frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

US cities are axing Flock Safety surveillance technology

https://www.cnet.com/home/security/when-flock-comes-to-town-why-cities-are-axing-the-controversial-surveillance-technology/
121•giuliomagnifico•1h ago

Comments

lenerdenator•1h ago
It really is amazing how they managed to fit so much copper into those devices.
therobots927•59m ago
Would be a shame if it became common knowledge.
Dezvous•49m ago
It's quite ironic to get an amazon ring video ad while viewing this article.
therobots927•41m ago
Ring is just as bad. Arguably worse because it comes with a convenience / personal security factor.
elphinstone•21m ago
An obnoxious, autoplay-at-full-volume ad that took the page an extra 30 seconds to load and somehow bypassed firefox adblockers...
josefritzishere•46m ago
Funny that. Not everyone wants to live in an open air prison.
jmuguy•43m ago
I'm surprised Garrett Langley still has a job, he seems wildly out of touch. For instance he really believes that his Panopticon as a service is the reason crime is down in cities, conveniently ignoring crime rates prior to COVID.
therobots927•41m ago
He won’t for long. The backlash is just getting started. Left or right, no one wants their whereabouts subject to constant surveillance.

His only advantage is that the cops are on his side and won’t let go of these cameras without a fight.

mlinhares•34m ago
Nah, he's just missing a good PR campaign, there's a 30% of the population that will eat whatever their supreme leaders say they should, I'm sure they can sanewash these cameras as well.
therobots927•24m ago
America is pretty polarized around privacy as demonstrated by reactions to the Snowden leaks. So I think that’s a fair point.
hrimfaxi•21m ago
That was over a decade ago. I wonder if it has gotten better or worse since.
ses1984•26m ago
No one wants their whereabouts subject to constant surveillance, except everyone who carries a “normal” cell phone, in other words not a burner.
therobots927•24m ago
Yes but you can always leave your phone behind if you want to drop off the map. Flock makes that borderline impossible.
hrimfaxi•23m ago
Do people who carry normal cell phones do so with the active desire to have their whereabouts subject to constant surveillance?
thinkingtoilet•40m ago
Does he really believe it or is it his job to say he really believes it?
everdrive•36m ago
Could he tell the difference?
Zigurd•32m ago
"Garrett Langley" sounds like what they renamed the villain in Le Mis for an American audience.
jdross•41m ago
I realize how unpopular flock is, and I will first say that I have literally never personally looked into the privacy concerns. But one city you don’t see named here is SF, which has cited Flock as a primary driver of its 10x reduction in car break-ins, and 30% reduction in burglaries. Those were a quality of life plague while I lived there
ceejayoz•37m ago
Crime's been descending from the COVID blip for a while, everywhere, Flock or otherwise. My city saw zero murders in Q1; 2021 saw ~15 by now.

In other words: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSVqLHghLpw

BoggleOhYeah•20m ago
Any evidence that the reduction is actually due to the cameras?
MisterTea•17m ago
> which has cited Flock as a primary driver of its 10x reduction in car break-ins, and 30% reduction in burglaries

Are there reports or studies released which explains how the flock system influenced these reductions?

phendrenad2•37m ago
It's funny, if the company had just sold cameras to cities, they probably could have avoided this whole mess. But they just had to hit some keywords for Wall Street (like "AI" "cloud" and "SaaS"), which had the side-effect of making it appear (true or not) that they were part of a Palantir-style surveillance panopticon that tracks you everywhere.
alex43578•3m ago
A big part of the value is the network: track a stolen a car or a suspect in the next town over, or across the country.
e2le•36m ago
For those unfamiliar, you can read more about the flock safety cameras themselves here:

https://consumerrights.wiki/w/Flock_license_plate_readers

And more about the company behind the cameras:

https://consumerrights.wiki/w/Flock_Safety

gosub100•33m ago
Someone in my hometown was arrested for vandalizing them. The media chose to say "city owned security camera". It's amazing how they will rush to defend private enterprise.
Zigurd•30m ago
Legacy local news is highly dependent on the police for content and access. No surprise.
waNpyt-menrew•27m ago
Would crime go up, down or stay the same if all surveillance cameras were removed? The answer to that is the only one that matters.

Ironically many people who whine about surveillance cameras have their video door bells or similar setups.

