Ask HN: Are LLMs Just Philosophical Zombies?

2•slipknotfan•1h ago

The whole point of LLMs is to fake being human through following the likely paths text will follow. Is that not what a philosophical zombie[0] is: appearing to be human while having no actual intelligence?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie

Comments

Trasmatta•1h ago

> appearing to be human while having no actual intelligence?

Isn't a P-zombie about consciousness, not intelligence?

jqpabc123•1h ago

It's not actually "artificial intelligence" but more like "fake intelligence".

Assembling a plausible sounding sentence doesn't mean that you know what you're talking about.

The number of people who fail to grasp this is mind boggling.

pixel_popping•59m ago

And how do you explain that they can do advanced mathematics?

jqpabc123•5m ago

How do you explain the fact that sometimes they can't? If they *really* understand math, why is the error rate so high?

According to a 2025 Stanford HAI report, large language models fail basic multi-step arithmetic up to 40% of the time without external tools.

https://medium.com/@dojolabs.main/why-does-ai-get-math-wrong...

Show IH: Knowledge Core

Show HN: Nimble.css minimal classless CSS library for great-looking default HTML

ChatGPT vs. a specialized medical AI on 5 clinical cases (verbatim outputs)

Show HN: Reducing a 66-node dependency cycle to 13 in Scrapy

High Intensity Functional Training in Hybrid Competitions: A Scoping Review

Browser using agents relying on expensive residential proxies?

Anthropic: Using large language models to scale scalable oversight

Show HN: Turning a Gaussian Splat into a Videogame

'Staggering' number of people believe unproven claims about vaccines, raw milk

Teaching AI models to say "I'm not sure"

The Sycophancy Problem: Why your AI is a Polite Liar (and how to fix it)

A 95%-accurate AI agent fails 64% of the time on 20-step tasks

Paperback – generative UI, rendered on device – no pixel stream, no server GPU

Mike Stonebraker Turing Award Winner: Postgres, Disagreeing with Google [video]

Bitwarden CLI Compromised in Ongoing Checkmarx Supply Chain

Pentagon wants $54B for drones, more than most nations' military budgets

Show HN: Gova, a declarative GUI framework for Go

Show HN: Claude Code skills for building LLM evals

OpenAI website has a full timeline of Elon Musk-related events

How to hit your Claude weekly limit so you can go outside and touch grass

The Library Freedom Project

Scripting macOS Image Playground to Create Game Assets for Free and Locally

Medical data of half a million Britons listed for sale on Chinese website

A Manager's Guide to Reducing AI Costs Without Reducing Headcount

Low-plastic diet&urinary levels of plastic-associated phthalates&bisphenols

Show HN: Lilith-zero update: fast Rust security for agents

OK Google, make middle school suck more

Your Name in Landsat

Making Rust Workers reliable: panic and abort recovery in WASM‑bindgen

Uefa plans to offer Champions League streaming service direct to fans