arpa "domain" syntax.

ranger_danger•3mo ago

> Reverse delegation (RFC 2317) is the way IP-to-FQDN lookups are usually done now

> Before this was popular, you could get your ISP to defer to your DNS for reverse records directly

I'm not actually seeing the difference between these two... besides this new "reverse delegation" allowing different nameservers for prefixes longer than /24... aren't you still relying on your ISP/upstream provider (if you don't own your own IPs) to delegate reverse lookups to your own DNS server either way?

merlyn•3mo ago

Correct, what RFC2317 brings you, is an example of you creating a new namespace in some structured format (IIRC, there are three different example formats given in this RFC), and you just have the upstream ISP, which has the reverse delegation done on the zone cut boundary for the IP ranges it controls inserting a CNAME out to your new namespace on nameservers you control for the reverse PTRs so the reverse PTRs can be formed that way.

Running a long time ISP, I found extremely few customers wanting to do something like RFC2317, or could actually figure out and do it effectively. Almost all were content with control panel/API and having the ISP do it after I pointed them to this informational RFC asking them if this is what they wanted.

anonymousiam•3mo ago

I think part of the reason most ISPs don't support RFC2317 or reverse delegation is that it makes it easy for a bad actor who's in charge of the DNS server being delegated to, to spoof any domain they want. The consequences of this sort of spoofing have now been limited by other systems and protocols anyway, so it's not as big of a deal.

ISPs prefer to have direct control of the reverse lookups within their IP blocks so they can ensure the integrity of the information.

Maple Mono: Smooth your coding flow

Sid Meier's System for Real-Time Music Composition and Synthesis

Show HN: Slop News – HN front page now, but it's all slop

Show HN: Empusa – Visual debugger to catch and resume AI agent retry loops

Show HN: Bitcoin wallet on NXP SE050 secure element, Tor-only open source

White House Explores Opening Antitrust Probe on Homebuilders

Show HN: MindDraft – AI task app with smart actions and auto expense tracking

How do you estimate AI app development costs accurately?

Going Through Snowden Documents, Part 5

Show HN: MCP Server for TradeStation

Canada unveils auto industry plan in latest pivot away from US

The essential Reinhold Niebuhr: selected essays and addresses

Rentahuman.ai Turns Humans into On-Demand Labor for AI Agents

StovexGlobal – Compliance Gaps to Note

Show HN: Afelyon – Turns Jira tickets into production-ready PRs (multi-repo)

Trump says America should move on from Epstein – it may not be that easy

Tiny Clippy – A native Office Assistant built in Rust and egui

LegalArgumentException: From Courtrooms to Clojure – Sen [video]

US moves to deport 5-year-old detained in Minnesota

If you lose your passport in Austria, head for McDonald's Golden Arches

Show HN: Mermaid Formatter – CLI and library to auto-format Mermaid diagrams

RFCs vs. READMEs: The Evolution of Protocols

Kanchipuram Saris and Thinking Machines

Chinese chemical supplier causes global baby formula recall

I've used AI to write 100% of my code for a year as an engineer

Looking for 4 Autistic Co-Founders for AI Startup (Equity-Based)

AI-native capabilities, a new API Catalog, and updated plans and pricing

What changed in tech from 2010 to 2020?

From Human Ergonomics to Agent Ergonomics

Advanced Inertial Reference Sphere