So which is it?

macintux•26m ago
Crime would go down if everyone was executed. Your question is not the only one that matters.
hrimfaxi•25m ago
No it's not. Would crime go up, down, or stay the same if we had to get strip searched before entering airplanes?
waNpyt-menrew•24m ago
The types of crime that would happen in an airplane would already be identifiable due to its constrained cabin, so I don’t understand the comparison.

Let’s use your example for say a concert. Is checking bags worth it? Would crime go up if there was no bag check? Why or why not?

ceejayoz•10m ago
> Is checking bags worth it?

Probably not. It's mostly there to preserve the profits from alcohol sales.

> Would crime go up if there was no bag check?

Did it go down when they added them?

ceejayoz•19m ago
I mean, that depends on whether you consider the warrantless, disproportionate search a crime.

It should be!

RankingMember•23m ago
> The answer to that is the only one that matters.

Is it, though? Crime would be super low if we were all confined to prison cells by default, too.

waNpyt-menrew•22m ago
For a tech forum the rebuttals are terrible. I expected better. Cameras do not confine one to a prison cell.
ceejayoz•18m ago
> For a tech forum the rebuttals are terrible.

Physician, heal thyself!

RankingMember•12m ago
You made a broad-brush statement that essentially justified anything in the name of safety. You might want to re-word your statement if you meant otherwise.
throwway120385•16m ago
There are ways of doing this that don't require you to abdicate all of your privacy to a third-party SaaS company who makes it easy to share information with the police everywhere.

My camera system is not connected to the cloud and it has a retention policy of 4 weeks. I took pains not to aim them anywhere where I'd be collecting data outside of my own property. There's full-disk encryption in use. The police could maintain their own surveillance network and place their own cameras in a legally compliant way and it would be fine.

Flock and Ring are awful because they enable easy surveillance and search after the fact, not a priori because they are surveillance systems. If they required proof of warrant before letting the police execute a search I think a lot of people would be more comfortable with them. A police officer stalking an ex is like the basic example you get if you ask an ALPR vendor why we need audit logging and proactive auditing of all searches. But that's not the only way these tools enable invasion of privacy.

If you want proof that that's the problem with them, you should know that people have been building wired camera systems and ALPR systems for decades before Flock and Ring came into existence. So it's solely the cloud Search-as-a-Service business model that's the problem there.

gorgonical•26m ago
Musician-turning-tech anarchist (?) Benn Jordan is making a very interesting series of videos about Flock cameras, their poor safety, and their gray-area interfacing with local governments:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMIwNiwQewQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uB0gr7Fh6lY

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vU1-uiUlHTo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pp9MwZkHiMQ

I recommend them.

boriskourt•21m ago
Super worth a watch. Lots of technical tidbits also.
waNpyt-menrew•20m ago
Someone complaining about local governments having data while directing them to YouTube, whose owner does surveillance at a scale far exceeding all local governments of all countries combined, is ironic.

Why don’t these people use Peertube at least. Fact of the matter is they’d like to personally profit off the same nonsense they complain about. This person has a million subscribers, they aren’t some random whistleblower. It’s a job, like all media, generating outrage.

If all of them used peertube maybe we’d have a solid competitor.

ceejayoz•17m ago
https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/we-should-improve-society-som...
puppykito•17m ago
???

It is very clearly because YouTube has a higher reach than any other platform in that space.

baggachipz•14m ago
I drove into a very affluent subdivision this weekend, and like most others around here it had a flock camera recording every car on the way in. This camera, however, had the gall to advertise its presence as a neighborhood security measure. "Flock Safety watches this neighborhood" read the sign on the post, or some such. Of course the residents there had no choice but to accept its installation, as the local police support it. Nefarious framing and marketing in the name of "safety".
bradleyankrom•3m ago
I saw the same thing in a Home Depot parking lot yesterday. I guess I'm glad there's some sort of notice about it, even if its intent is more, I dunno, branding? It took me a while to figure out what all the solar panel + camera on a post installations were as they popped up around my town. I even pulled over to inspect the hardware for signs of ownership and didn't find anything.

