frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Tesla sales in Germany have cratered from last year, data shows

https://www.cnbc.com/2025/11/05/tesla-musk-germany-sales-down.html
42•moosedman•3mo ago

Comments

belter•3mo ago
"Tesla sales crash across Europe with drops of up to 90%" - https://www.techspot.com/news/110124-tesla-sales-crash-acros...

Reminder that last quarter Tesla reported record deliveries...basis for an SEC investigation?

bdangubic•3mo ago
> basis for an SEC investigation

That is funny. Of all the things Tesla should be under investigation their sales in Germany won't make top-100 list.

belter•3mo ago
I am referring to their dramatic reduction in sales and market share loss in all European markets...and struggling in China...while reporting record deliveries. Fairy tales or creative reporting?
bdangubic•3mo ago
the sales surged in the US due to tax credit expiration
belter•3mo ago
You are repeating unproven claims repeated by badly paid US financial analysts mostly at CNBC. If that is true, it would show on up on vehicle registration, specially in California their largest market...but it does not...

In California, that is Tesla biggest U.S. market, registrations fell 9.4% in Q3 and are down 15.1% YTD. If there were a big U.S. rush, you’d expect CA to pop, it did not.

Also looking at this whole thread, the selective downvote of my comments by Tesla sycophants shows I am on to something...

quantified•3mo ago
Tesla can say anything as being "commercial puffery".
bdcravens•3mo ago
Tesla's sales last quarter were the result of the US ending subsidies, so record sales and decreases outside of the US aren't mutually exclusive facts.
more_corn•3mo ago
I wonder if it’s still too soon for the CEO of a car company to throw up a Nazi salute on an internationally televised event. Let’s check the sales results. Yep still too soon.

Also pro tip. If you didn’t MEAN to throw up a Nazi salute and you’re sorry for offending people you should immediately (or at all) 1) say that wasn’t intended to be one 2) apologize for offending everyone who isn’t a Nazi 3) Refrain from presenting a collection of Nazi jokes as your sole public defense.

quantified•3mo ago
Having sold all the ones possible to affluent Greens, it's how you sell the remainder to affluent conservatives.
michael1999•3mo ago
except that ev sales are up just tesla is down

https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/teslas...

testing22321•3mo ago
Model Y was the best selling vehicle in Europe in September

https://www.autonews.com/tesla/ane-europe-top-50-september-2...

0cf8612b2e1e•3mo ago
Is that because they have fewer model numbers? If you look at fleet sales, does that placement still hold? Something like Toyota might have dozens of different similar products, diluting their rank ordering.
breve•3mo ago
Volkswagen sells more EVs than Tesla in Europe:

https://eu-evs.com/marketShare/ALL/Groups/Line/All-time-by-Q...

Volkswagen's sales are split across many brands (VW, Audi, Skoda, Porsche, Cupra, MAN, Scania, etc.) and models.

rsynnott•3mo ago
This is largely a function of their brand positioning. There are about 20 models of car under about 6 brands on the VW MEB platform, all, well, very similar (except the weird microbus thing). Tesla has instead chosen to go for two models under one brand.

Both are _valid_ approaches, and you see both from other companies (eg GM leans into the many brands thing fairly heavily, BMW is single brand few models), but it does make claims of "this is the best selling vehicle" rather uninteresting.

bfkwlfkjf•3mo ago
Turns out Nazis aren't popular in Germany.

EDIT: it's funny that I say this every time, and every time I get downvoted. I have no idea why.

MandieD•3mo ago
Possibly because unfortunately, about 20% of German voters voted for the AfD in the last federal election, which likes to put some Nazi-sounding stuff on its campaign posters ("Kinder statt Inder," for example).

However, your analysis still kind of stands, as the AfD and even more extreme parties (like "Wahre Alternativ") tend to do better in the worse-off parts of the country like the hollowed-out districts on the eastern border (such as the one my brother-in-law left pretty much the moment his accounting degree hit his hand) where people were not big Tesla buyers, and poorly in affluent, well-educated places like Munich and Freiburg, where the kind of people who had been buying Teslas live (and are now buying just about any other EV).

bfkwlfkjf•3mo ago
Oh you mean people are downvoting because they disagree that Nazis are unpopular. Never thought that would be it.
rsynnott•3mo ago
Even discounting the economics, leaning into something which is liked by 20% of the population and loathed by everyone else is poor brand positioning.

Also, I feel like "I wasn't going to buy this, but the CEO did a Nazi salute and I like Nazi salutes so I'll buy it" is a much weirder and less probable phenomenon than "well, I was going to buy this, but the CEO did a Nazi salute so fuck no". Political affinity isn't really enough to make people buy what they otherwise weren't going to buy, but political anathema _will_ be enough to put people who were potential buyers off.

0815beck•3mo ago
Tesla went from "a cool tech company, and also the ceo does rocket stuff, which is kinda nice" to "what is wrong with that f*cking nazi jerk" in the last 10 years in my circles, and it is very much deserved.
bn-l•3mo ago
When that word is used dishonestly for everyone you don’t agree with it loses all meaning.
evanb•3mo ago
In Germany it hits home when someone gives the Roman salute with an angry scowl on your face during a moment of transition of power.
moogly•3mo ago
Twice. While paraphrasing the 14 Words.

And not even denying it afterwards.

a_bonobo•3mo ago
and gives public presentations at gatherings of the far-far-right party https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-01-26/elon-musk-supports-af...
rsynnott•3mo ago
> Roman salute

Btw, note that it was not actually a Roman salute (though it may have been adopted by Italian fascists because they incorrectly believed it had been used by the Romans; they were keen on Roman iconography).

evanb•3mo ago
Indeed, but if I had called it the Nazi salute I'd have been begging the question---or something like it.
bn-l•3mo ago
This is a pure lie and pure slander. I’m not even a fan boy but you can’t just outright slander people. It’s shameful.
noir_lord•3mo ago
> “The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.” (Orwell).

Everyone can watch the video and draw their own conclusion but how anyone can and not see it I don't know.

belter•3mo ago
And this factual post is flagged because?