frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Word2vec-style vector arithmetic on docs embeddings

https://technicalwriting.dev/embeddings/arithmetic/index.html
66•kaycebasques•15h ago

Comments

aDyslecticCrow•13h ago
There have been quite a few writing tools that are effectively just GPT wrappers with pre-defined prompts. "rephrase this more formally". Personally I find them to modify too much or are difficult to use effectively. Asking a for a few different rephrasings and then merging it myself ends up being my workflow.

But ever since learning about word2vec, I've been thinking that there must be a better way. "Push" a section in with the formal vector a bit. Add a pinch of "brief", dial up the "humour" vector. I think it could create a very controllable and efficient writing tool.

acmiyaguchi•12h ago
This does exist to some degree, as far as I understand, along the lines of style-transfer and ControlNet in visual domains. Anthropic has some research called "persona vectors" which effectively push generative behaviors toward or away from particular traits.

[0] https://www.anthropic.com/research/persona-vectors [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.21509

nostrebored•12h ago
> How do we actually use this in technical writing workflows or documentation experiences? I’m not sure. I was just curious to learn whether or not it would work.

--

There are a few easy applications.

* When surfacing relevant documents, you can keep a list of the previous documents visited and boost in the "direction" that the customer is headed (could be an average of the previous N docs or weight towards frequency). But then you're just building a worse recsys for something where latency probably isn't that critical.

* If you know for every feature you release, you need an API doc, an FAQ, usage samples for different workflows or verticals you're targetting, you can represent each of these as f(doc) + f(topic) and find the existing doc set. But then, you can have much more deterministic workflows from just applying structure.

It's nice that you have a super flexible tool in the toolbox, but I think a lot of text based embedding applications (especially on out of domain data like long, unchunked technical docs) are just better off being something else if you have the time.

kaycebasques•10h ago
> If you know for every feature you release, you need an API doc, an FAQ, usage samples for different workflows or verticals you're targetting, you can represent each of these as f(doc) + f(topic) and find the existing doc set. But then, you can have much more deterministic workflows from just applying structure.

This one sounds promising to me, thanks for the suggestion. We technical writers often build out "docs completeness" spreadsheets where we track how completely each product feature is covered, exactly as you described. E.g. the rows are features, column B is "Reference", column C is "Tutorial" etc. So cell B1 would contain the deeplink to the reference for some particular feature. When we inherit a huge, messy docs set (which is fairly common) it can take a very long time to build out a docs completeness dashboard. I think the embeddings workflow you're suggesting could speed up the initial population of these dashboards a lot.

seg_lol•10h ago
You can probably do this in a day with a CLI based LLM like Claude Code. It can write the tools that would allow you to sort, test and cross check your doc sets.
jdthedisciple•12h ago
Intriguing! This inspired me to run the example "calculation" ("king" - "man" + "woman") against several well-known embedding models and order them by L2 distance between the actual output and the embedding for "queen". Result:

    voyage-3-large:             0.54
    voyage-code-3:              0.62
    qwen3-embedding:4b:         0.71
    embeddinggemma:             0.84
    voyage-3.5-lite:            0.94
    text-embedding-3-small:     0.97
    voyage-3.5:                 1.01
    text-embedding-3-large:     1.13
Shocked by the apparently bad performance of OpenAI's SOTA model. Also always had a gut feeling that `voyage-3-large` secretly may be the best embedding model out there. Have I been vindicated? Make of it what you will ...

Also `qwen3-embedding:4b` is my current favorite for local RAG for good reason...

smallerize•10h ago
That never exactly worked for word2vec either. https://blog.esciencecenter.nl/king-man-woman-king-9a7fd2935...
kaycebasques•9h ago
From the linked article:

> The widely known example only works because the implementation of the algorithm will exclude the original vector from the possible results!

I saw this issue in the "same topic, different domain" experiment when using EmbeddingGemma with the default task types. But when using custom task types, the vector arithmetic worked as expected. I didn't have to remove the original vector from the results or control for that in any way. So while the criticism is valid for word2vec I'm skeptical that modern embedding models still have this issue.

Very curious to learn whether modern models are still better at some analogies (e.g. male/female) and worse at others, though. Is there any more recent research on that topic? The linked article is from 2019.

gojomo•9h ago
Not sure you can judge whether these modern models do well on the 'arithmetic analogization' task based on absolute similarity values – & especially L2 distances.

That it ever worked was simply that, among the universe of candidate answers, the right answer was closer to the arithmetic-result-point than other candidates – not necessarily close on any absolute scale. Especially in higher dimensions, everything gets very angularly far from everything else - the "curse of dimensionality".

But the relative differences may still be just as useful/effective. So the real evaluation of effectiveness can't be done with the raw value diff(king-man+woman, queen) alone. It needs to check if that value is less than that for every other alternative to 'queen'.

(Also: canonically these exercises were done as cosine-similarities, not Euclidean/L2 distance. Rank orders will be roughly the same if all vectors normalized to the unit sphere before arithmetic & comparisons, but if you didn't do that, it would also make these raw 'distance' values less meaningful for evaluating this particular effect. The L2 distance could be arbitrarily high for two vectors with 0.0 cosine-difference!)

jdthedisciple•16m ago
> It needs to check if that value is less than that for every other alternative to 'queen'.

