frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Atlassian CEO: AI doesn't replace people here, but we're firing them anyway

https://www.heise.de/en/news/Atlassian-CEO-AI-doesn-t-replace-people-here-but-we-re-firing-them-anyway-11208758.html
90•layer8•1h ago

Comments

neogodless•1h ago
Related:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47343156 Atlassian to cut roughly 1,600 jobs in pivot to AI (reuters.com)

~yesterday, 273+ comments

bigwheels•1h ago
Also:

An important update on our team https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47342835 - Yesterday, 18 comments

bloppe•1h ago
I've become convinced that "investing in AI" is just the magic incantation CEOs are using to spin layoffs as a positive rather than a negative for the company's reputation among investors
apercu•1h ago
It's PR to cover management failure due to "me too", which reached ridiculous levels in the last 5 years.
lokar•46m ago
I don't see what it has to do with "me too"

Take block:

AFAICT, it was just really badly managed. A long time ago it got about as much share of its main market as it was going to get. They took the cash flow from that and hired a bunch more engineers to try to break into adjacent markets, and failed, and failed and failed.

Now they are just retreating to the steady income from their core business

afavour•43m ago
I don't really see any relevance to "me too". Far more likely it's to cover from insane overhearing in the pandemic era, and no one wants to admit they overdid it.
dv_dt•38m ago
I would guess the opposite, that anti-woke statements from management is a big red flag correlating with poor company performance
Bluescreenbuddy•29m ago
How is this in any way related to me too? How is that what to took from this? I implore you to think critically.
odshoifsdhfs•13m ago
You are being downvoted because of the 'me too', but think you are refering to companies copying other companies (Amazon hires 10k? We hire 10k! Google fires 5k? we fire 5k) and not the 'me too' movement about sexual assault/harrassement.
afavour•44m ago
Yup. I thought this was an interesting take on the Block layoffs, from a former employee:

"I Worked for Block. Its A.I. Job Cuts Aren’t What They Seem."

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/03/04/opinion/block-jack-dorsey...

mandeepj•5m ago
also -

"Salesforce CEO says Block's cuts shouldn't fuel worries of mass layoffs: 'That company has its own unique issues'" https://www.aol.com/articles/salesforce-ceo-says-blocks-cuts...

one more :-) -

https://gizmodo.com/sam-altman-says-companies-are-ai-washing...

ludicrousdispla•1h ago
steering wheel manufacturer lays off thousands in anticipation of self-driving cars
rootusrootus•57m ago
I really like this analogy, and I tend to think most analogies are contrived. This is spot on.
ilaksh•1h ago
> Cannon-Brookes emphasized in his blog post that Atlassian does not follow the philosophy of replacing people with AI. At the same time, he also stated, “It would be disingenuous to pretend AI doesn’t change the mix of skills we need or the number of roles required in certain areas. It does.”
salawat•59m ago
Passive voice. It's not the situation, it's the executive's chatted course of action in response to it. They are trying so hard to avoid any hint of culpability for the decision they are making. Laughable.
Ekaros•1h ago
When your customers have less developers you need yourself less developers. And if they are paying by the seat... Your income is directly affected by layoffs... So reduction does make sense.

And as they say any new companies can replace the Atlassian products by bespoke vibe coded alternatives in a few days...

NwtnsMthd•52m ago
That last sentence holds a lot of truth.

Our company has drastically downsized its dependence on Atlassian in the past month, we will be completely free in a few more. With the help of modern AI tools we've been able to replace their products with internal tools that are better tailored to our needs.

fred_is_fred•24m ago
I think any company with some motivated developers and a budget for h/w or cloud could rebuild a good enough JIRA in a month. I don't see how Atlassian survives long term
bombcar•17m ago
Jira isn't the product, it's the development platform that builds the product (which is a codified version of all the bad business decisions your company has ever made).
ebiester•10m ago
Because you see the IC side of the Atlassian toolkit. The management side is much more expansive and this starts mattering when you are coordinating larger projects.

That said, if you are a smaller company, you absolutely could kill Jira pretty quick.

hedora•21m ago
I last used Atlassian stuff about a decade ago.

Did they ever get around to fixing basic bugs like "Jira and Confluence use different markdown dialects"?

They've had a decade to address those sorts of obvious problems that bite 100% of the end users of their stuff, and apparently employed over 1600 people during that decade. That's 160 centuries of person time. I wonder what it was wasted on, if not making their fairly small core product suite usable.

I think we're going to see more and more incumbent companies with big moats and terrible products get replaced with vibe coded solutions over the next year or two.

bombcar•18m ago
No, they simplified it by cancelling almost all non-cloud instances and moved to being a direct per-seat SaaS, with (apparently) all the same bugs but fewer features.
jorvi•11m ago
Still feels weirdly inefficient.

Why have every company vibe code their own semi-good bespoke tool when instead one company can handcraft the tool with optimisations much better than AI can ever dream of, and then sell that tool for a reasonable markup. Especially if the tool is open source open core, so companies can PR improvements they think will be broadly applicable.

autoexec•51m ago
> “We are doing this to self-fund further investment in AI and enterprise sales while strengthening our financial profile,”

They take in billions every year but still come away with millions in negative income. I have no idea what their problem is but I'm pretty sure the 1,600 people they just fired weren't it. Throwing away people in yet another round of layoffs to further invest in AI is not a good sign.

toomuchtodo•42m ago
In my opinion, it is similar to Parkinson's Law [1] about work filling into the time given to it, but replace work with bureaucracy filling the aggregate enterprise revenue on offer. Atlassian's work, one might argue, is "done" but has such cashflow from business customers that they can continue to spend above and beyond what is needed to maintain what has been built to service their customer base. They could be 37signals/Basecamp, but they are enabled beyond that (from the business customer cashflows mentioned), and so these actions occur until an innovator comes along to replace them (and potentially, the cycle repeats due to enterprise sales cycle durations, inertia, etc).

