Ask HN: Can a startup idea succeed solely based on execution?

1•slashtmpslashme•1h ago

Let's say I have an idea which someone has already built.

But I execute it much better in some way. (Eg: cost efficiency / user experience / whatever). So there might be something else which is approximately same as my application, can I win based on refinement or efficiency of execution?

Or is it more likely the competitor will figure out the way to realize the same efficiency gains?

What are some examples of this succeeding and failing?

Any personal anecdotes will be appreciated too.

Comments

james_marks•1h ago

“Execute it much better in some way” is the definition of a startup.

And typically the ones that succeed execute one thing much better than their peers: distribution.

WheelsAtLarge•12m ago

I don't gave proof but I would say that most successful startups are copies of other startups. A unique idea is so much harder to execute in both money and effort so coping an ongoing business and making it better is the way to go.

A successful business is mainly about managing resources and people. The idea is secondary.

I would bet on a successful team over an idea any time.

Show HN: I made a SaaS to crush technical interviews

Lucid aims for ‘the heart of the market’ with three new EVs priced at $50,000

Radiance Meshes for Volumetric Reconstruction

Who Owns Alignment?

Libre Computer: Platforms for Software-Defined Hardware

AI chatbots used inaccurate information to change people's political opinions

Beyond the Front Page of the Internet

Debatable Lands

Let's Not Bring Back the Gatekeepers

The Status Game (With Will Storr)

Google Cloud: Disclosure of Information to the European Commission

Show HN: Marvin, your own AI-powered game studio

Wolfenstein 3D's map renderer [video]

The Third Day of Agents How Agents Work – Tools, Memory, and Plans

Target-text: An easy way to style text fragments

Show HN: A SOTA chart-extraction system combining traditional CV and LVMs

Kimina-Prover: Applying Test-Time RL Search on Large Formal Reasoning Models

We Got Claude to Fine-Tune an Open Source LLM

Why Does the Salish Sea Glow in the Dark?

Microsoft denies report of lowering targets for AI software sales growth

A smarter way for large language models to think about hard problems

Dependency Groups to the Rescue

Gaussian Splat Reconstruction from Anything via OpenAI Chat Completions

Relativistic Covariance and Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics

Ask HN: Would you use an AI that translates your body's signals? (3-min survey)

Ask HN: Dealing with Almost a Decade of Harassment

The Animate and The Inanimate, a cosmological tome written by a child prodigy [pdf]

Indian scientists spot Milky Way-like galaxy from 12B years ago

In 1995, a Netscape employee wrote a hack in 10 days that now runs the Internet

Show HN: TurboSanta – Stateless secret Santa generator