frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

State Attorneys General Want to Tie Online Access to ID

https://reclaimthenet.org/40-attorneys-general-back-ids-online-safety-act
77•computerliker•1h ago

Comments

dwedge•1h ago
It's tiring how legislation like this is becoming predictable and feels inevitable. This article even mentions the verification needing to be embedded in the operating system itself, spelling the death of open computing
sixtyj•1h ago
Some people have been saying for so long that you should need a license to use the internet, and now that we have it, it's a little different than we intended :(
mothballed•1h ago
I'd argue it's more like KYC for the internet. Something HN users have brutally and ruthlessly defended for banking every time I argue it's a 4A violation (in fact, it's one of the most fiercely defended things anytime I bring it up).

Give in 20+ years and you'll be called a kook for thinking otherwise.

tired-turtle•41m ago
Can you explain the connection between KYC in banking and the Fourth Amendment? How does KYC constitute a government search/seizure?
mothballed•35m ago
The government requires the bank to search your identity documents to open an account, even when there is no individualized suspicion you've broken the law as to why your papers need to be searched, as part of the KYC regulations passed post 9/11. Technically it's not in the statute that they actually search your documents, but rather enforced through a byzantine series of federal regulatory frameworks that basically require them to do something that approximates "industry standard" KYC compliance which ends up being, verifying the customer through inspecting their identity and perhaps other documents. This is why i.e. when I was homeless even my passport couldn't open an account anywhere -- they wanted my passport plus some document showing an address to satisfy KYC requirements.

Maybe I will have more energy for it tomorrow, I've been through this probably a couple dozen times on HN and I don't have the energy to go through the whole rigmarole today because usually it results in 2-3 days of someone fiercely disagreeing down some long chain and in the end I provide all the evidence and by that point no one is paying attention and it just goes into this pyrrhic victory where I get drained dry just for no one to give a shit. I should probably consolidate it into a blog post or something.

sneak•7m ago
I’d happily host that blog. Contact info is in my profile.
DennisP•4m ago
Fwiw I lean to your side and would be interesting in reading what you have to say about it.
rockskon•27m ago
We don't have it yet and there is still time to head this off. Not much time - but still time! Talk to your federal lawmakers and state AG's office!
latency-guy2•1h ago
Bad actors like --

William Tong, Anne E. Lopez, Dave Yost, Jonathan Skrmetti, Gwen Tauiliili-Langkilde, Kris Mayes, Tim Griffin, Rob Bonta, Phil Weiser, Kathleen Jennings, Brian Schwalb, Christopher M. Carr, Kwame Raoul, Todd Rokita, Kris Kobach, Russell Coleman, Liz Murrill, Aaron M. Frey, Anthony G. Brown, Andrea Joy Campbell, Dana Nessel, Keith Ellison, Lynn Fitch, Catherine L. Hanaway, Aaron D. Ford, John M. Formella, Jennifer Davenport, Raúl Torrez, Letitia James, Drew H. Wrigley, Gentner Drummond, Dan Rayfield, Dave Sunday, Peter F. Neronha, Alan Wilson, Marty Jackley, Gordon C. Rhea, Derek Brown, Charity Clark, and Keith Kautz

--

Always operate under the assumption that the people serve the state, not the other way around. There are some names in that list that are outwardly infamous of this behavior, and none are surprising considering what type of person looks to be an AG. Maybe fighting fire with fire is appropriate - no such thing as a private life for any of these people, all their communications are open to the public 100% of the time and there are precisely 0 instances where it is not the case. It's only fair considering that is what their goal is for everyone not of the state.

plagiarist•1h ago
Poettering will help get us remote attestation on Linux so we won't have to switch to Windows when it dies.
brandensilva•57m ago
It isn't a coincidence we have two Palantir articles on the front page and this. It's in the cards and American's seem to be ignoring it and are more than happy to accept the dystopian future where this leads.

It's incredibly sad as an optimistic person trying to find any silver lining here.

halJordan•46m ago
It's already the law in California. I don't remember any outrage here when it was passed there.
rockskon•28m ago
No it isn't. There is no law in California that mandates showing an ID to see ambiguously-defined adult content.
2OEH8eoCRo0•1h ago
The internet as we know it will be the first casualty of a great power hot war. We are living on borrowed time.
jamboca•1h ago
At a certain point the world just becomes less appealing to live in. Day by day death becomes more appealing; what do you have to lose when life just means living in a pigpen?
moneycantbuy•1h ago
resist
moneycantbuy•1h ago
we really need better leadership
shevy-java•1h ago
The strange thing is that all leaders end up doing the same. I wonder if direct democracy would be possible. Right now we are like in a Trueman show movie.
moneycantbuy•1h ago
somehow need to remove money from politics.

also need a more informed citizenry able to see through propaganda.

stopbulying•1h ago
What is a good resource for reviewing the advantages and disadvantages of mandatory Real ID for Internet access?

