Ask HN: How does an indy website integrate with cookie vendors to make money?
4•ricksunny•1mo ago
There have been many posts on HN about the annoying cookie consent dialogs. I've never understood how indy websites actually themselves do earnout from placing those cookies on users' devices. Like, there are all of those vendors listed, somehow those vendors are making money from the act, how does some of that revenue cycle back to the indy website posing the cookie consent dialog?
Comments
dtagames•1mo ago
That isn't what cookies are for. A proper explanation is too long to post here but there are two basic kinds. The first kind identifies you as a repeat visitor to the same site. This is used to log you back in without entering your password and other such uses. These are called first party cookies.
The second type is called third party cookies and these are placed by advertisements to track you across multiple sites (though there are other ways to do that which don't require a cookie). Presumably, the site owner could recieve some share of ads placed on their site, but in practice these third party cookies are placed by login tools (Google login) and other "drop-in" content which the site owner finds valuable but might not be advertising.
In this case, neither the money from the data collected about the user, which can be sold, nor the money from the ads which are delivered on later sites that were chosen because of the user's collected are shared with the owner of the site who passes out the cookie.
dtagames•1mo ago
The second type is called third party cookies and these are placed by advertisements to track you across multiple sites (though there are other ways to do that which don't require a cookie). Presumably, the site owner could recieve some share of ads placed on their site, but in practice these third party cookies are placed by login tools (Google login) and other "drop-in" content which the site owner finds valuable but might not be advertising.
In this case, neither the money from the data collected about the user, which can be sold, nor the money from the ads which are delivered on later sites that were chosen because of the user's collected are shared with the owner of the site who passes out the cookie.