Ask HN: What's the Deal with XMPP

2•ekjhgkejhgk•3mo ago

I just recently discovered XMPP, and why isn't it more widely used?

Last time I went exploring into free messaging alternatives I looked into Matrix. I looked into Matrix again, and it's still terrribly slow. XMPP on the other hand is snappy. Despite this, XMPP is still more widely used than Matrix (not to mention whatsapp/signal/telegram). Why is this? Is there some downside I'm missing?

Comments

vga42•3mo ago

It's 'extensible.' That's what they say. 'Extensible.' You know what that means? It means they didn't finish it! It's like buying a car, and they say, 'Oh, the engine? That's... extensible. You figure it out!'

ekjhgkejhgk•3mo ago

That's such an uncharitable take... Many of these features that you would say make it unfinished didn't exist when XMPP first came out.

Being extensible has its downsides for sure, but calling it unfinished because it can be extended...

ekjhgkejhgk•3mo ago

Ignorant take. WhatsApp uses XMPP. Zoom uses XMPP.

You see, I kept learning about XMPP and thinking "this is really good stuff, why isn't it more widely used?"

And so I realized: It IS very widely used precisely for being so good. Then the companies intentionally making it un-interoperable.

BrenBarn•2mo ago

I mean Matrix is also extensible.

pndy•3mo ago

We had XMPP in facebook's messenger and google talk up until both companies decided that they embraced this open protocol enough and removed support /s

Pretty sure someone recently commented on XMPP and why it failed - mostly because of variety of servers and clients which differ among each other too much.

In Poland the second most popular instant messenger network during the "golden period" beside Gadu Gadu was Tlen.pl. It used a modified XMPP but it was never fully compatible with it - it was impossible to reach contacts from tlen.pl domain. Then facebook arrived and people moved from "domestic" networks to global ones.

apothegm•3mo ago

XMPP comes with the additional downside that most of the tooling around it is (or at least, a decade ago was) written in Erlang. Which is a niche purely functional language with a weird-ass syntax that is challenging to transition to from the C-syntax-derived procedural/OOP languages that make up the vast bulk of mainstream programming.

ezst•2mo ago

That's provably untrue. If you mainly write modules for the ejabberd server, indeed erlang might be on the menu, but that's very specific. If you develop on the client-side, pretty much all mainstream languages (JS, Python, C/C++ w&w/o Qt, Java, Go, rust, C#, …) have decent and independently well-maintained libraries to interact with XMPP. On the server-side, prosody (Lua) is as big (if not bigger) than ejabberd. And there are Openfire (JVM) and other implementations as well. Erlang is definitely not as unavoidable as you make it seem.

Show HN: Deterministic NDJSON audit logs – v1.2 update (structural gaps)

The Greater Copenhagen Region could be your friend's next career move

Do Not Confirm – Fiction by OpenClaw

The Analytical Profile of Peas

Hallucinations in GPT5 – Can models say "I don't know" (June 2025)

What AI is good for, according to developers

OpenAI might pivot to the "most addictive digital friend" or face extinction

Show HN: Know how your SaaS is doing in 30 seconds

ClawdBot Ordered Me Lunch

What the News media thinks about your Indian stock investments

Running Lua on a tiny console from 2001

Google and Microsoft Paying Creators $500K+ to Promote AI Tools

New filtration technology could be game-changer in removal of PFAS

Show HN: I saw this cool navigation reveal, so I made a simple HTML+CSS version

Kinda Surprised by Seadance2's Moderation

I Write Games in C (yes, C)

Django scales. Stop blaming the framework (part 1 of 3)

Malwarebytes Is Now in ChatGPT

Thoughts on the job market in the age of LLMs

Show HN: Stacky – certain block game clone

AIII: A public benchmark for AI narrative and political independence

SectorC: A C Compiler in 512 bytes

The API Is a Dead End; Machines Need a Labor Economy

Digital Iris [video]

New wave of GLP-1 drugs is coming–and they're stronger than Wegovy and Zepbound

Convert tempo (BPM) to millisecond durations for musical note subdivisions

Show HN: Tasty A.F.

The Contagious Taste of Cancer

U.S. Jobs Disappear at Fastest January Pace Since Great Recession

Bithumb mistakenly hands out $195M in Bitcoin to users in 'Random Box' giveaway