Artemis II: Integrity completes its first return trajectory correction burn

https://www.nasa.gov/blogs/missions/2026/04/07/artemis-ii-flight-day-7-first-return-correction-bu...
1•Bubble1296•42s ago•0 comments

Two Years of Valkey

https://redmonk.com/sogrady/2026/04/06/valkey-at-two/
1•j03b•1m ago•0 comments

Claude Code Usage Dashboard

https://github.com/phuryn/claude-usage
1•neamar•1m ago•0 comments

An interactive map of river basins and watersheds of North and South America

https://python-maps-vis.vercel.app
1•alphabetatango•1m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Embenx – agentic memory layer for AI agents

https://github.com/adityak74/embenx
1•akarnam37•3m ago•0 comments

The Abbey That Fueled Scotland's Street Violence and Saved the Bees

https://www.governance.fyi/p/the-abbey-that-fueled-scotlands-street
1•bigbobbeeper•3m ago•0 comments

Thoughts on Slowing the Fuck Down

https://mariozechner.at/posts/2026-03-25-thoughts-on-slowing-the-fuck-down/#toc_5
2•lebek•4m ago•0 comments

Giving AI coding agents a Principal Engineer's mind and cost of intern

https://github.com/juyterman1000/entroly
1•abbyedd•4m ago•1 comments

Pine Trees – A 1,400-line private reflection harness for Claude instances

https://github.com/Habitante/pine-trees
2•daniel-navarro•5m ago•1 comments

92% of MCP servers have security issues (and how to fix it)

https://github.com/arbitusgateway/arbitus
3•nicholasfvelten•8m ago•0 comments

Convert Temperature and Humidity to Solar Radiation and Heat Flux with FiaPhy

https://github.com/fiaos-org/FiaPhy
1•openrockets•9m ago•0 comments

Frontier AI models are the most cost-efficient

https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.03834
2•mzelling•9m ago•0 comments

AI Sycophancy: The Yes-Man Problem

https://the-infrastructure-mindset.ghost.io/ai-sycophancy-the-yes-man-problem/
1•wphillipmoore•9m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Emotional probes for Gemma 4 – Replicating Anthropic's emotion research

https://github.com/RyanCodrai/emotional-probes
1•justsomeguy1996•10m ago•1 comments

TorchTPU: Running PyTorch Natively on TPUs at Google Scale

https://developers.googleblog.com/torchtpu-running-pytorch-natively-on-tpus-at-google-scale/
1•markerbrod•10m ago•0 comments

Is software support the real expiration date of modern electronics?

https://borisljevar.substack.com/p/the-climate-crisis-illusion-of-action
1•blnlx•10m ago•0 comments

Software job openings surge this year, defying AI fears

https://www.businessinsider.com/ai-isnt-killing-software-coding-jobs-booming-trueup-2026-4
1•b-man•10m ago•1 comments

Why Microsoft's war on Windows' Control Panel is taking so long

https://www.theverge.com/news/908624/microsoft-windows-control-panel-removal-explanation
2•rpgbr•10m ago•0 comments

Iran demands Bitcoin fees for ships passing Hormuz during ceasefire

https://www.ft.com/content/02aefac4-ea62-48db-9326-c0da373b11b8
2•pavlov•12m ago•1 comments

Gym-Anything: Turn Any Software into an Agent Environment

https://cmu-l3.github.io/gym-anything/
2•wellecks•12m ago•0 comments

Why some California homeowners feel trapped in houses they want to leave

https://www.sfgate.com/california/article/gains-taxes-california-housing-22183896.php
2•stevenwoo•12m ago•1 comments

Show HN: We fingerprinted 178 AI models' writing styles and similarity clusters

https://rival.tips/research/model-similarity
2•nuancedev•12m ago•0 comments

A security scanner as fast as a linter – written in Rust

https://github.com/peaktwilight/foxguard
1•peaktwilight•13m ago•0 comments

App that fixes what is broken

https://career-journey-mvp.vercel.app/
1•TheHRPassionGuy•14m ago•0 comments

Artemis II astronauts wake up to the voice of Apollo 13 commander Jim Lovell [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zp2Yg3VBlsE
1•voxadam•15m ago•0 comments

Friendship Recession

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friendship_recession
1•futurecat•16m ago•0 comments

AI Generates Files. Who Manages Them?

https://filesfirst.substack.com/p/your-ai-generates-files-who-manages
1•ilian•17m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Exp / Desktop App to simply convert

https://getexpi.app
1•philematic•17m ago•0 comments

Show HN: RaptorCI – Catch risky code changes and weak tests before they ship

https://getraptorci.com/
1•jcarroll24•17m ago•0 comments

Universe to You – Everything Explained. Probably

https://scrollytelling.ai/universe-to-you/
1•thunderbong•18m ago•0 comments