Ask HN: Is There a Shell Revival?

1•sshadmand•4h ago

I’ve used shell scripts before, but mostly in a pretty limited way with other people’s open source scripts to do something specific, or the occasional one off to clean up a drive.

Ironically, now that agents are genuinely good at coding, I find myself “writing” more shell scripts.

They’re robust, portable, and work in almost any environment I care about. Agents are very comfortable producing them, they execute fast, and they’re great for automation.

What I’ve ended up with is a growing set of automations built around simple, interactive shell script menus that handle things I do all the time. When I want to improve one, add branching logic, or tweak behavior, I just ask AI to mod the script and move on. I kind of love it.

It feels like a shell script revival, at least for me.

Curious if others are experiencing the same shift or if I fell into some weird bubble/anti-pattern.

Comments

fragmede•4h ago

I mean, they're useful to you, presumably, so who cares if it is a weird bubble. I'll tell you about the weird bubble I've tried. So you start with bash, then python, ask it to do it in rust for speed, and then for shiggles, have it do it in assembly! The problem with assembly is that it's not portable, and I'm currently on a MacBook which is arm, and I still need to be on x86, so maybe I'll try for c (and not c++) next.

sshadmand•4h ago

There is a reshaping of what we think is “right”. Like, I am less and less interested in SDKs since I can just ask for a lightweight, custom, integration into anything I want based on API docs. I mean, I still use a lot of SDKs…buuuut it feels like I’m forcing the AI to use them for my monkey brain’s sake. Is predefined mashup of structured services even necessary anymore?

rzzzwilson•3h ago

I too used shell a lot back in the day. I once wrote a 5000+ line system to handle database administration and a bespoke email system with retries to handle flaky communications. But that was a long time ago and requirements that forced the use of shell. These days I still write small shell scripts but for larger scripts I use python. I find that shell is even better when interfacing with a Linux system than python, but python is better at higher-level logic and control.

sshadmand•1h ago

Interesting. I use a lot of python and nodejs for my apps, maybe this shell angle is a weird quirk I developed for no particular reason. I keep a seperate repo called “manager” and use it to manage my other parts of the stack like, “run tests for each repo, bump version, commit to git” with a single CLI command. I have no idea why that started. My guess is an agent created a shell script and I just went with it and built up around it. Good to hear other perspectives. Thanks!

bgbntty2•3h ago

I'd make sure the scripts work with edge cases like unexpected characters in file names (new lines and so on), especially if you don't control the names yourself. Maybe prompt the AI to do some tests if that's possible?

And keep backups. Not because you're using AI, necessarily. And not because you're using shell scripts. But just in case.

The "bubble" part doesn't concern you. If it works for you, it works for you. Whether or not it's a "bubble" is more of an economic issue at a larger scale.

Ask HN: New user here – unable to submit a link. Do I just need to wait?

Show HN: I replaced a 5-person marketing team with a swarm of autonomous agents

Show HN: I built an AI that scans 10k Reddit comments to find 'Blue Ocean' ideas

Want to know what LLMs think about your brand?

Positive Imagining Changes the Brain in Seconds

I grew up in Russia. Here's why we're afraid of freedom

Pydantic-DeepAgents – A Python Framework for Building Autonomous AI Agents

TPU Mania

Show HN: Seedance2:AI Video Generator with smooth motion and rich details

Show HN: Hazbin Hotel OC Maker – Create Original Characters with AI

Show HN: I built this because finding a job f**king sucks

'A nightmare' – The battle over Warner Bros is turning Hollywood upside down

Show HN: Tic Tac Flip – A new strategic game based on Tic Tac Toe

Show HN: CF Local Helpers – Dashboard for Cloudflare Workers Local Dev

"You should never build a CMS"

Will blockbuster obesity drugs revolutionize addiction treatment?

Interlock – a circuit breaker and certification system for AI infrastructure

ICE Holding Chinese Man Who Documented Uyghur Camps

Counter Social – a next-generation anti abuse and user privacy social network

Game Theory and Your Lawn

'It was like a dream': How Australia's rarest bird of prey was found

Show HN: Rolldphobia – Bundle size analyzer with tree-shaking using Rolldown

Hyrumrand – Golang random number generator based on random map iteration order

Ask HN: How does traceroute on airplane wifis work?

Neutrino Alchemy: Sun's Ghost Particles Caught Transforming Atoms

Pingfs: Stores your data in ICMP ping packets

Design Is Search

Altman: Super intelligence in 10 years, more extraordinary things in 2026

What happens when the coding becomes the least interesting part of the work

Ask HN: A browser that syncs history reliably across devices?