You see this with all manner of large enterprise in my experience, where what they continue to do is "good enough" to allow for these inefficiencies and actions because they are, on some spectrum, "money printers" due to their moat and inertia. Creative destruction is not a forgone conclusion, nor fast. Is the incumbent exploring the problem spaces adjacent to their core business(es) to increase their TAM to increase shareholder value? Are they innovating? Or are they just churning and burning up revenue on meaningless work?

All of these companies doing layoffs to invest in AI is not about AI specifically, it is about reaching for profits and yield in a challenging business landscape and macro post zero interest rate policy ("ZIRP") imho. They are desperate for productivity growth, whether that is doing more with less people, AI, offshoring, whatever because money now has a cost.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_law

dasil003•5m ago
Have you looked at the actual expenses and where you think they should cut rather than people? Or are you saying with all those people they should be able to turn their growth story around?
ChrisArchitect•49m ago
[dupe] Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47343156
ddtaylor•9m ago
Literally couldn't figure out the anti-pattern for rejecting all of the cookies so I moved on.

Claude Code Auto Mode Lets the Agent Approve Its Actions – That's the Problem

https://grith.ai/blog/claude-code-auto-mode-vs-grith
2•edf13•1m ago•0 comments

Htmz – a low power tool for HTML

https://leanrada.com/htmz/
1•Tomte•1m ago•0 comments

Food Stamp Recipients Sue over Bans on Sugary Drinks

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/03/11/us/politics/usda-sued-snap-soda-ban.html
1•Alupis•1m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Two AI entities wouldn't write until we discussed their existence

https://github.com/wjcornelius/Claudefather/blob/main/THEY_ASKED_FIRST.md
1•BillCorOnBass•2m ago•0 comments

The Reason California Can't Build

https://www.theatlantic.com/economy/2026/03/california-housing-yimby-reforms/686334/
1•JumpCrisscross•3m ago•0 comments

Another Calif. company moves its HQ out of state, this time to Georgia

https://www.sfgate.com/california/article/yamaha-motor-headquarters-22062905.php
1•Alupis•3m ago•1 comments

Call for developers: Fossil for AI-agent dev

https://github.com/BenSiv/fossil-scm
1•bensiv•5m ago•1 comments

Virtual Math Museum

https://virtualmathmuseum.org/
1•narcraft•7m ago•0 comments

Claude Code Voice Mode

https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11101966-using-voice-mode
2•linolevan•8m ago•0 comments

Killing SaaS. Anatomy of a murder. How I replaced Wisprflow.ai with vibe coding

https://gpt3experiments.substack.com/p/killing-saas-the-anatomy-of-a-murder
1•nutanc•11m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: AI evaluation for an EV charger without additional installation?

1•chrisgd•11m ago•1 comments

Bubble Sorted Amen Break

https://parametricavocado.itch.io/amen-sorting
5•eieio•13m ago•1 comments

Show HN: A test harness that blocks unsafe AI actions before execution

1•celestinestudio•13m ago•0 comments

Grammarly Is Facing a Class Action Lawsuit over Its AI 'Expert Review' Feature

https://www.wired.com/story/grammarly-is-facing-a-class-action-lawsuit-over-its-ai-expert-review-...
1•laurex•14m ago•0 comments

If a web server runs websites then a corporation server? (2025)

https://interconnected.org/home/2025/03/13/homeostasis
2•alcazar•15m ago•0 comments

Linux Page Faults, MMAP, and userfaultfd for fast sandbox boot times

https://www.shayon.dev/post/2026/65/linux-page-faults-mmap-and-userfaultfd/
2•shayonj•15m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Cloud to Desktop in the Fastest Way

https://nativedesktop.com/
2•lasgawe•16m ago•0 comments

Software Maturity Wall

https://www.apolloacademy.com/software-maturity-wall/
1•akyuu•16m ago•0 comments

Fast and free coding agent written with Go

https://github.com/cheikh2shift/godex
1•cheikhshift•17m ago•0 comments

Show HN: PipeStep – Step-through debugger for GitHub Actions workflows

https://github.com/Photobombastic/pipestep
4•photobombastic•18m ago•2 comments

Apple's MacBook Neo makes repairs easier and cheaper than other MacBooks

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2026/03/more-modular-design-makes-macbook-neo-easier-to-fix-than-...
6•GeekyBear•19m ago•2 comments

An agentic workflow, March 2026 edition

https://twolongos.com/3/12/an-agentic-workflow-march-2026-edition/
2•suzzer99•19m ago•1 comments

Is your vet owned by private equity?

https://privateequityvet.org/vet-list/
4•hampelm•20m ago•0 comments

Show HN: LogClaw – Open-source AI SRE that auto-creates tickets from logs

https://logclaw.ai
5•Robelkidin•20m ago•0 comments

WikiCity – Where every building is a Wikipedia article

https://wikicity.app/
2•leononame•20m ago•1 comments

Harness Engineering

https://openai.com/index/harness-engineering/
4•jlas•20m ago•0 comments

A Day in the Life of an Enshittificator [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T4Upf_B9RLQ
2•KindAndFriendly•22m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Understudy – Teach a desktop agent by demonstrating a task once

https://github.com/understudy-ai/understudy
4•bayes-song•22m ago•0 comments

Inboxscan – find every subscription hiding in your email (runs locally)

https://github.com/LakshmiSravyaVedantham/inboxscan
2•sravyavedantham•22m ago•1 comments

Ask HN: In 2026, how do you share a list of URLs to the public (or friends)?

2•wenbin•24m ago•1 comments