Ask HN: Why did ICE deport my coworker?

18•RyanShook•4w ago

My coworker in Houston is from El Salvador and has been in the US legally under temporary protected status for roughly 20 years. He had all his paperwork in order and had renewed his temporary protected status at the proper times. He also has children born in the US.

Three weeks ago he was stopped at random by ICE while driving in his truck. He was immediately detained outside Houston then taken to detention at the border a few days later. He hired an immigration lawyer while in detention two weeks ago was deported today before anything regarding his case could be heard.

Comments

toomuchtodo•4w ago

If you're not a US citizen, you're fair game, this administration and the federal agencies in question do not respect temporary protected status.

(and even in the case of being a citizen, denaturalization is being threatened, even though illegal)

starkparker•4w ago

> If you're not a US citizen, you're fair game

US citizens detained or released from ICE detention in the last week:

Twin Cities area (Robbinsdale), Thursday morning: https://www.startribune.com/us-citizen-arrested-ice-day-afte...

Twin Cities area (Richfield), Thursday afternoon: https://bringmethenews.com/minnesota-news/pattern-emerging-o...

Minneapolis, Thursday morning: https://sahanjournal.com/education/border-patrol-detains-min...

Twin Cities area (Brooklyn Park), Monday: https://www.cbsnews.com/minnesota/news/us-citizen-ice-encoun...

Baltimore: https://www.cbsnews.com/baltimore/news/maryland-ice-detentio...

Salisbury, NC: https://www.qcnews.com/news/u-s/north-carolina/rowan-county/...

On a Carnival cruise ship docked in Miami: https://www.azfamily.com/2026/01/07/phoenix-veteran-says-ice...

----

ProPublica report on 170 citizen detentions as of October: https://www.propublica.org/article/immigration-dhs-american-...

WaPo report on citizen detentions ("DHS ... has not provided any figures") in December: https://www.washingtonpost.com/immigration/2025/12/07/trump-...

burnt-resistor•4w ago

Even US citizens are fair game if they're not rich/popular enough. Renee Nicole Good's family will discover that no Bivens nor 1983 civil claims will be possible because federal agents essentially have absolute immunity. Michigan state is acting in a performative manner to assuage emotions when nothing will happen as they lack jurisdiction. That is a problem only Congress can solve, but won't because they're beholden to the same rich assholes as Clarence Thomas takes vacations and other bribes from.

shlip•4w ago

Have you been hibernating since january 2025 ? You're living in a dictatorship now, that's why.

markus_zhang•4w ago

I hope his family is OK. Suddenly losing a father and a financial source is panicking.

JohnFen•4w ago

It's because the feds are working hard to replace the rule of law with tyranny.

lawn•4w ago

You need to read up on fascism.

giardini•3w ago

Your question is essentially "X was in the USA legally, so why was X deported for being in the USA illegally?"

Answer1: Your assumption is incorrect: X was in the USA illegally.

Answer2: You're astroturfing, you have no "friend" and this is a fake post.

Plenty of other answers.

My point is, other than politicking, why post this on HN? HN is not an appropriate forum for such questions.

Show HN: Remotion directory on the web (videos and prompts)

Portable C Compiler

Show HN: Kokki – A "Dual-Core" System Prompt to Reduce LLM Hallucinations

Software Engineering Transformation 2026

Microsoft purges Win11 printer drivers, devices on borrowed time

Lunch with the FT: Tarek Mansour

Old Mexico and her lost provinces (1883)

'AI' is a dick move, redux

The source code was the moat. But not anymore

Does anyone else feel like their inbox has become their job?

An AI model that can read and diagnose a brain MRI in seconds

Dev with 5 of experience switched to Rails, what should I be careful about?

AlphaFace: High Fidelity and Real-Time Face Swapper Robust to Facial Pose

Scientists discover “levitating” time crystals that you can hold in your hand

Rammstein – Deutschland (C64 Cover, Real SID, 8-bit – 2019) [video]

Tell HN: Yet Another Round of Zendesk Spam

Postgres Message Queue (PGMQ)

Show HN: Django-rclone: Database and media backups for Django, powered by rclone

NY lawmakers proposed statewide data center moratorium

OpenClaw AI chatbots are running amok – these scientists are listening in

Show HN: AI agent forgets user preferences every session. This fixes it

Introduce the Vouch/Denouncement Contribution Model

Show HN: SSHcode – Always-On Claude Code/OpenCode over Tailscale and Hetzner

Microsoft appointed a quality czar. He has no direct reports and no budget

Multi-agent coordination on Claude Code: 8 production pain points and patterns

Washington Post CEO Will Lewis Steps Down After Stormy Tenure

DevXT – Building the Future with AI That Acts

A Minimal OpenClaw Built with the OpenCode SDK

The silent death of Good Code

The Internal Negotiation You Have When Your Heart Rate Gets Uncomfortable