There you go: Closest 3 words (by L2) to the output vector for the following models, out of the most common 2265 spoken English words among which is also "queen":

    voyage-3-large:             king (0.46), woman (0.47), young (0.52), ... queen (0.56)
    ollama-qwen3-embedding:4b:  king (0.68), queen (0.71), woman (0.81)
    text-embedding-3-large:     king (0.93), woman (1.08), queen (1.13)
All embeddings are normalized to unit length, therefore L2 dists are normalized.
thornton•10h ago
We’ve done similar work. Use case was identifying pages in an old website that now 404 and where they should be redirected to.

Basically doc2vec and cosine similarity. Totally nonsensical matching outputs to the point matching on title tag vectors or precis was better so now I’m curious if we just did something wrong…

gojomo•9h ago
If by 'doc2vec' you mean the word2vec-like 'Paragraph Vectors' technique: even though that's a far simpler approach than the transformer embeddings, it usually works pretty well for coarse document similarity. Even the famous word2vec vector-addition operations kinda worked, as illustrated by some examples in the followup 'Paragraph Vector' paper in 2015: https://arxiv.org/abs/1507.07998

So if for you the resulting doc-to-doc similarities seemed nonsensical, there was likely some process error in model training or application.

Columnar and the ADBC Driver Foundry

https://columnar.tech/blog/announcing-columnar/
1•refset•2m ago•0 comments

(1) the Great American Soybean Con Job [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYEMuzss1Ys
1•xbmcuser•6m ago•0 comments

Comparison Traits – Understanding Equality and Ordering in Rust

https://itsfoxstudio.substack.com/p/comparison-traits-understanding-equality
1•rpunkfu•15m ago•0 comments

Leaving the Freedesktop.org Community

https://vt.social/@lina/115431232807081648
3•birdculture•21m ago•0 comments

A Death Train Is Haunting South Florida

https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/2025/10/brightline-train-florida/684624/
1•raw_anon_1111•24m ago•0 comments

Parsing with zippers improves parsing with derivatives

https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3408990
1•fanf2•33m ago•0 comments

Trump threatens to go into Nigeria 'guns-a-blazing' over attacks on Christians

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/nov/01/trump-nigeria-christian-persecution
2•prmph•38m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Postflare AI – An AI-Powered Social Media Strategist and Bulk Scheduler

1•techxeni•41m ago•1 comments

Throw and Catch-a 30-second relaxing dog fetch game (plays in browser)

https://throwandfetch.com
2•kwaeason•45m ago•0 comments

Lincoln Island – imaginary space for the entrepreneurial kind

https://growingfearless.substack.com/p/lincoln-island-is-ready-to-receive
2•josmor•47m ago•0 comments

Cali THCA Blend Vape pen 500mg

1•arbiabbasi•49m ago•0 comments

Apple is killing old phones/Macs instantly with the glass thing

7•vasan•50m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How do you manage your prompts in agent workflows

2•ph4rsikal•55m ago•0 comments

Down with T2, long live T3 Metrics for q.computers that one should think about

https://m-malinowski.github.io/2025/09/07/quantum-coherence.html
1•wadamczyk•57m ago•0 comments

How Should Business and Tech Leaders Spend in 2026?

https://insurtechamsterdam.com/public/blog/ai-technology-spend
2•Venesha•59m ago•0 comments

Insurance and Climate Risk

https://insurtechamsterdam.com/public/blog/insurance-climate-risk
1•Venesha•1h ago•0 comments

Mixboard

https://labs.google.com/mixboard/welcome
1•ms7892•1h ago•0 comments

Build to Last – Chris Lattner on Software Craftsmanship and AI

https://www.fast.ai/posts/2025-10-30-build-to-last.html
3•tamnd•1h ago•0 comments

Through the Crystal Ball of VC Florian Graillot

https://insurtechamsterdam.com/public/blog/insurance-innovation
1•Venesha•1h ago•0 comments

Our newest model: Chandra (OCR)

https://www.datalab.to/blog/introducing-chandra
1•denysvitali•1h ago•0 comments

ChatGPT leaked conversations to Google Search console

https://www.quantable.com/ai/the-old-rules-are-dead/
4•miohtama•1h ago•0 comments

Context engineering

https://chrisloy.dev/post/2025/08/03/context-engineering
3•chrisloy•1h ago•0 comments

Samsung Internet Browser Launches on Windows

https://browser.samsung.com/beta
1•KoftaBob•1h ago•0 comments

Wealth, Shown to Scale

https://eattherichtextformat.github.io/1-pixel-wealth/
7•Manheim•1h ago•0 comments

Reimagining social media optimized for meaning, not engagement

https://www.facts.social/
3•guywithnoh•1h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: What are you working on? (November 2025)

5•tamnd•1h ago•3 comments

Computer Entertainer (1982 – 1990)

https://archive.gamehistory.org/folder/519c0dbd-0f5d-45fe-83c2-355a756391a9?sortField=date&sortDi...
1•jruohonen•1h ago•0 comments

Show HN: I built a free VPN that runs directly in Chrome

https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/quickvpn-proxy-–-vpn-for/pnbbbdihfmedmgilpjldboihdodhnkel
2•hritik7742•1h ago•0 comments

FortNine – Google is often paid for fake ad influence [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BfNIRyPi5QA
1•juliushuijnk•1h ago•1 comments

Spinoza's Ethics

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spinoza%27s_Ethics
5•r_singh•2h ago•0 comments