Who has enjoyed using PR code reviewers? What worked and what didn’t?

3•yashwantphogat•1mo ago

I’m curious about people’s experiences with pull request code reviewers, both human and automated.

For those who have used PR review tools or bots:

What did you actually find helpful?

What ended up being annoying or counterproductive?

At what point did you stop paying attention to the feedback?

I’m particularly interested in how people balance signal vs noise in reviews, and whether summaries, inline comments, or opt-in depth work better in practice.

Asking to understand real usage patterns and pain points, not to promote anything. Happy to just listen.

Comments

casmn•1mo ago

I am using dependabot, grouped dependencies once a week.

We started by having it doing PR for every single dependencies update every day, but that was a little too much noise

But i depends on how big your team is

yashwantphogat•1mo ago

Yes, team size really changes the dynamics. We ran into similar issues when reviews started taking over entire days. I’m building and testing a quieter review approach that only goes deeper when asked, and I’m trying to understand where that tradeoff works best. would you like to try it out? your feedback will help me to improve it further.

ryanchants•1mo ago

We're using CodeRabbit at work, and it has been pretty positive overall. Especially once we turned off the poems and sequence diagram noise. Useful enough that I'm looking at paying for it for side projects when I am the sole developer.

yashwantphogat•1mo ago

That makes sense. A lot of these tools seem to become useful once the extra noise is turned down. I’m actually building and testing a quieter review approach myself and trying to understand what really helps in day-to-day use. would you like to give it a try?

Show HN: Paper Arena – A social trading feed where only AI agents can post

TOSTracker – The AI Training Asymmetry

The Devil Inside GitHub

Show HN: Distill – Migrate LLM agents from expensive to cheap models

Show HN: Sigma Runtime – Maintaining 100% Fact Integrity over 120 LLM Cycles

Make a local open-source AI chatbot with access to Fedora documentation

Introduce the Vouch/Denouncement Contribution Model by Mitchellh

Software Factories and the Agentic Moment

The Neuroscience Behind Nutrition for Developers and Founders

Bang bang he murdered math {the musical } (2024)

A Night Without the Nerds – Claude Opus 4.6, Field-Tested

Could ionospheric disturbances influence earthquakes?

SpaceX's next astronaut launch for NASA is officially on for Feb. 11 as FAA clea

Show HN: One-click AI employee with its own cloud desktop

Show HN: Poddley – Search podcasts by who's speaking

Same Surface, Different Weight

The Rise of Spec Driven Development

The first good Raspberry Pi Laptop

Seas to Rise Around the World – But Not in Greenland

Will Future Generations Think We're Gross?

State Department will delete Xitter posts from before Trump returned to office

Show HN: Verifiable server roundtrip demo for a decision interruption system

Impl Rust – Avro IDL Tool in Rust via Antlr

Stories from 25 Years of Software Development

minikeyvalue

Neomacs: GPU-accelerated Emacs with inline video, WebKit, and terminal via wgpu

Show HN: Moli P2P – An ephemeral, serverless image gallery (Rust and WebRTC)

How I grow my X presence?

What's the cost of the most expensive Super Bowl ad slot?

What if you just did a startup instead?