The timing and manner of the break make a lot more intuitive sense when you consider that the engine is essentially a massive gyroscope. As the plane starts to rotate, the spinning engine resists changes to the direction of its spin axis, putting load on the cowling. When the cowling and mount fail, that angular momentum helps fling the engine toward the fuselage.
It seems like both are true, but doesn't necessarily prove WHY the mount failed.
The referenced AA Flight 191 is shockingly similar. It makes me wonder if aviation really is back sliding into a dangerous place.
The murder suicides in the last few decades seem more concerning.
Dropping an engine entirely is a similar situation to a failure - with the benefit that you now have a substantially lighter if imbalanced aircraft.
Should this plane have been able to fly by design even with an engine fallen off?
https://www.reddit.com/r/aviation/comments/1p276xx/ntsb_issu...
That in turn reminds me of the DHL flight out of Baghdad in 2003 that was hit by a missile [0]. Absolutely amazing that they managed to keep it together and land with damage like that.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2003_Baghdad_DHL_attempted_sho...
It doesn't seem aircraft are designed to survive these types of catastrophic failures.
NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFEN'BOAFID
:J11...:i= of ArutiOn SMel@LA5 301
A.,r Tral1C.IYU';UQlt-Ort!!
NTS,B ri@ss @at.Joo JurtJer
DCA26 22\C2<But beyond figuring out why the engine mount failed, I am very interested in what caused the actual crash. "Just" losing thrust in a single engine is usually not enough to cause a crash, the remaining engine(s) have enough margin to get the plane airborne. Of course this was a major structural failure and might have caused additional damage.
EDIT: It seems there was damage to the engine in the tail, even though this was not specified in the preliminary report, likely because it has not been sufficiently confirmed yet.
Seems like the risk/reward just isn't really there for the few of them still in service, and if anything happened it would be a PR nightmare on top of a tragedy.
Definitely an end of an era!
And air freight just gets a lot less public attention, I think they are going to keep flying them if they don't get grounded.
From the photos, it’s clear it went up over the wing and impacted the fuselage with a (at least) minor explosion, which would have thrown foreign objects into the third engine in the tail for sure.
Losing 2/3 of the engines isn’t survivable on takeoff for this class of plane, at the weights they were at.
frenchman_in_ny•1h ago
[0] https://avherald.com/h?article=52f5748f&opt=0