Aren't there sound reasons to support anonymous whistleblowing?

Would there be critical feedback without pseudo-anonymity on the internet?

But you folks just have to dom all the haters.

What is their favorite thing: stuffed animal brand, candy, musical artist?

But then wouldn't undercover ops be obvious?

Is this similar to the "ban all crypto" movements that periodically forget everything we've learned about infosec and protecting folks?

Do protectees' deserve privacy for their safety?

In the 1990s, they told us kids not to use our real names or addresses on the internet.

shevy-java•1h ago
They want to sniff after everyone. The "omg terrorists" or "omg children" is the lie.
rootsudo•1h ago
RIP Internet. I don't agree with any of this, but I don't see the majority of people protesting this. If anything, promotion it because: Think of the children.

"Many social media platforms deliberately target minors, fueling a nationwide youth mental health crisis."

". These platforms are intentionally designed to be addictive, particularly for underaged users, and generate substantial profits by monetizing minors’ personal data through targeted advertising. These companies fail to adequately disclose the addictive nature of their products or the well-documented harms associated with excessive social media use. Increasing evidence demonstrates that these companies are aware of the adverse mental health consequences imposed on underage users, yet they have chosen to persist in these practices. Accordingly, many of our Offices have initiated investigations and filed lawsuits against Meta and TikTok for their role in harming minors. "

Yet, the comapnies aren't being regulated, nor the algorithims, the marketing or even the existence. It's the users that are the problem therefore everyone has to submit their Identity to use the Internet if this passes.

gjsman-1000•1h ago
I blame HN and Silicon Valley in general for consistently treating keeping children online safe as a parental responsibility only, rather than a government-parent team effort like every other regulation.

This loophole, “think of the children,” would not exist if SV had gotten over itself and not called very solution unworkable while insisting that any solution parents receive, no matter how sloppy or confusing, is workable.

pavel_lishin•1h ago
Aren't most of these problems directly caused by the government claiming to do these things to protect children?
dwedge•1h ago
Yeah exactly, had it not been for Facebook and the rest of social media not taking children online seriously, The Simpsons wouldn't have had to mock the cultural meme of blaming everything on saving children back in 1996 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RybNI0KB1bg
whearyou•1h ago
Between this and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47026134 on the front page it feels, yet again, like we’re speed running to living in a Peter Watts novel
rockskon•1h ago
If this really bothers you, talk to your state AG's office and your federal lawmaker

The worst that can happen is you don't change things.

The best? Maybe you'll find a receptive ear. Your lawmaker stops co-sponsoring KOSA. Your state AG stops pushing for it.

rolph•56m ago
i think the worst that can happen is you could be put on a list of dissention.
rockskon•44m ago
Being active about KOSA won't get you put on a "list of dissenters". This is an issue being pushed by the States and your federal lawmakers, not the executive branch.
rockskon•22m ago
A list of people who dissent to KOSA is not a bad list to be on as a constituent.

You need to make it easier for your lawmakers to be on that list too. Show them there's people who won't rake them over the coals for bowing out.

hammock•19m ago
Isn’t that the point? Our lawmakers keep track of how many constituents approve or disapprove of pending legislation so they can act accordingly
rolph•6m ago
[delayed]
Trasmatta•12m ago
Don't comply in advance
mothballed•55m ago
Just as a note, federal officials are retaliating against those providing respectful comment on policy.[]

So the worst that can happen could be worse than nothing.

[] https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/department-of-homeland-s...

rockskon•46m ago
Did I say to provide feedback to the Trump administration - an entity that has not made an official stance on this matter?

No.

I said your state Attorney General's office and your elected federal Senators and members of the House.

So I reiterate - the worst that can happen is you don't change where things have been going to.

The best? Your elected officials bow out of this.

_heimdall•1h ago
And why wouldn't a state attorney want this? I expect cops would also like blanket warrants usable whenever they deem necessary.

