frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

NanoClaw solves one of OpenClaw's biggest security issues

https://venturebeat.com/orchestration/nanoclaw-solves-one-of-openclaws-biggest-security-issues-and-its-already
30•marsh_mellow•1h ago

Comments

senko•1h ago
File system access is not one of OpenClaw's biggest security issues. If that were so, running it in a VM or another computer (I hear Mac Minis are popular!) would solve it.

If you need it to do anything useful[0], you have to connect it to your data and give it action capabilities. All the dragons are there.

If you play it careful and don't expose your data, comm channels, etc., then it's much like the other AI assistants out there.[1]

---

[0] for your definition of useful

[1] I do appreciate the self-modification and heartbeat aspects, and don't want to downplay how technically impressive it is. The comment is purely from POV of an end-user product.

stevepike•1h ago
Reminds me of https://xkcd.com/1200/
samkim•25m ago
Agreed, sandboxing is only part of agent security. Authorization (what data the agent can access and what tools it can execute) is also a big part of it.

I've found primer on agent sandboxes [0] is a great reference on sandboxing options and the trade-offs

For agents there's a tension between level of restriction and utility. I think a large part of OpenClaw's popularity is that the lack of restriction by default has helped people see the potential utility of agents. But any agent that isn't just for trying things out requires consideration of what it should and should not be able to do and from there the decision around the best combination of sandboxing and authorization.

At work, we've found it helpful to distinguish coding agents vs product agents. Coding agents have the ability to add new execution paths by pulling in external code or writing their own code to run. Product agents have a strictly defined set of tools and the runtime prevents them from executing anything beyond that definition. This distinction helps us reason about what sandboxing is required.

For data permissions it's trickier. MCP uses OAuth for authentication but each server can have different expectations for access to the external service. Some servers let you use a service account where you can narrow the scope of access but others assume a token minted from an admin account which means the MCP server might have access to things beyond what the agent using the server should.

So for that, we have an MCP proxy that lets us define custom permissions for every tool and resource, and at runtime makes permission checks to ensure the agent only gets access to the subset of things we define ahead of time. (We're using SpiceDB to implement the authorization logic and checks) This works well for product agents because they can't add new execution paths. For coding agents, we've tinkered with plugins/skills to try to do the same but ultimately they can build their way around authorization layers that aren't part of the runtime system so it's something we're still trying to figure out.

---

[0] https://www.luiscardoso.dev/blog/sandboxes-for-ai

LelouBil•18m ago
Sandboxing is great, and stricter Authorization policies are great too, but with these kinds of software, my biggest fear (and that's why I am not trying them out now) is prompt injection.

It just seems unsolvable if you want the agent to do anything remotely useful

Someone•4m ago
[delayed]
mjr00•1h ago
> Concrete Media: Public Relations for B2B tech companies

This is a marketing piece for Concrete Media.

Whenever you see an article like this, be sure to ask yourself how the author came up with the idea for the article, and how the author got in contact with any people interviewed in the article.

hypfer•1h ago
Exactly this.

The whole wording also doesn't make sense.

OpenClaw was released in November of 2025, yet the article sounds like NanoClaw _disrupts_ some old staple of the industry.

You can't use that wording 4 months into the whole "industry". Even less so, when your competitor was "launched" 2 weeks ago. Even less so when it's written by claude

This nothingburger is so much nothing, it might as well be an antiburger.

senko•1h ago
Should anyone think the comment is dismissive, here's this directly in the text:

> a respected public relations firm that often works with tech businesses covered by VentureBeat

bryan0•1h ago
Nanoclaw is excellent. Natively uses Apple containers and easy to use with oauth Claude code subscription. Only annoying thing was it defaults to WhatsApp, but it’s easy to fork and mod as you want. The best thing is asking it to mod itself!
benocodes•1h ago
if you're looking for the repo: https://github.com/qwibitai/nanoclaw

not 500 lines but looks more reasonable then openclaw

Kevcmk•1h ago
This “article” completely written with “AI”
ChrisArchitect•1h ago
Previous discussion on the Show HN: from the dev:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46850205

publicinterest•45m ago
To their credit they put a single sentence of warning into the article they commissioned, but to highlight:

- I don't care deeply about this code.

- (This isn’t) production code but a reference or starting point they can use to build functional custom software for themselves.

- I spent a weekend giving instructions to coding agents to build this.

9 days ago

moomoo11•1h ago
This is why I really think for AI tools it’s probably good to just start fresh.

Like our emails, files, other accounts and stuff. That’s “ours” and personal.

Even for business, that should be off limits.

What we do give to AI should be brand new blank slates. Like say I roll out an AI solution in March 2026. That is the seed from which everything we do using AI will work.

To get there we could move data we want to the new environment. But no access to any existing stuff. We start fresh.

If it needs to take any actions on behalf of our existing accounts it needs to go through some secure pipeline where it only tells us intent, without access.

cobbal•25m ago
This is cutting off the "Access to private data" leg of the lethal trifecta. One of the few ways to actually make an agent secure.
netdur•38m ago
I have tried to solve the agent running wild, and I found two solutions, the first is to mount the workspace folder using WASM to scope any potential damage, the second is running rquickjs with all APIs and module imports disabled, requiring the agent to call a host function that checks permissions before accessing any files

--- [0] https://github.com/netdur/hugind

tmaly•27m ago
Aside from the security differences, what can OpenClaw do that NanoClaw cannot?
sathish316•19m ago
How is NanoClaw immune to the Lethal trifecta attack based on prompt injection that OpenClaw is also prone to?

https://simonwillison.net/2025/Jun/16/the-lethal-trifecta/

Lethal trifecta:

1. Access to your private data

2. Exposure to untrusted content

3. The ability to externally communicate

Any combination of 1-3 or more skills can result in a prompt injection attack if it satisfies the above criteria - Gmail or sales personal data, Reddit or X posts or comments in white text, Gmail or Reddit or X to send confidential information to the attacker.

