super interesting pseudo IPC channel and at least mildly concerning from a security perspective. saw it on your site first and am shocked there is not a single other comment yet here
was hoping to find at least one “cmon this is easy to avoid with X thing in the kernel/OS” info nugget dropped
simonw•2mo ago
I'm not sure how much of a security concern this one is, at least for the kinds of things I care about with respect to containers.
I want my containers to be able to run work without other containers spying on them (already hard thanks to timing attacks).
This IPC channel only works if both containers are collaborating together. I don't think you can use it to spy on my container if my container isn't actively participating.
viega•2mo ago
Agreed that this is not a critical problem, and the cooperative side channel can be useful in otherwise uncooperative environments.
The article does mention wanting to coordinate across multiple identical processes running on the same node in a wide variety of environments as the motivator.
So maybe it should be a feature, not a bug :)
restlake•2mo ago
two well-balanced takes making me think I should embrace the fun parts of this design and worry less about the risks! it’s a pretty cool idea and impressive it works
pizzafeelsright•2mo ago
That is a fun read. Shared systems indeed share outside their designer's intent.
simonw•2mo ago
restlake•2mo ago
was hoping to find at least one “cmon this is easy to avoid with X thing in the kernel/OS” info nugget dropped
simonw•2mo ago
I want my containers to be able to run work without other containers spying on them (already hard thanks to timing attacks).
This IPC channel only works if both containers are collaborating together. I don't think you can use it to spy on my container if my container isn't actively participating.
viega•2mo ago
The article does mention wanting to coordinate across multiple identical processes running on the same node in a wide variety of environments as the motivator.
So maybe it should be a feature, not a bug :)
restlake•2mo ago