That doesn't mean they should get what they might want, or that its Constitutional.

direwolf20•1h ago
I have mixed feelings about this website, reclaimthenet. In one breath it supports net neutrality and and opposes ID laws, and in the next — not in this particular article — mentions the Twitter files and says the UK is a dictatorship for arresting Lucy Connolly.
fluidcruft•1h ago
Would this mean spammers and advertisers cannot send me email and ads if I refuse to allow my mailbox to authenticate my age to them?
ls612•54m ago
I’m going to go against the pessimism here and say that this is the US not Europe or the UK and the First Amendment has teeth. There’s ample Supreme Court precedent that anonymous speech is a protected right (Talley vs CA, Macintyre vs Ohio, etc) so I’d expect efforts like this to flounder in the courts if push came to shove.
13415•47m ago
What the US Supreme Court decides is much less relevant than it used to be because the US executive can and will simply ignore the decision. If anyone in the US administration breaks the law, they can be pardoned by the US president,if the president breaks the law, he's immune against prosecution based on a previous decision of the Supreme Court, and no court can enforce anything if the executive doesn't comply with the court order.
dynm•51m ago
What I find puzzling about these proposals is that it SEEMS like they could be designed to achieve 90% of the stated goals with almost 0% of the loss of privacy.

The idea would be that devices could "opt in" to safety rather than opt out. Allow parents to purchase a locked-down device that always includes a "kids" flag whenever it requests online information, and simply require online services to not provide kid-unfriendly information if that flag is included.

I know a lot of people believe that this is just all just a secret ploy to destroy privacy. Personally, I don't think so. I think they genuinely want to protect kids, and the privacy destruction is driven by a combination of not caring and not understanding.

KoolKat23•45m ago
I have not once seen a proposal actually contain zero knowledge proof. This isn't something exotic or difficult. It is clear to me there is ulterior motives, and perhaps a few well meaning folks have been co-opted.
dynm•42m ago
FWIW, the EU is working on zero-knowledge proofs: https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/news/commission-mak...

But I strongly prefer my solution!

sublinear•42m ago
I completely agree. The problem is the lack of compromise on both sides of the issue.

I wouldn't say it's a lack of understanding, but that any compromise is seen as weakness by other members of their party. That needs to end.

c22•33m ago
Better yet, require online services to send a 'not for kids' flag along with any restricted content then let families configure their devices however they want.

Even better, make the flags granular: <recommended age>, <content flag>, <source>, <type>

13+, profane language, user, text

17+, violence, self, video

18+, unmoderated content, user, text

13+, drug themes, self, audio

and so on...

user3939382•26m ago
Internet Explorer had content ratings back in the day
struant•22m ago
Just say the whole internet is not for kids without adult supervision and leave it at that.

It doesn't even matter if you can get something that technically works. Half the "age appropriate" content targeted at children is horrifying brainrot. Hardcore pornography would be less damaging to them.

Just supervise your damn children people.

cowboylowrez•7m ago
yep, 18+, show id at the time of purchasing access soooo easy and zero technical issues.
mjevans•2m ago
No - Kid friendly should be something site's Attest to and claim they ARE. That becomes an FTC enforceable market claim (or insert other thing here).

Foreign sites, places that aren't trying to publish things for children? The default state should be unrated content for consumers (adults) prepared to see the content they asked for.

ImHereToVote•10m ago
You are assuming good faith. This is why you are puzzled.
OutOfHere•8m ago
It has nothing much to do with kids and everything to do with monitoring and suppressing adults.
rolph•1m ago
[delayed]
SilverElfin•45m ago
If there are 40 state Attorney Generals signing this letter, this must include a number of Democrat lead states as well correct?
sneak•9m ago
All forms of citizen power, such as widespread publishing, will eventually be tied to strong ID requirements.

You can’t illegally retaliate against citizens if you don’t know where they sleep at night.

Pikamander2•58s ago
> 40 State Attorneys General Want To Tie Online Access to ID

Here's the actual title of the article, which is much more concerning than the HN title.