LelouBil•16m ago
Prompt injection just seems unsolvable.

Are there works toward preventing it 100% of the time ? (I would assume the LLMs architectures would have to change)

kvdveer•13m ago
It is not immune, but it limits #1 and #2.

The "lethal trifecta" is a limited view on security, as it's mostly concerned with leaking data. This solution focuses on a different aspect: the ability of rogue actions (instead of rogue communications per #3).

Spotify-fs Store any file inside Spotify tracks

https://github.com/Xelckis/spotify-fs
1•delduca•2m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Gottp – A Postman/Insomnia-Like TUI API Client Built in Go

https://github.com/sadopc/gottp
1•sadopc•3m ago•0 comments

Migrating from Slurm to Kubernetes

https://blog.skypilot.co/slurm-to-k8s-migration/
2•rombr•4m ago•0 comments

Evolving Git for the next decade (FOSDEM 2026)

https://lwn.net/SubscriberLink/1057561/040a5b0283517773/
1•chmaynard•5m ago•0 comments

Lightweight daemon to remap the Copilot keyboard key in Linux using libevdev

https://github.com/m-bartlett/remap-copilot
1•evah•5m ago•0 comments

We built a museum exhibit about a 1990s game hint line, with a physical binder

https://yarnspinner.dev/blog/hint-line-93/
1•PaulHoule•6m ago•0 comments

EU commission eyes turning 5G antennas into drone detectors

https://www.euractiv.com/news/commission-eyes-turning-5g-antennas-into-drone-detectors/
1•giuliomagnifico•8m ago•0 comments

Maxis Software Toys

https://arbesman.substack.com/p/maxis-software-toys
1•arbesman•8m ago•0 comments

SEO Score for Your Docs

https://docsalot.dev/tools/docs-seo
1•fazkan•8m ago•0 comments

Interactive guide to Bitcoin's proof of work

https://bennet.org/learn/proof-of-work-what-bitcoin-mining-really-does/
1•tombennet•9m ago•1 comments

Show HN: TagLib-WASM – Read/write audio metadata with all JavaScript runtimes

1•CharlesW•9m ago•0 comments

Talk to Proteins

https://www.codyliu.com/chatmol
1•codyyyyliu•10m ago•0 comments

Opus 4.6, Codex 5.3, and the post-benchmark era

https://www.interconnects.ai/p/opus-46-vs-codex-53
1•gmays•11m ago•0 comments

Andreessen Horowitz's Rising Influence over Trump-Era AI Policy

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2026-02-10/trump-s-ai-policy-shaped-by-vc-tech-giant-andr...
1•atlasunshrugged•11m ago•0 comments

Challenger Center announces Space Coding Challenges with Hack Club

https://challenger.org/news-insights/new-partnership-with-hack-club-launches-space-coding-challen...
1•Charmunk•11m ago•0 comments

The hunt for zero-CVE container images

https://thenewstack.io/chainguard-and-the-hunt-for-truly-zero-cve-container-images/
2•CrankyBear•12m ago•0 comments

Old Reddit Broken

https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/1r1fde4/is_old_reddit_super_super_broken_right_now_for/
2•amai•13m ago•0 comments

Turning YouTube into Cloud Storage [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l03Os5uwWmk
1•f311a•13m ago•0 comments

Gallup will no longer measure presidential approval after 88 years

https://thehill.com/homenews/media/5733236-gallup-stops-presidential-approval-ratings-polls/
15•hypeatei•14m ago•2 comments

Show HN: Simulate Anybody's Gmail Inbox

https://unread.ooo/
1•theroo•14m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Steam and Autism, a book by Opus 4.6

https://github.com/cloudstreet-dev/STEAM-and-Autism
1•DavidCanHelp•15m ago•1 comments

Are we losing our sense of "Quality" in the age of AI agents

https://mcradcliffe.substack.com/p/zen-and-the-art-of-hand-written-code
1•bigpapikite•16m ago•0 comments

Metasurfaces create super-sized neutral atom arrays for quantum computing

https://physicsworld.com/a/metasurfaces-create-super-sized-neutral-atom-arrays-for-quantum-comput...
2•rbanffy•16m ago•0 comments

Google sent personal and financial information of student journalist to ICE

https://techcrunch.com/2026/02/10/google-sent-personal-and-financial-information-of-student-journ...
2•MaysonL•16m ago•0 comments

Building High-Performance Electron Apps

https://www.johnnyle.io/read/electron-performance
2•aCodeCrafter•18m ago•0 comments

What Is a Diminished Value Claim? The Secret to Recovering Your Car's Lost Value

https://suretyinsights.com/blog/what-is-a-diminished-value-claim-and-when-should-you-file-one
2•engelo_b•18m ago•0 comments

Can my SPARC server host a website?

https://rup12.net/posts/can-my-sparc-server-host-my-website/
4•abnercoimbre•19m ago•1 comments

The Incoming Slopocalypse and the Death(?) Of Open Source

https://www.llamaindex.ai/blog/on-the-incoming-slopocalypse-and-the-death-of-open-source
1•makaimc•21m ago•0 comments

A practical guide to use AI Coding agents

https://www.devtoolsacademy.com/blog/ai-coding-agents-practical-guide/
2•alokDT•22m ago•0 comments

Subreply – a text-only social network

https://subreply.com/trending
3•lucianmarin•22m ago•1 comments