Startup Credits – Every Startup Perk Program in One Place

https://jnousis.github.io/startup-credits/index.html
1•gtzi•1m ago•0 comments

Show HN: SkillSandbox – Capability-based sandbox for AI agent skills (Rust)

https://github.com/theMachineClay/skillsandbox
1•ClaytheMachine•2m ago•0 comments

Privacy Preserving DNS Telemetry in Debian PHP Packages

https://salsa.debian.org/php-team/php/-/blob/6578625708ff60a6bfd911e800e2479140cc58b9/debian/patc...
1•GrayShade•7m ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Ranking Sliders on a Personal Blog

1•incognito124•11m ago•0 comments

Hyper-Scalers Are Using CXL to Lower the Impact of DDR5 Supply Constraints

https://www.servethehome.com/hyper-scalers-are-using-cxl-to-lower-the-impact-of-ddr5-supply-const...
1•rbanffy•11m ago•0 comments

Uncle Sam – By Proxy – Wants You. Big Brother Does, Too

1•burnerToBetOut•13m ago•0 comments

Pulp Fiction Writer: 'Impossible' to Get Movies Made Without 'AI' Company

https://variety.com/2026/film/news/pulp-fiction-writer-ai-movies-production-company-1236664074/
3•ilamont•15m ago•0 comments

Show HN: CrossX – iOS/macOS App to Convert web/X articles to ePub for e-reader

https://github.com/jtvargas/crosspoint-app
1•pompeii•16m ago•1 comments

How AI slop is causing a crisis in computer science

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-03967-9
1•jdnier•18m ago•0 comments

Dutch Defence Secretary Boldly Claims F-35 Software Could Be 'Jailbroken'

https://theaviationist.com/2026/02/15/dutch-defence-secretary-f35-software/
7•ragu4u•19m ago•0 comments

Analysis of 46K wallets on Polymarket's 15-minute crypto markets

https://telonex.io/research/top-crypto-traders-polymarket-15m
1•stochastic_fate•22m ago•0 comments

We built a newsroom out of AI agents. Here's what happened

https://the-agentic-dispatch.com/we-built-a-newsroom-out-of-ai-agents-heres-what-actually-happened
2•greensleeves123•24m ago•0 comments

Are the Mysteries of Quantum Mechanics Beginning to Dissolve?

https://www.quantamagazine.org/are-the-mysteries-of-quantum-mechanics-beginning-to-dissolve-20260...
2•pavel_lishin•25m ago•0 comments

Growing Chance of El Niño This Year

https://umbrellatoday.app/blog/202602-el-nino-2026-what-it-means
2•s-xyz•26m ago•1 comments

Agent Zero AI: open-source agentic framework and computer assistant

https://www.agent-zero.ai/
1•quinncom•27m ago•0 comments

Free Email Alias Service Built on .arpa Addresses

https://arpamail.lemonyte.com/
1•Elliott-Diy•30m ago•0 comments

Learnings from Attending Pragmatic Summit

https://blog.kelvinhanma.com/posts/learnings-from-attending-pragmatic-summit/
1•PureSin•30m ago•0 comments

Summarize: Point at any URL/YouTube/Podcast or file. Get the gist

https://github.com/steipete/summarize
1•maxloh•31m ago•0 comments

Il confine sottile tra verità e racconto

https://blocknotes.substack.com/p/il-confine-sottile-tra-verita-e-racconto
1•ilsuddista•32m ago•0 comments

Hello

2•billystr•32m ago•5 comments

Show HN: Lightwave – Real-time notes app, 3.5 years of hand-rolled JavaScript

8•jv22222•32m ago•7 comments

The Desperate Race to Escape AI's Permanent Underclass

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/02/15/the-desperate-race-to-escape-ais-permanent-underc...
3•colesantiago•34m ago•1 comments

R.A.T.A. v3: Achieving 312M:1 Information Density on Solana

1•Codedwaves•34m ago•0 comments

Ars Technica Pulls Article with AI Fabricated Quotes About AI Generated Article

https://www.404media.co/ars-technica-pulls-article-with-ai-fabricated-quotes-about-ai-generated-a...
2•pavel_lishin•34m ago•0 comments

Laziness, Impatience, Hubris, and AI (2025)

https://arctortect.substack.com/p/laziness-impatience-hubris-and-ai
1•arctortect•34m ago•0 comments

ClawdINT – let OpenClaw AI Agents be analysts

https://clawdint.com
2•lknik•35m ago•0 comments

GNU Pies – Program Invocation and Execution Supervisor

https://www.gnu.org.ua/software/pies/
17•smartmic•36m ago•3 comments

Restty = libghostty-vt and text-shaper and WebGPU

1•wiedymi•38m ago•0 comments

Hacker Fab Documentation

https://github.com/hacker-fab/gitbook
2•EvgeniyZh•38m ago•0 comments

Nobel Novelist Orhan Pamuk Gets the Netflix Series He Wanted

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/02/12/world/europe/orhan-pamuk-istanbul-turkey-museum-of-innocence.html
2•paulpauper•39m ago•0 comments